In this second installment of “Mirror World” Anna and Andrew open wide for a haunting glimpse into dental related scares! - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - t…

Everyone's got eclipse on the brain, so Anna & Andrew explore some ways different cultures made sense of the eclipse, then cap it off with some spooky ideas for things that could happen. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter …

Andrew’s recent trip to Australia inspires today’s deep dive into the science and folklore surrounding the sky’s spookiest little (and sometimes big) critter: the BAT. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @s…

Anna & Andrew propel into a wild true story about the unexpected overlap between occult rituals and NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitt…

Anna & Andrew wriggle in the wide world of monstrous worms, from the Gobi Desert to a sink hole in Kansas. - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk…

Anna and Andrew workshop a new segment called “Mirror World,” this time exploring paranormal activity in kitchens and also the terror of delivery-only restaurants! - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scary…

Anna and Andrew take in a dip in the world of wet ghosts: including Seaweed Charlie, a frozen ghost ship and a haunted pond called “Haunted Pond." - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Tw…

Anna and Andrew explore the urban legend surrounding San Antonio’s “Donkey Lady Bridge” and touch on other bridge ghosts before discussing what animals their souls would be fused to should the occasion arise. - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagra…

Anna and Andrew explore some of humanity’s most unlucky individuals, including a solitary lotto loser, a park ranger lightning magnet and a woman named Jeanne. - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on I…

In yet another installment of “Tiny Scary Things” Anna and Andrew read gentle listener accounts of babies seeing into the beyond and the ghost of a wily hamster named Houdini. - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @sca…

In this ep, Anna and Andrew unpack the shockingly recent origins of those pesky, technologically disruptive critters known as "gremlins." - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MER…

Anna and Andrew read a listener submission about Exploding Head Syndrome and other phenomena. Also Andrew shares a shocking previously undisclosed sleep-related fact about himself. - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod -…

Anna and Andrew ring in the leap year fittingly with a leaping villain/real criminal/supernatural penny dreadful who terrorized London in the 1830’s with…parkour? - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod o…

Anna and Andrew crack the spine on a morbid book of maps of infamous Hollywood events, which reveals different levels of coolness depending on whether Andrew is holding it. Plus, a gentle listener tale has us all playing a round of "Angel or Janitor?" - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Tw…

Anna and Andrew spend too long talking about medical horrors to scare the 20-somethings in the crowd before diving into the possibly last undiscussed Christmas Horror, and yes, he wears a hat. Then they dive into a listener submitted tale that leads to a game of "Angel or Janitor?" - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @th…

Anna and Andrew read a listener submitted tale about a grave phone call then weigh in on supernatural Reddit photos. - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.pub/lic/bdCk…

In today’s ep, Anna and Andrew check in to the infamous creepypasta “The Keyhole” and discuss just what’s so scary about motels. - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod on Instagram & Twitter MERCH - tee.…

Get your Thanksgiving prep work done while Anna and Andrew dig into this iconic food related campfire story “Tailypo” and discuss another spooky Appalachian entity. - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter Follow The Pod - @scarystory_pod…

Anna and Andrew unearth the true tale of a cursed ring that may have inspired one of the most enduring fantasy novels of all time, and follow it up with a listener email about a haunted dormitory. - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Instagram & Twitter …

Anna and Andrew are BACK with some special Halloween eps! In this one, they catch up on the past year and read the Reddit tale of haunted babydoll along with a harrowing encounter with Black Eyed Children. Scary! - Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish on Instagram & Twitter Follow Anna - @annadrezen on Inst…

As you consolidate your leftover candy and put away your Halloween decorations, allow Anna and Andrew to share some crucial intel on mummies, both real and imaginary, then bring it home with a character study of Mr. Dark from Ray Bradbury’s “Something Wicked This Way Comes. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices…

Anna and Andrew unleash some of your own spooky submissions in this special Halloween ep, including a witchy bookstore, a haunted laboratory and a first date interrupted by a cult! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoicesBy Forever Dog

Reconnecting with their roots in “teenage hooooer,” Andrew reads the classic urban legend “Tap Tap Tap” and unpacks the history of Lovers’ Lanes in America and Anna shares a brand new segment involving an upsetting character from Stephen King’s “The Stand.” Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices…

We all know Spooky Isn't Seasonal, but this Halloween we thought we'd serve you gentle listeners a long overdue surprise... and a bit of greb. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoicesBy Forever Dog

In their finale episode, Anna and Andrew struggle to think of a way to say goodbye, so instead they read the last remaining Scary Story to Tell In the Dark, "BA-ROOM" and talk about mean funeral songs, bald celebs, gifted astrologists and one more greb & bride of a much older, very rich man for the road. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdC…

Anna and Andrew read a listener’s tale of a mysterious baby cry and chat about the ghostliness of babies, crying and TikTok. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus: http://foreverdogpodcasts.com/plus FOL…

In this grab bag of an episode, Anna and Andrew read a farewell from Son of Owl Dad, a mother’s “The Mummy” memory and a chilling dermatological tale. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus: http://forev…

In this one for the books, Anna and Andrew read a shocking story submitted by Mara Wilson, about a train-hating, inn-keeping, cow-avenging murder suspect (and ghost) named Prissy. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on F…

In this jam-packed ep, Anna and Andrew recall the ethical horror of a certain anatomical exhibit of the 00’s and read a listener tale of an HR related curse! For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus: http:…

Inspired by a listener’s true mind bender of a tale, Anna and Andrew discuss the supernatural nature of telephones, wrong numbers and technology in general. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus: http:/…

In this mouthy episode, Anna and Andrew read “The Teeth” then discuss the horror of veneers, walking home and Steve Harvey. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus: http://foreverdogpodcasts.com/plus FOLL…

In this toddler-centric episode, Anna and Andrew read listener tales concerning baby-monitor scares, cubed cheese and the ghostliness of sneezes. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus: http://foreverdog…

In this ep, Anna and Andrew return to the vault of listener submitted tales to read one about a ghost with no feet, then discuss afterlife scents, undead vacations and Poltergeist 3. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free o…

Katy Fishell returns to read the artful chills of “Faster and Faster” and discuss outdated horror tropes, perverted wolves and the classic work of art “Eight Legged Freaks." For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever…

Katy Fishell returns to read the artful chills of “Faster and Faster” and discuss outdated horror tropes, perverted wolves and the classic work of art “Eight Legged Freaks." For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever…

In this little morsel of an ep, Andrew shares a personal post-Halloween tale about a ghostly encounter with a haunting rain-soaked specter in all black. Or maybe it was just a Mennonite. You decide! For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On T…

In this year’s Halloween Special, absolute icon Doug Jones (The Shape of Water) drops by to read “The Hearse Song” and discuss creature wants, silent movie monsters and post-mortem fingernail growth. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On …

Roz Drezfalez (Ghosted!) is back to reflect on “The Ghost in the Mirror” and discuss Bloody Mary the ghost, Bloody Mary the drink and Jennifer Coolidge the actress. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus…

Spiritual cousin of the pod and absolute delight, Roz Drezfalez (Ghosted!) joins Anna and Andrew this week to discuss non-denominational exorcisms, ghost grandmas and Catholic spookiness. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-F…

Spencer Novich (American Horror Story) is back again to dig into the four-legged horror of “The Black Dog” and discuss bad ghost dog owners, the myth of cats stealing the lives of babies and oppressive theater spaces. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary S…

American Horror Story’s own “Pale Man”, Spencer Novich joins Anna and Andrew to discuss formative frightening moments, threatening audition tapes and the trials and tribulations of being fitted for fangs. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tel…

In this long-requested ep, Anna and Andrew read “The Wendigo” and with the help of a gentle listener’s research, unpack the problematic nature of the tale, the harm that comes with appropriating Indigenous culture for the purposes of horror, and the actual origins of the cannibalistic monster. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Fo…

In this long-requested ep, Anna and Andrew read “The Wendigo” and with the help of a gentle listener’s research, unpack the problematic nature of the tale, the harm that comes with appropriating Indigenous culture for the purposes of horror, and the actual origins of the cannibalistic monster. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o Fo…

The thrilling conclusion of Andrew's interview with special guests Naomi Ekperigin and Andy Beckerman (Couples Therapy). For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus: http://foreverdogpodcasts.com/plus FOLLOW …

Very special guests Naomi Ekperigin and Andy Beckerman (Couples Therapy) drop by to read the iconic, skin-crawling tale “The Red Spot” and talk spiders, house centipedes and spider crickets. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod A…

Andrew and special guest-host Rachel Wenitsky (The Tonight Show) bid adieu to Listener Campfire Tale summer with a horrifying tale including shadowy figures, weeping spectres and outdated gender norms. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell O…

Returning to The Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark series, Andrew and special guest-host Rachel Wenitsky (The Tonight Show) trot into the animalistic horror of "The Hog" then discuss reincarnation, burial practices and pig-related frights. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3…

Andrew is joined by special guest-host Rachel Wenitsky (The Tonight Show) to read a listener's thrilling tale of aunts, surprise pilgrimages and The Queen of Pop herself. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Do…

In this ep, Anna and Andrew expose a listener’s deeply frightening story about a ghostly Polaroid then look into the history of spirit photography. For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod Ad-Free on Forever Dog Plus: http://foreverd…

In this ep, Anna and Andrew read a listener’s eerie encounter with a phantom orchestra and discuss the scariest music to hear from beyond, the perils of getting fit and the otherworldly nature of “Funky Town.” For merch click here: http://tee.pub/lic/bdCk0NATv7o For episode transcriptions click here: https://bit.ly/3n3nDYQ Listen to Scary Stories T…