Best RJ and Rachel Metzger Podcasts (2024)

1
Marcus or Markieff & Villisca Axe Murders 32:52

3+ y ago32:52

32:52

This week, we have a sports conspiracy and some more murders. Based on what you know about us, I'll let you guess who presents what.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Precognition Dreams & USSR UFOs 34:16

3+ y ago34:16

34:16

This week, Rachel looks into what Reddit has to say regarding a subject some listeners wanted more stories on and RJ looks into his favorite topic, with a Russian twist.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Invisible Fangs & Dozier School for Boys 36:12

3+ y ago36:12

36:12

This week, RJ looks into a haunting/possession/just crazy person? Rachel talks about another sad thing, like usual.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
La Voisin & The Hamburg Bombing 34:16

3+ y ago34:16

34:16

This week, Rachel looks at a "witch" that was a real witch. RJ talks about something that might be share an explanation with ghosts, time travel...? Who knows. In the News LinkBy RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Listener Stories Vol. 3.5 1:01:51

3+ y ago1:01:51

1:01:51

Thanks to everyone that submitted stories again. Please, we want to hear your stories. If we missed yours, we just missed it, please send it to us again! Also, if you submitted and want stickers, reach out to us! Thanks!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Listener Stories Vol. 3 54:28

3+ y ago54:28

54:28

Thanks to everyone who submitted. If you submitted and aren't on this episode, see if you're in Vol. 4 and/or just reach back out to us as we may have lost it! Thanks!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Native and Aboriginal Little People & NOVA 57:46

3+ y ago57:46

57:46

This week, RJ looks at more cases like Hobbits, Leprechauns, and Dwinde. Rachel, looks at a.... nonprofit?By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Gef the Talking Mongoose & Hannah Up 32:50

3+ y ago32:50

32:50

This week Rachel looks into a case that may be a ghost, sheep dog, a mongoose, or scarier still - a child. RJ meanwhile shares a story about someone that is Jason Bourne, minus all the cool stuff.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
The Special Special Vol. 1 1:45:02

3+ y ago1:45:02

1:45:02

This week, we recap all our previous specials and search for additions to the stories. We want to do this every 5 specials so as not to let huge topics die forever. This year, we recap Area 51, JFK, Bigfoot, Zodiac, and Mothman (kinda). Listen to those first, it's the first time we have a prerequisite! For Bigfoot: Source 1 Source 2…

1
Devil's Footprints & Aum Shinrikyo 49:31

3+ y ago49:31

49:31

This week, RJ looks at a case that could be a balloon accident, an escaped Kangaroo, or of course... the Devil. Rachel on the other hand, looks at a for sure case of crazies.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
LaLaurie House & Baikal Lake Encounter 45:49

3+ y ago45:49

45:49

This week Rachel shares a sad story about mistreated slaves. RJ shares another Russian story that is, as all Russian stories are, shrouded in Blyat.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Matrix Confirmed & Dogman 1:03:24

3+ y ago1:03:24

1:03:24

This week RJ tries once again to convince Rachel of the Matrix. She's says that it's for the birds. And Rachel convinces RJ, once again, that rednecks really do see weird things in the woods. Videos Referenced in Episode: Facebook Viral Bird Instagram Bird Not Convincing Another One Bird with People Under and Other Birds California Highway NBA Play…

1
Hinterkaifeck Murders & Lily Dale Spiritulism 1:01:38

3+ y ago1:01:38

1:01:38

This week Rachel does another spooooky murder with no solve in sight. RJ talks about a community of weirdos, which makes him happy.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Courage the Cowardly Dog Origin & Finland 39:23

3+ y ago39:23

39:23

RJ talks about some possible inspiration for the Courage the Cowardly Dog, a demonic TV show straight from hellfire! Rachel talks about a land that exists.... or does it?!?!?!?By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
San Haven Sanitorium & Lourdes Miracles 1:18:45

3+ y ago1:18:45

1:18:45

Rachel has a creepy place submitted to us by a listener to talk about. RJ talks about some of the most well-documented miracles in the history of the world.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
I Look Pretty Good for a Dead B**** 41:43

3+ y ago41:43

41:43

We're finally back from hiatus! RJ has a Pentagon UFO unit update. Rachel talks about Yōkai from Japanese culture. It's a mess coming back, but hey, we're glad to be back!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Smiley Face Theory & Dyson Spheres 29:30

4+ y ago29:30

29:30

This week, we both talk about our favorite topics. Which, if you know the show, you should be able to guess!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Mothman Special Pt. 2 1:07:45

4+ y ago1:07:45

1:07:45

This week we continue diving into the mothman. While on quarantine. I'm bored. Please help me.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Mothman Special Pt. 1 1:29:07

4+ y ago1:29:07

1:29:07

This week, and for the next week as well, we look at Mothman. An underrated, in our newly formed opinion, cryptid!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Season 2 Intro 16:53

4+ y ago16:53

16:53

By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Egyptian Marian Apparition & Alice Kyteler 45:58

4+ y ago45:58

45:58

By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
1-Year Anniversary Recap 38:19

4+ y ago38:19

38:19

This week we recap the past year on the podcast!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Duende & The Jim Twins 1:00:20

5y ago1:00:20

1:00:20

This week, Rachel shares a cryptid that is seemingly both Irish and Spanish in decent? Not really, but kind of.. A lot. Also, RJ Talks about how weird twins are. They're so weird. Seriously.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
GPT-2 & The Greenbrier Ghost 43:51

5y ago43:51

43:51

This week, RJ tells some strange tales that make no sense - even more than normal. Rachel talks about a ghost that does something only a handful have ever done.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Ghost Show Mini-Episode 3 15:13

5y ago15:13

15:13

This week, we review "A Haunting", "My Celebrity Ghost Story", and "Ghost Nation". Enjoy!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
The Panama Disappearance & The Ghost Show Ghost 36:52

5y ago36:52

36:52

This week, Rachel looks at another mysterious disappearance without an official resolution. RJ shares a first-person narrative from Huffpost that is well-told by the author.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Ghost Show Mini-Episode 2 15:54

5y ago15:54

15:54

This week, RJ and Rachel review Ghost Hunters, Ghost Adventures, and BuzzFeed Unsolved Supernatural!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Gimbal-Gofast & The Werewolf of Bedburg 54:16

5y ago54:16

54:16

This week, RJ pays off an 8-month tease and finishes covering the best UFO evidence of all time! Rachel mixes a couple common subjects with a "cryptid" who was likely just a regular serial killer.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Celebrity Conspiracy Theories & Chronovisor 44:50

5y ago44:50

44:50

This week Rachel says blasphemy about some celebrities. RJ, while describing the "Papacy's best kept secret" talks about legitimate blasphemy as well! Join the party.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Ghost Show Mini-Episode 1 17:48

5y ago17:48

17:48

This week, review and compare Paranormal Lockdown and Ghosts in the Hood! One is one of the best and the other is meh, found out our thoughts and give them a watch!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Baigong Pipes & Benjaman Kyle 51:56

5y ago51:56

51:56

This week, RJ shares the tale of an ancient structure that defies everything we know about history... If you stop listening before we get to the rational explanation. Rachel shares a tale about a man with only a misspelled first name and a birthday and he only got one of those things right.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Reddit Alien Encounters & St. Augustine Lighthouse 55:49

5y ago55:49

55:49

This week, Rachel looks at some Reddit Alien stories for a change of pace. RJ looks at a very famous haunted location that they've visited because it has found its way into the haunted hall of fame. That's not a place, but we wish it was.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Zodiac Killer Special 1:30:51

5y ago1:30:51

1:30:51

This week, we look at one of the most infamous serial killers in history and discuss his victims, potential identities, and other theories about him! Also, drawing winners announced in this episode! Credit to these two YouTube videos for providing some audio for us as well.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Q&A 1 1:59:10

5y ago1:59:10

1:59:10

Here are some questions that were asked of us! It's a long one! If you feel like we missed your question, we might have! Please send it in again and we'll put it in our next episode!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Ghost Hunt Mini-Episode 23:31

5y ago23:31

23:31

For this mini-episode, we talk about our first ghost hunt. It will be on YouTube within the month, but just wanted to put this out for anyone not interested in watching the video. No real spoilers, but feel free to watch the hunt first and skip this for now, or listen to it. Either way.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Order of the Solar Temple & The Bunyip 51:01

5y ago51:01

51:01

This week, RJ talks about the Order of the Solar Temple which had an interesting end... If they didn't, would we even talk about them? And Rachel discusses a cryptid that RJ had never heard of, but its parts all sound familiar. Like, all of its parts.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Grace Sherwood - The Witch of Pungo 31:49

5y ago31:49

31:49

This week for a mini-special, RJ and Rachel look at the only witch trial in Virginia's history!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Poveglia Island & The Matrix 1:06:53

5y ago1:06:53

1:06:53

This week Rachel talks about an island that's really, really gross. And a bit creepy, we guess. Also, RJ tries to understand if we're in a Matrix, and that's a rabbit hole that we might be tempted to go down again.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Winchester House 19:02

5y ago19:02

19:02

For a mini-sode, RJ and Rachel both researched the Winchester House. And in a huge disappointment, neither found any evidence of actual ghosts... SHOCKER!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
1979 UFO Car & Arkansas Birds 38:28

5y ago38:28

38:28

This week RJ looks at a potential UFO encounter with evidence that's as close as a walk from a listener's in-law's house! Rachel tells a strange story where the evidence was a short walk from many, many people's houses! Also, stay tuned after the outro at the end of the episode for this week's bloopers!…

1
Blooper Episode 1 12:31

5y ago12:31

12:31

WARNING: Explicit Language and Nonsense will meet you here. Prepare for the cringe.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Maura Murray Disappearance & The Kelly-Hopkinsville Encounter 46:08

5y ago46:08

46:08

This week, Rachel looks at an odd disappearance with some very random details. RJ looks at some goblins (owls?) that tormented (lived near?) some rural folks. Also, we recorded this like a month ago, so our timeline is way off. HAPPY TO BE BACK!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Listener Stories Vol. 2 1:16:03

5y ago1:16:03

1:16:03

This week we share some listener stories with a special guest: Carol from Retro Late Fee! Thanks to everyone that submitted a story! Please submit at any time through any social media platform!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Operation LAC & Jamison Family Disappearance 45:01

5y ago45:01

45:01

This week RJ looks at another potential origin for a common conspiracy theory, but this one was proven to be true. It also may have deadly consequences, even if some of the theories are a bit shaky. Rachel looks at some people with some really hillbilly names that went missing... Or did they? Oh wait, they did. The question is... Who did it?…

1
Mercy Brown & The Mandela Effect 46:54

5y ago46:54

46:54

This week on the Skeptical Skeptics Podcast, Rachel talks about vampirism *ahem* consumption *ahem*. While RJ discusses one of the more widespread "paranormal" anomalies. See if you have become a victim of it too!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
What Do We Think About Things? 49:58

5y ago49:58

49:58

This week we discuss how we feel about aliens, ghosts, conspiracies, cryptids, etc. in general. This is so we can document our overall thoughts and see how/if they change over time. Join the conversation!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Danvers State Hospital & White House UFO's 55:09

5y ago55:09

55:09

This week, Rachel looks at a classically creepy hospital that's been shrouded in even more mystery. RJ looks at one of the most defining early UFO incidents that helped start UFO culture.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Bigfoot Special 1:33:10

5y ago1:33:10

1:33:10

This week on the Skeptical Skeptics Podcast, RJ and Rachel look at bigfoot. This is a very long episode, being a special. So, get comfortable, get a snack ready, and prepare to get the full history of Bigfoot in North America in the first half and modern compelling evidence in the second half of the episode. Videos referenced/Audio Used: Vocalizati…

1
Filipino Folklore & The Doodler 49:20

5+ y ago49:20

49:20

This week on the Skeptical Skeptics, RJ looks at some folklore from one of his cultures, the Philippines. Rachel looks at the serial killer with the worst name we've ever heard. And not scary, just straight the worst.By RJ and Rachel Metzger

1
Eriksson Twins & Paranormal Police 55:46

5+ y ago55:46

55:46

This week on Skeptical Skeptics, Rachel tells a tale about two twins that did a bunch of strange stuff in a short amount of time despite being seemingly normal people. RJ tells many tales about weird people going through weird things that actually call the cops for once!By RJ and Rachel Metzger

Podcasts Worth a Listen

RJ And Rachel Metzger Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide