Today’s episode is a 2 for 1! A two-fer! The first case is about Carlina White. Carlina was kidnapped at birth and did not find out until she became pregnant with her own baby and needed a copy of her birth certificate. The second case is about the Jim Twins. Two brothers who were separated at birth and found each other almost 40 years later. Shout…

Cari Farver was a 37-year-old woman from Iowa who had a quick fling with Dave Kroupa of Omaha, Nebraska in October 2012 — and two weeks later, she vanished, never to be seen again. The complex craziness that actually took place in this case never ceases to amaze me. Shoutout to Colton Carnley with CX3 for everything he has done to help us get this …

On November 9th, 1971 the List family was found brutally murdered in their New Jersey mansion. All that was left behind by the murderer was a disturbing letter. Police noticed that the family photos had been altered. John List, the husband and father, had been cut out from all family photos. He was also nowhere to be found in the home. John wouldn’…

At the time of her disappearance, Courtney Holden was living in a home with her son, her adoptive mother, Judy, and her adoptive brother, Joshua. Many knew about the abuse Courtney was experiencing, but Courtney never received the help she so desperately needed. Judy and Joshua were known to refer to Courtney as “Cindy” – short for “Cinderella” – i…

On a Saturday afternoon in 2003, Sheila Davalloo attempted to murder her husband Paul Christos while they were playing a game. Sheila came up with this game and made it seem like she wanted to rekindle a lost spark in her marriage. However, Sheila had something more sinister planned. After Paul’s attack, police started looking into Sheila’s life. T…

This is the story of a Milwaukee love affair between Dolly Oesterreich, the wife of a wealthy apron manufacturer, and her teenage lover that she secretly moved into the attic of the home she shared with her husband. This began a decade-long deception that ended in the murder of Fred Oesterreich. Shoutout to Colton Carnley with CX3 for everything he…

On New Year’s Eve 1999, Kaylene “Katy” Harris and her friend Krystal Surles were brutally attacked. Krystal rushed to get help, but unfortunately Katy lost her life. Krystal later woke in the hospital determined to get justice for her and Katy. She remembered exactly what their attacker looked like and was ready to tell police everything she could …

This episode is about a man that was murdered, dismembered, and discarded along a highway in Ohio. The prime suspect, his girlfriend at the time, left town shortly after being released from police custody and hasn’t been seen since. Shoutout to Colton Carnley with CX3 for everything he has done to help us get this podcast up and running. We, quite …

Nannie Doss had dreamt of romance almost her entire life. She would do anything to have the life she wanted. Getting rid of everything that wasn't working out for her… including killing four of her husbands. Nannies murders didn’t stop with her husbands. She went on to murder eleven people total. When she was eventually caught, Nannie giggled while…

On an afternoon in August of 2017, a very pregnant Savanna Greywind, then just 22-years-old, was asked by a neighbor named Brooke Crews to come upstairs and help her with a sewing project. Savanna agreed and went to try on a dress at the apartment shared by Brooke Crews and her boyfriend, William Hoehn. This was the last time anyone saw Savanna ali…

In July 1984, Dan Arnold was found brutally murdered in the parking lot of Immanuel Baptist Church in Clinton, North Carolina. Where Dan worked as the minister of music. His death shocked the small town of Clinton. Dans murder wouldn’t be solved until four years later. Dan and his wife Donna were involved in a complicated secret life, with a man na…

The Fritzl case drew a lot of attention beginning in 2008, when a woman named Elisabeth Fritzl told police in the town of Amstetten, Lower Austria, that she had been held captive for 24 years by her father, Josef Fritzl. Fritzl had assaulted, sexually abused, and raped his daughter repeatedly during her imprisonment inside a concealed area in the c…

Anna Bachmeier was a sweet, spunky little girl who everyone in town knew. She had a tough upbringing, being raised by a single mother who struggled to provide a stable life for Anna. One morning when Anna was walking around her neighborhood, she was abducted and murdered. Anna’s life was robbed from her by an evil man named Klaus Grabowski. Anna’s …

Robert Ackermann, also known as the Vienna cannibal, was a 19 businessman and doctor impersonator with a morbid curiosity about the inner workings of the human body who, after several hospitalizations for untreated schizoaffective psychosis, murdered his roommate, ate him, and then tried to blame it on mice. Yes, mice. Other criminals fear Ackerman…

Edmund Kemper III, is an evil man. Ed is a serial killer who killed multiple college girls, his own mother, his mothers best friend and his grandparents. He’s 6’9, and has a near genius level IQ. Ed gave multiple interviews while in prison which played a part in the Netflix series Mindhunter. Shoutout to Colton Carnley with CX3 for everything he ha…

Today’s true crime case is about a German cannibal that found a willing victim that wanted to be slaughtered and eaten. He dismembered the entire body of his victim so that he could store the parts in his freezer, which he proceeded to eat over the following 10 months. The entire process was recorded on videotape by the pair and would later be used…

The case of Gypsy Rose Blanchard and her abusive mother, Dee Dee. Their story is very strange and sad. For her entire life, Gypsy received medical treatment for conditions she did not have. Dee Dee claimed her daughter had muscular dystrophy, leukemia, seizures, learning disabilities and more. None of this is true. Dee Dee was the true sick one. Sh…

Five-year-old, Summer Moon-Utah Wells was reported missing the evening of Tuesday, June 15, 2021 when she disappeared from her home on Ben Hill Road in Rogersville, Tennessee. When she disappeared, she was 3 feet tall, weighed 40 lbs, had really short blonde hair, and had blue eyes. Her parents said she loved to play princess but was very much a to…

Robert Hansen appeared to be a normal man, trusted by many people in his community. He owned a small bakery, had a wife and children, and was known as a good friend. Until one day, when a distressed woman came forward and told police she had been kidnapped by someone who she described looking like Robert Hansen. Police would soon find out that Robe…

In May of 2005, Natalee Holloway, who was 18 at the time, went on a graduation trip to Aruba with about 120 of her classmates. She and her friends would hang out on the beach during the day and would party at local bars at night. Natalee met Joran van der Sloot and brothers Deepak and Satish Kalpoe at a bar on the last night of her trip. She left w…

Colleen Stan wanted to surprise one of her friends for her birthday, she decided to hitchhike to her destination but her sweet surprise soon turned into a nightmare. Colleen’s freedom was taken from her by the person who picked her up. She was held captive by an evil man, with the help of his wife. Colleen couldn’t escape until 7 years later. This …

This is the tragic story of Caylee Marie Anthony, an innocent, two year old girl who died in the care of her monster of a birth giver, Casey Anthony. Casey never reported her daughter missing and told lie, after lie, after lie in order to cover her azz, and she somehow managed to get away with it. Caylee deserves justice. Shoutout to Colton Carnley…

Aileen Wuornos had a traumatic childhood. Years of abuse and neglect left her to fend for herself for most of her life, and eventually she earned a living through sex work in Florida. Aileen spiraled down a very dark path after she picked up a man who allegedly tried to kill her. She killed the man in what she claimed was self defense. Aileen snapp…

Remember all of the madness from Part 1? Well, don't worry. I'll give you a brief recap. In this episode, you'll learn more about information that has come out about this case since the investigation started. You can expect to learn more about Alex Cox's violent past and unusual relationship with his sister, red flags leading up to and surrounding …

Two brothers, Lyle and Eric Menendez, seemed to have it all growing up in a mansion in Beverly Hills, attending Ivy League schools, driving nice cars, playing sports, and enjoying anything money could buy. That seemingly perfect life was shattered when the brothers entered the den of their Beverly Hills home and murdered their own parents on the ev…

Tylee Ashlyn Ryan and Joshua Jaxon (also know as "J. J." Vallow) were siblings from Chandler, Arizona, who went missing in September 2019 and whose remains were found buried in shallow graves on June 9, 2020 in Rexburg, Idaho, in their stepfather, Chad Daybell's, backyard. Unfortunately, Tylee and J.J. weren't the only victims. Lori and Chad believ…

How well do you really know someone? Charlie Brandt's wife and friends thought they knew who he was. People around him thought he was a devoted husband and a good friend. Then, one morning in 2004, Michelle Jones stopped answering her phone calls, and a worried friend went to check on her and found Charlie dead in Michelle's garage. Police arrived …

The murder of Mike Williams was the first case that Leah and I ever discussed. This is truly a case that I'll never forget. In this episode, Leah and I discuss how the two most important people in Mike's life ultimately chose to murder him in order to cash in on a hefty insurance policy and be together. What's scarier is the fact that they almost g…

Get to know your hosts, Hayley and Leah. During this quick, meet your hosts episode, we share a little about us, the podcast, and how we got started. We are taking the no BS approach to podcasting. From here on out, you can expect for us to dive right into the case each of us are covering. Welcome to Looks That Kill. Shoutout to Colton Carnley with…