Best Murder And Mimosas Podcasts (2024)

1
453: Heart! Heart! Heart! 1:14:45

39m ago1:14:45

1:14:45

The Dog & Pony crew faces the monster under the bed, considers a move to Ravenloft Heights Condos, contemplates vampire theology, and breaks some heart. Of course, once again, they gotta go up to get down. Dog & Pony Show VII, Part 6 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Dan Moren, Erika Ensign, Jane Ritt and Mikah Sargent Show Notes & Links Edited by Er…

1
452: A Mouthful of Vampire Juice 1:11:50

9d ago1:11:50

1:11:50

It’s just some axes, messin’ around and vampires named Oliver, Poison, Malachi, Renée, and Gerald and Johnny Darkness. See you next time, Renée! Dog & Pony Show VII, Part 5 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Dan Moren, Erika Ensign, Jane Ritt and Mikah Sargent Show Notes & Links Edited by Erika Ensign. Curse of Strahd Support this show and other shows…

1
451: OSHA the Spider Hag 1:01:26

10d ago1:01:26

1:01:26

The party grapples with questions like “How would a spider stand on eight different office chairs?,” “Will the treasure be a gilded bed-flipper or a three-pack of magic axes?,” and “Are owls birds?” (DM Tony would like to emphasize that they ARE.) One thing that’s certain: Arrigal is the MVNPC. Dog & Pony Show VII, Part 4 Tony Sindelar with Aleen S…

1
450: Many Pieces of Furniture Died Here 1:08:09

17d ago1:08:09

1:08:09

In the course of mapping the Larders of Ill Omen, the team encounters a Crucible crucible, a spooky office, the ruined corpses of cots, and so many tears. But it starts with a hug. Dog & Pony Show VII, Part 3 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Dan Moren, Erika Ensign, Jane Ritt and Mikah Sargent Show Notes & Links Edited by Erika Ensign. Curse of Stra…

1
449: Sparkling Despair 1:06:44

29d ago1:06:44

1:06:44

Lina du Lina is a sommelier who stores her emotions in her swords, and Elavor pleads the fifth acorn. Meanwhile, the crew traverses a misty hallway toward a wine cellar where Bruldish has a couple of axe-idents. Dog & Pony Show VII, Part 2 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Dan Moren, Erika Ensign, Jane Ritt and Mikah Sargent Show Notes & Links Edited…

1
448: An Octopus Riding a Sabertooth Tiger 1:10:11

1M ago1:10:11

1:10:11

The Dog & Pony crew is back! Bruldish, Crucible, Elavor, Imra, Lina, and the whole menagerie kick off the season with a drawbridge that’s just a bridge, a really charming rat, some sweeping in the dark, and a real mist opportunity. Dog & Pony Show VII, Part 1 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Dan Moren, Erika Ensign, Jane Ritt and Mikah Sargent Show …

1
447: A Showoff Assassin 1:05:04

1M ago1:05:04

1:05:04

In the final episode of The Price of Beauty, the adventurers take the battle to the hags…when they aren’t repeatedly pulling Townley from the abyss. Candlekeep - The Price of Beauty, Part 7 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Annette Wierstra, James Thomson, Mikah Sargent and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Warren Frey. Candlekeep Mysteries S…

1
446: Murder Armoire 51:52

2M ago51:52

51:52

Our heroes are stuck in a hallway, and their only means of defense are arson and ice rinks with a dash of desperation. Candlekeep - The Price of Beauty, Part 6 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Annette Wierstra, James Thomson, Mikah Sargent and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Warren Frey. Candlekeep Mysteries Support this show and other sho…

1
Crimson Rituals and the Flight of the Teen Vampires 41:47

2M ago41:47

41:47

Step beneath the shadow of a normal suburban home with us, and you'll find a world where the lines between reality and nightmare blur. In this macabre episode of Murder and Mimosas, we untangle the Wendorff family murders—a chilling tale of gothic subcultures, blood rituals, and a deadly romance. As we recount the night Jennifer Wendorff's existenc…

1
445: Auburn or Blauburn 55:01

2M ago55:01

55:01

The party reunites, beats up some statues, and encounters language barriers in their quest to save a scared Dwarf from a questionable wellness clinic. Candlekeep - The Price of Beauty, Part 5 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Annette Wierstra, James Thomson, Mikah Sargent and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Warren Frey. Candlekeep Mysteries…

1
Darkness Behind the Laughter of Schoolchildren 29:39

2M ago29:39

29:39

Discover the harrowing journey of Shanda Sharer, whose life was tragically cut short in a tale of friendships gone fatally awry. Join us as we delve into a story marked by adolescent betrayal, exploring the complexities of schoolyard dynamics and a love triangle that led to heartbreaking consequences. We'll guide you through the chilling events tha…

1
444: Marinara Mimosa 57:21

2M ago57:21

57:21

Jasper meets a kobold, Lonewalker befriends a gorgon, and they may unlock the secret of the spa…but at what cost? Candlekeep - The Price of Beauty, Part 4 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Annette Wierstra, James Thomson, Mikah Sargent and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Warren Frey. Candlekeep Mysteries Support this show and other shows li…

1
A Mysterious Death in the Arkansas Night and the Battle for Answers 46:41

2M ago46:41

46:41

Peel back the veil of a small Arkansas town's darkest hour as we recount the chilling, unresolved "boys on the track" case. A summer night's illegal deer spotlighting spree for teenagers Kevin Ives and Don Henry tragically ends on the train tracks—but was it truly an accident? The initial ruling rapidly dissolves under scrutiny, with a suspicious t…

1
443: Spataumatons 51:34

2M ago51:34

51:34

Relaxation turns into suspicion as the party learns more about a spa whose main product is secrecy. Candlekeep - The Price of Beauty, Part 3 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Annette Wierstra, James Thomson, Mikah Sargent and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Warren Frey. Candlekeep Mysteries Support this show and other shows like it on The I…

1
🔒 The Invisible Threads of Crime Storytelling 29:54

2M ago29:54

29:54

Subscriber-only episode Ever wonder about the meticulous craft behind your favorite true crime shows? Alexandra Kitty, author of "Murder in a Sundown Town" and a guiding force for "A Time to Kill," shares her serendipitous shift from art teacher to true crime researcher. In a riveting session, we unravel the complexities of distilling sprawling pol…

1
Nebraska's Nightmare: The Teenage Killers' Trail 37:45

2M ago37:45

37:45

Can you imagine the terror that swept through Lincoln, Nebraska, when a teenage couple embarked on a murderous rampage? Pour a mimosa and join me as we unravel the chilling tale of Charles Starkweather and Caril Ann Fugate, whose violent escapades in 1958 have become the stuff of true crime legend. Together, we'll explore Charles's descent from bul…

1
442: Spa Day 58:45

2M ago58:45

58:45

Our heroes have a spa day, but behind the incense and wind chimes lies danger. Candlekeep - The Price of Beauty, Part 2 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Annette Wierstra, James Thomson, Mikah Sargent and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Warren Frey. Candlekeep Mysteries Support this show and other shows like it on The Incomparable network b…

1
A Lament for Lost Childhood Amidst Liverpool's Grief 30:47

3M ago30:47

30:47

Unravel the haunting narrative of James Bulger, a two-year-old boy whose disappearance from a Liverpool shopping center spiraled into a heart-wrenching tragedy. As we recount the day that changed a family forever, we hold space for James's memory, scrutinizing the chilling CCTV footage that marked his final moments and the unwavering efforts of a c…

1
441: We're Big Readers Here 56:54

3M ago56:54

56:54

A group of misfit adventurers climb through a book-shaped portal and into a suspiciously lovely spa on a quest to find a Dwarven librarian. Candlekeep - The Price of Beauty, Part 1 Tony Sindelar with Aleen Simms, Annette Wierstra, James Thomson, Mikah Sargent and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Warren Frey. Candlekeep Mysteries Support th…

1
Silent Screams Among Tokyo's Dazzling Lights 29:06

3M ago29:06

29:06

Imagine the neon glow of Tokyo's nightlife hiding a sinister secret that ensnares the unwary. That's where we take you in our latest episode, as we unravel the tragic tale of Carita Bridgway, an Australian whose dreams were shattered amid the enigmatic world of Japan's hostess clubs. We dissect a puzzling narrative full of dubious characters and qu…

1
440: Plan L for Lion 1:18:07

3M ago1:18:07

1:18:07

The Stygian Gambit comes to a thrilling conclusion, but not before Revelle instigates even more lion chaos! Keys from the Golden Vault - The Stygian Gambit, Part 5 Tony Sindelar with Annette Wierstra, Erika Ensign, Jason Snell and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Erika Ensign. Keys from the Golden Vault Support this show and other shows li…

1
Greed's Deadly Currency 24:30

3M ago24:30

24:30

Could the desperate throes of poverty compel a seemingly ordinary woman to weave a web of deceit and murder? Join us as we recount the haunting, true tale of Martha Marek's life in early 20th-century Austria—a narrative drenched in manipulation and crime. From Martha's grim childhood and her unnerving dealings with an older man to her and Emil Mare…

1
439: I Am A Loud Lion 1:25:49

3M ago1:25:49

1:25:49

Plan B - the B is for best. Or is it for bump? Baboon? Keys from the Golden Vault - The Stygian Gambit, Part 4 Tony Sindelar with Annette Wierstra, Erika Ensign, Jason Snell and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Erika Ensign. Keys from the Golden Vault Support this show and other shows like it on The Incomparable network by becoming a membe…

1
A Resort Shrouded in Shadows: The Mystery of Ricky's End 37:21

3M ago37:21

37:21

Imagine the picturesque landscapes of Honduras, a place where Ricky embraced his passion for hotel management and became the heart of a resort community. His story, though, takes a dark and unexpected turn, leading us down a path of love, betrayal, and loss. In the latest episode of Murder and Mimosas True Crime Podcast, we honor Ricky's legacy and…

1
Episode 14 - The Stanley Hotel, Delimar Vera and Lady Eom (Kim Sum-ja) 1:02:35

3M ago1:02:35

1:02:35

HELLO our little culties!! This week we are talking about a famous hotel and some crazy women! FIrst up is the Stanley Hotel in Estes Park, CO. The inspiration for the Stephen King movie, The Shining. It was built by Freelan Oscar Stanley, co-founder of the Stanley Motor Carriage Company, and opened on July 4, 1909, as a resort for upper-class East…

1
438: This Casino Is Not Airtight 1:12:03

3M ago1:12:03

1:12:03

Some rat shenanigans, a soak in the spa, and … Oh God! It’s a LION! Keys from the Golden Vault - The Stygian Gambit, Part 3 Tony Sindelar with Annette Wierstra, Erika Ensign, Jason Snell and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Erika Ensign. Keys from the Golden Vault Support this show and other shows like it on The Incomparable network by bec…

1
Carol Jenkins: A Sundown Town's Injustice 26:55

4M ago26:55

26:55

When the shadows of a sundown town cloak a chilling tale of loss, the story demands to be told with the reverence it deserves. Together with Alexandra Kitty, a journalist with a keen eye for the often-overlooked narratives in true crime, we unravel the poignant story of Carol Jenkins—a young woman whose life ended tragically on the streets of Marti…

1
437: Rat Race 1:10:59

4M ago1:10:59

1:10:59

Come for the duelling intimidation checks, stay for the downtime portion of the heist. Keys from the Golden Vault - The Stygian Gambit, Part 2 Tony Sindelar with Annette Wierstra, Erika Ensign, Jason Snell and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by Erika Ensign. Keys from the Golden Vault Support this show and other shows like it on The Incompar…

1
A Treacherous Transformation from Officer to Offender 38:19

4M ago38:19

38:19

Prepare to be captivated as we guide you through the dark descent of Russell Williams, a man whose outward success masked his inner deviance. Once a respected Canadian Air Force Colonel, Williams led a double life that spiraled from theft to unspeakable violence. Our journey begins with a deep dive into his turbulent upbringing, from the family uph…

1
436: Rule 6: Win! Win! Win! 1:05:28

4M ago1:05:28

1:05:28

TPK returns to the greater Varkenbluff area with another heisty challenge, in which Jaee, Levithia, Revelle, and K’ronng learn it’s better to rule in Hell than serve drinks at a casino. Keys from the Golden Vault - The Stygian Gambit, Part 1 Tony Sindelar with Annette Wierstra, Erika Ensign, Jason Snell and Monty Ashley Show Notes & Links Edited by…

1
Illness, Infatuation, and the Inevitable Downfall 40:13

4M ago40:13

40:13

Can the perfect family facade hide a deadly secret lurking beneath? This episode uncovers the twisted tale of the Yoder family, where chiropractic care blends with covert operations, and an American Dream spirals into a haunting nightmare. Join us as we explore the complex web of relationships that trap the Yoders: Mary and Bill's seemingly ideal l…

1
Episode 13 - Omm Sety, Sherri Rasmussen, Katherine Knight 1:18:07

4M ago1:18:07

1:18:07

HELLO our little culties!! Thank you to everyone who participated in our contest to name our new Mascot. The winner was....@lizzard._.14!! Our mascots name is Cory the Coroner!! Congratulations Lizzie!! Omm Sety. Otherwise known as Dorothy Eady. She fell down the stairs at a very young age and technically died for a little while. When she came to, …

1
435: That's Not a Boomstick 1:14:45

4M ago1:14:45

1:14:45

Our heroes reconvene, and the smackdown begins with spikes and teleporting and murderously rough terrain! Oh my! Candlekeep - A Deep and Creeping Darkness, Part 6 Tony Sindelar with Dan Moren, Jason Snell, Kathy Campbell, Mikah Sargent and Tiff Arment Show Notes & Links Edited by Warren Frey. Candlekeep Mysteries Support this show and other shows l…

1
John Busby's Twilight Ambush: A Badge's Burden and the Quest for Justice 28:40

4M ago28:40

28:40

As the sun dipped below the horizon on the fateful night of August 31, 1979, police officer John Busby's life changed forever—a tale of crime and courage we unpack over a round of Mimosas. Joined by my co-host Shannon, we chart the trajectory of betrayal that led to bullets flying and a family thrown into turmoil. The details of that night, scribbl…

1
434: Paulie Read an Ethics Book 53:12

4M ago53:12

53:12

The spelunking continues as our party confronts both menacing meenlocks and muddy morasses of morality. Candlekeep - A Deep and Creeping Darkness, Part 5 Tony Sindelar with Dan Moren, Jason Snell, Kathy Campbell, Mikah Sargent and Tiff Arment Show Notes & Links Edited by Warren Frey. Candlekeep Mysteries Support this show and other shows like it on…

1
The Many Faces of True Crime 43:48

4M ago43:48

43:48

Could Gypsy Rose's early release and confessions crack open our understanding of her notorious past? This episode, Sierra and Danica, traverse the intricate world of Gypsy Rose, dissecting her complex history and confessions post-incarceration. We're peeling back the layers on her alleged sexual abuse, pill addiction, and eyebrow-raising decision t…

1
Tales of Trauma and Terror with Katherine Knight 29:41

5M ago29:41

29:41

What happens when the threads of a disturbed mind and unresolved trauma weave a tapestry of horror? Shannon and Danica, invite you to step into the shadows of Katherine Knight's life—a journey that goes much deeper than the murder of John. As we sift through the debris of Katherine's chilling past, from her family's dysfunction to the darkness of s…

1
433: Sorry about the Bagpipes 59:53

5M ago59:53

59:53

From empty(?) town to damp caves, our exhausted adventurers just can’t catch a break as they delve deep into the meenlock mystery.By The Incomparable

1
Bonnie Garland/ A Shattered Silence in Scarsdale 34:30

5M ago34:30

34:30

Imagine the shockwaves that ripple through an idyllic town when the unthinkable shatters its calm—a young, promising life cut short in a place where crime is as rare as a misstep on the social ladder. That's the backdrop of today's episode, as we recount the haunting murder of Yale student Bonnie Garland, whose affluent upbringing in Scarsdale was …

1
Episode 12 - The Screaming House Union Missouri, Tristan Beaudette and Dyatlov Pass 1:31:58

5M ago1:31:58

1:31:58

HELLO our little culties!! Don't forget our contest and new merchandise is out! The Screaming House of Union Missouri. It's going to be a hard pass for me on this one. You know I won't turn many adventures down, but when the Catholic church admits a place is diabolical, I'm going to listen to them. Morgan's story is about Tristan Beaudette. A truly…

1
432: Spooky Nightmares 54:37

5M ago54:37

54:37

Our (mostly) exhausted heroes explore the easily mispronounced town of Vermeillon to untangle the mystery of an abandoned domicile and the strange creatures within.By The Incomparable

1
Richard Speck/ The Darkness of Chicago's Darkest Night 27:21

5M ago27:21

27:21

Peel back the curtain on Chicago's darkest night with your hosts Danica and Sam, as we recount the twisted tale of Richard Speck, the man whose heinous actions sent shivers down the spine of a city and etched his name in true crime infamy. Sip on your Mimosa while we navigate through the stormy seas of Speck's life; from the death of his father to …

1
431: Disco Centipedes 1:04:04

5M ago1:04:04

1:04:04

Can our heroes resist an onslaught of disco centipedes in an otherwise drab town? Can they keep stay-stay-staying alive?By The Incomparable

1
A Lethal Partnership Unveiled 28:56

5M ago28:56

28:56

Ever wonder what darkness lies behind the eyes of a killer couple? This episode peels back the layers of the sinister Moorhouse murders, where David and Catherine's twisted paths led them to the abduction of innocent Kate Moore. As Shannon and Danica dissect their chilling story, we reveal the impact of their traumatic histories on their descent in…

1
430: Bats are the Answer 1:14:25

5M ago1:14:25

1:14:25

In this new Candlekeep Mysteries adventure, A Deep and Creeping Darkness, a band of mismatched adventurers visit the realm’s largest library. Literary snobbery ensues.By The Incomparable

1
Meredith Emerson/ A Hike into Darkness 30:35

5M ago30:35

30:35

Could Gary Hilton's chilling legacy hold even more secrets? As we unpack the spine-tingling tale of his heinous acts, including the unsettling New Year's Day vanishing of Meredith Emerson and her beloved dog Ella, you won't want to miss a moment of our narrative journey. With Danica and Shanna at the helm, uncover the relentless pursuit by Meredith…

1
429: Roll for Chocolate 3:12:48

6M ago3:12:48

3:12:48

Settle in (to a bath?), light a fire (on yourself?), cuddle up (with a dragon?), and enjoy this extra-long holiday special, in which four epic-level adventurers try to save the Mirthmas gifts and maybe make some friends along the way.By The Incomparable

1
Brittany Merritt/ The Murder of Her Father 48:07

6M ago48:07

48:07

Today, we have special guest Brittany Merritt on to tell the story about her father's murder. What should have been a special time of year for this family quickly turned to one of loss and hurt. The confusion around what happened added to the pain, but Brittany wanted answers and began digging into the information herself. Reverie Nature Podcast Na…

1
Episode 11 - Skinwalker Dogs, La Llorana and the Teke Teke 43:03

6M ago43:03

43:03

HELLO our little culties!! Hope your Halloween was as spooky as you wanted it to be! This week we were still in the Halloween spirit so we delved into some spooky legends! Jamie tells us about the Skinwalker Dogs...you will never look at your dogs the same again! Morgan talks about the legend of La Lallorna also known as the Weeping Woman. This wom…

1
428: Yetis Roasting on an Open Fire 46:12

6M ago46:12

46:12

Our heroes continue their trek to the tower to save all the Mirthmas gifts. But can they get past the spicy magic? And who’s in the bathroom?By The Incomparable

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Murder And Mimosas Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide