Abby continues her story of the Silent Twins, June and Jennifer Gibbons, and their later lives and time in Broadmoor Hospital for the Criminally Insane. Ashlyn talks about the incredibly sad story of Cierra Breland and the abusive relationship that led to her disappearance. This episode has everything: pronunciations for Hozier, bags of doom, empty…

Abby talks about the very silent and very interesting Gibbons sisters, June and Jennifer, and their infamous love-hate relationship, codependent childhoods, and made-up secret language. Ashlyn discusses the depraved and horrifying violence that took place in Imperial Japan during WW2 under Unit 731. This episode has everything: An engaging surprise…

Abby continues her trek through the Appalachian’s with creepy stories from the folks who’ve hiked it. Ashlyn talks about the man who killed his family twice, Gregory Green, his victims, and the heroic Faith Green. This episode has everything: a couple of smooth disc jockeys, small world stories, conversational birth control, some *ahem* personal mo…

Abby dives deep into the very strange and creepy legend and lore of the ancient Appalachian Mountain region. Ashlyn talks about the infamous and horrifying mass shooting at Columbine High School. This episode has everything: car trouble, Ashlyn’s five cents, hairstyles appropriate for the Appalachian Trail, some very eligible cryptids, and the wors…

Abby talks about the wild and chaotic case of the disappearance of Walter Collins and those he left behind. Ashlyn tells the harrowing and absolutely incredible story of Mary Vincent and the horrific attack she survived. This episode has everything: gaslighting cats, a tinder date with a cryptid, a lot of money in the 1920s, Ashlyn’s GD allergy med…

Things get real weird for our 69th episode! Abby covers the strange story of the Glasgow Ice Cream Truck chaos that ended in a horrific act of arson. Ashlyn covers the infamous tale of the Kray brothers, Ronald and Reginald, who terrorized London for decades. This episode has everything: creamy milk, a new clown in town, how to superglue your whole…

Were back! And we kick things off in a big way! Abby dives deep into the creepy history of the infamous and… handsome… very haunted Robert the Doll. Then, Ashlyn covers the tumultuous tale of Elmer McCurdy, the story of a man that only begins with his death. This episode has everything: No new shoes, a description of the most handsome doll in the w…

Abby dives into the mystery of three lighthouse keepers that disappeared under strange circumstances from one of the Flannan Isles of Scotland in 1900. Ashlyn talks about the illustrious and violent life of the infamous female Chinese pirate known as Zheng Yi Sao. This episode has everything: a summary of ghost hunting, ✨giving✨ the Ring video, a r…

Abby talks about the creepy real-life-not-the-Will-Smith-movie urban legend of the Men in Black. Then, Ashlyn talks about a horrific piece of human garbage, Carl Panzram. This episode has everything: selfish Taco bastards, the reigning urban legends, the “S” word, the difference between “robbery” and “burglary”, and a tift with Taft. Thanks for lis…

Strap in for uncontrollable laughter as Abby talks about one of the most famous and credible UFO sightings and the abduction of Betty and Barney Hill. Then, Ashlyn talks about a love triangle that had a horrific ending with her story of the murder of Katelynn Stone. This episode has everything: a little bout of tuberculosis, a notch away from Orion…

Abby gets real weird this week with the infamously strange happenings of the Bennington Triangle in Vermont. Ashlyn finishes up her story about Charles Manson, talking about his later life as the leader of a cult, and the murders he and his cult are known for. This episode has everything: a generic happy birthday for everybody, the only thing that …

Abby tells the story of Carla Yellow Bird’s murder, and her amazing aunt Lissa who found answers. Ashlyn dives into part one of her story on Charles Manson, beginning with his terrible early years. This episode has everything: a summary of birthday festivities, a skedaddler, a dramatic opening line, Manson in a McMansion, and something we need on a…

Sign the petition here to help urge the search for Marcedes Myran, Morgan Beatrice Harris & Buffalo Woman! https://www.change.org/p/search-the-prairie-green-and-brady-landfills-of-winnipeg-for-our-mmiw Abby talks about Canada’s latest serial killer and the indigenous women he targeted. Ashlyn deep dives into the history and ghosts of the infamously…

This week Abby finishes her story on the OG Mama’s Boy Ed Gein, talking about his victims and supposed victims, and the terrifying collection of things found in his farmhouse. Ashlyn talks about a famous English mystery: the story of an unnamed skeleton found within a tree. This episode has everything: the purchasing power of 1953 dollars, why all …

This episode has everything: Abby begins part one of her story of the most deviant serial killer in Wisconsin history, Ed Gein. Ashlyn talks about the dark history, ghosts and lore of Philadelphia’s Eastern State Penitentiary. This episode has everything: lovable idiots, the Norman Bates of it all, a weird smirk, the anti-doppelgänger, a life sente…

Abby talks about a creepy viral photo, the boy in it that went missing, and the lore of changelings. Ashlyn talks about the utterly horrifying “Soap Maker” of Italy, Leonarda Cianciulli. This episode has everything: the P-Man/Urinator, an offended red head, a great accidental accent, a strange connection to a bearded dragon, a self fulfilling proph…

Abby talks about a creepy house in L.A., and the horrific murder that took place there. Ashlyn dives deep into the sad story of a group of cavers at Mossdale Caverns. This episode has everything: what we hoped for this week, more Kool-Aid man impressions, squirrel enemies, Architect Harry Weiner, cave movie talk, and a word you can’t say the right …

Abby tells the mysterious tale of Finland’s most famous unsolved case, the Lake Bodom murders. Ashlyn talks about the world’s scariest grandma, Nannie Doss. This episode has everything: jealousy over a pink drink, hair licking, bird watching at 6 A.M., Agent boob guy, the grandmother card, the overkiller, and Nannie Doss: *Life insurance agencies h…

Abby sinks her teeth into the lore and dark history of vampires in New Orleans. Ashlyn talks about the recent case update on the murder of Pamela Conyers, and the possibly related case of Catherine Cesnik. This episode has everything: out of this world fan art, a miniature mug with questionable intended use, horrifying German accents, Ashlyn’s true…

Abby tells the story of Teresita Basa, a story where paranormal and true crime meet and a voice from the grave may have solved a cold case. Ashlyn talks about the very recent, and extraordinarily heinous, murder of model and influencer Abby Choi. This episode has everything: a note for Noodles & Co., the special ingredient at Krispy Kreme, bad vibe…

Abby tells the strange story of obsession surrounding the death of Cari Farver. Ashlyn takes us to Scotland for the history and ghosts of Glamis Castle. This episode has everything: some tonsil talk, a special viewing for Patreon, a “humble” castle, an utterly livable place, dabbing on a ghost, and the biggest secret in the parlor that we can’t tel…

This week Abby gives you a huge dose of weird with her story of two mysterious children from 1100s England. Ashlyn tells the tragic and horrible story of Virginia’s Colonial Parkway Murders. This episode has everything: Second-grade tae kwon do, an Instagram Live seance, an Aeropostale tangent, neon rave clothing in 1100s England, children who forg…

Abby talks about the strange and mysterious history of Sarah Winchester’s mansion. Ashlyn talks about the startlingly scary cryptid that came out of artificial intelligence: Loab. This episode has everything: circus outfit plans, the welcome package in Virginia, the Finders Keepers War, justice for robots, a coconut with facial features, and “Screa…

Abby talks about the murder spree that occurred on the University of Florida campus in 1990. Ashlyn tells another tragic story of family annihilation. This episode has everything: news in the art of crochet, the Big 4 when it comes to hallucinations, a South Jersey IT guy, and the worst brothers ever. Thanks for listening!! Love the show? Support u…

It’s episode 50, y’all! This week Abby covers the story of the mysterious disappearance of college sophomore, Bryce Laspisa. Then, Ashlyn discusses some dated medical practices that will have you cringing. This episode has everything: amazing cookies, Tina Bonecher taking a tumble, cow to blood transfusions, a new way to use tobacco, generically ri…

It’s our one year anniversary episode! Abby and Ashlyn tackle the recent tragic true crime story of the murders of Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin. This episode has everything: what we’ll be doing when we’re 95, an extra sad sadsquatch, and a grade-A moron. Thanks for listening!! Love the show? Support us on Patreon…

Abby dives into the massively creepy urban legend of the Black-Eyed Children. Ashlyn covers the mysterious story of Bageshwar’s episode of Mass Hysteria in India. This episode has everything: Burger King, the Black-Eyed Peas and BTK, who’s behind the horrible clothing at Target, a beautiful way to put something terrifying, a black-eyed children enc…

It’s Christmas in the I Scream Parlour! First, Abby pulls out the Christmas Eve true crime story of a family torn apart by a suspicious house fire: the Missing Sodder Children. Then, Ashlyn will knock your stockings off with her tales of Krampus, Belsnickel, Perchta, and the Icelandic Yule Lads. This episode has everything: a cold miser and a heat …

Abby wraps up her story of the Yuba County 5, explaining the known facts about the case and exploring the theories that surround it. Ashlyn talks about the strange and bizarre story of Frida Sofia, a little girl in need of rescue after an earth quake in Mexico City. This episode has everything: sequin flapper dresses, unreasonable reasonable theori…

Abby covers part one of the maddening story of the Yuba County 5, a snowy mystery that’s been dubbed “America’s Dyatlov Pass.” Ashlyn tells the utterly horrifying story of neglect that led to the death of Lacey Fletcher. This episode has everything: technology that’s too smart, some 70s snacks, a search team for a search team, terrible psychic advi…

Abby teaches a lesson in demons and cursed books that nobody asked for: Demonology 101. Ashlyn dives deep into the tale of Danielle Harkins, who secretly met with a group of students for a demon-driven ritual. This episode has everything: two days of turkey, a million logo designs, naming dogs after demons, whether snakes are all tail or all body, …

Abby covers the highly requested legend and history of India’s most haunted structure, the Bhangahr Fort. Ashlyn dives into the infuriating mystery of Minnesota’s missing news anchor, Jodi Huisentruit. This episode has everything: a request for feedback from YOU our listeners, uncooperative joke telling, tales of ghost hunting, our favorite ghost a…

Abby tells the hard to believe, and equally hard to stomach, story of Franklin Delano Floyd and his victims. Ashlyn talks about the messy and corrupt life and crimes of Alex Murdaugh. This episode has everything: Victorian and jaundice tans, a big old weirdo, the worst names to pick as aliases, breaking out of jail like it’s no big deal, the job fi…

Things get spooky in our Halloween episode! Abby(Annabelle) starts out with the story of - you guessed it - Annabelle the Doll! The original demonic “it” gorl and fear-mongering spooky doll-child of Ed and Lorraine Warren. Then, strap in for a mystery a la Abby from Ashlyn who pulled off the “Abby” look better than Abby does! Ashlyn tells the story…

Abby tells the spine-chilling tale of the real-life haunting of the Perron Family that inspired the film the Conjuring. Ashlyn shares the lore, legend, and historical accuracy of the Bunny Man story of Northern Virginia. This episode has everything: a Skeleton Key impression, a carrot candle, a jinx, a story that makes Ashlyn visibly upset, spirits…

Abby brings the nightmare fuel with her story of the terrifying phenomenon that is Spontaneous Human Combustion. Ashlyn dives deep into the panic-inducing Chicago murders caused by cyanide-laced Tylenol. This episode has everything: faucets that work, why we’re gonna get cancelled, coronary vs. culinary arts, sparks flying on a hot date, more specu…

Abby continues the super weird story of the Montauk Project with part 2, strap in for mind control, time travel, and nazi gold. Ashlyn gets real creepy this week with tales of actual real zombies among us. This episode has everything: a wise ass, an ideas guy, more twilight references, thinking food into existence, music from a fun guy, wearing an …

Abby begins part one of the swirling story of conspiracy weirdness that inspired Stranger Things, the Montauk Project. Ashlyn follows up with the actual confirmed and declassified weirdness that is the MKUltra CIA program. This episode has everything: koala-tee hugs, adding “von” to Abby’s name, an eerie flash mob, lab-or-a-tory vs. labra-tory, who…

Abby tells the extremely creepy story of the possessions and hauntings the Ammons Family experienced. Ashlyn tells the depraved story of the horrific Toy Box Killer, David Parker Ray. This episode has everything: adult twins that still wear matching clothing, reverse uniforms, demon attachment vs. skincare, tricky words to say, closet monsters, pro…

Stories submitted by our listeners Emma, Damon, and Frena. These stories have everything: a disappearing cradle, a thirsty ghost, a pretty rehearsed little girl, and some ghostly head pats. Thank you for your submissions! If you have a story to share, please email us at iscreamsocialpod@gmail.com Support the Show.…

Abby gets real weird with the brain-melting story of Andrew Basiago, who claims to be a Project Pegasus time traveler. Ashlyn tells the incredibly sad and horrific story of Junko Furuta. This episode has everything: tequila and assault, an obnoxiously long alumni tshirt, an illiterate actress, what to do when your Tesla dies, the worst parents ever…

Abby wraps up part two of the Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders. Ashlyn tells the heartbreaking, timely story of the Kiely Rodni case. This episode has everything: Abby fan-girling over a paranormal tv star, a giant pencil balloon, a low bar for what makes someone likable, how to eat an elephant, dogs with a vow, a couple The Office references, a big ol’…

This week Abby dives into part one of the horrific slayings of 3 young girls at a Girl Scout camp in Oklahoma. Ashlyn talks about one of the weirdest missing persons cases ever, the story of Lula Cora Hood. This episode has everything: wedding venue requirements, school jokes, horse camp, one story with excruciating detail and one without, mushroom…

This week Abby dives into the historically accurate, and not so accurate, lore surrounding the infamous Myrtle’s Plantation. Ashlyn takes us to Colonial Williamsburg for the plethora of hauntings frequently experienced there. This episode has everything: two sick hosts, the long distance running symptom, wannabe boy scouts, a bashful performer, the…

This week Abby tells the absolutely horrific story of the Elizabeth Bathory of New Orleans: Delphine LaLaurie. Ashlyn talks about the spooky history and lingering hauntings of Virginia’s St. Alban’s Sanatorium. This episode has everything: a joke with two punchlines, a party next to a party, a Nicholas Cage impression, the alternative Rocker room, …

It’s our 30th episode and we’ve got a doozy of an episode for you creeps! Ashlyn talks about the very goosebump-inducing lore of the shape-shifting malevolent skinwalker. Abby follows up with the story of Skinwalker Ranch, where you better keep an eye out for UFOs and protect your cattle. This episode has everything: personal life AND social media …

Abby continues her story of the Alaska Triangle, focusing on aliens and UFO sightings in the area. Ashlyn explains the quirky legend of the creepy Bunyip, her spirit cryptid. This episode has everything: packing for an EDM concert, Stranger Things but make it real life, friendly neighborhood aliens, fish tank UFOs, a bunyip smoking a cigarette, an …

Abby talks about the Alaska Triangle where 16,000 PEOPLE have gone MISSING since 1988!!! Ashlyn tells the story of the worlds youngest serial killer, Amarjeet Sada. This episode has everything: traumatic pet stories from childhood, the stories that haunt us, Ashlyn’s favorite word, otter noises, weird google searches, hating a child, someone who’s …

This week Abby tells the story of a Utah family that was found dead in their home, having left behind to-do lists as if they were going on vacation. Ashlyn continues with Part 2 of her story of the human pile of garbage that was the infamous John Wayne Gacy. This episode has everything: the dead of fall, Let’s Summon Demons: the game, more proof th…

This week Abby tells the story of a group of Russian hikers that met a terrifying and mysterious end in what’s known as the Korovina Group Incident. Ashlyn begins part one of the story of John Wayne Gacy’s infamous life and reign of terror. This episode has everything: bratwurst jokes, serious Dyatlov Pass vibes, a reason to go to the gym, John Way…