Best Stab In The Dark Podcast Podcasts (2024)

1
68. Incestuous Love of a Father (MURDERER: Steven Pladl) 40:24

1h ago40:24

40:24

Send us a text Becky and Bevy discuss a triple homicide. In the tranquil town of Knightdale, North Carolina, the Pladl family appeared to lead a typical suburban life. Steven Pladl, a man with a shadowed past, resided with his wife, Alyssa, and their children. Their seemingly ordinary existence took a dramatic turn when Katie, Steven’s estranged da…

1
#424 - Human Animal - Nicole Bass 2:36:05

3h ago2:36:05

2:36:05

This week, we delve into the story of a woman who started out as a successful bodybuilder, and transferred that into notoriety by her many, many appearances on The Howard Stern show. Wrestling was the natural next step, and she was employed by WWE, ECW & others. A very naturally sweet person, she had some outbursts, apparently really enjoying bitin…

1
189: Scott Peterson: Has the Public Opinion Shifted? Feat. Nancy Grace 57:21

1h ago57:21

57:21

This week we are joined by Nancy Grace. Scott Peterson... a name nearly everyone who follows true crime is familiar with. After spending the last 20 years in prison for the murder of his wife, Laci, he is speaking out. With back-to-back documentaries released on Peacock and Netflix, including one that presents his side of the story, many people are…

1
188: HORRIFYING Madeline Soto Docs Released, Man Fakes Death to Evade Rape Charges, Wade Wilson Gets Death, Teacher Sexually Assaulted Pre-K Student? 41:57

1h ago41:57

41:57

Today’s episode dives into everything happening this week in true crime. From new cases to updates on existing ones and more. Ghost Bed: GhostBed.com/AE with code “AE” for 50% off sitewide. Beam: Head to https://www.shopbeam.com/ANNIEELISE and use code ANNIEELISE for an additional 40% off. Don’t forget supplies are limited and you can only shop it …

1
67. Scream Killers (MURDERERS: Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik) 54:12

7d ago54:12

54:12

Send us a text This week on LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss the Pocatello horror. In 2006, Cassie Jo Stoddart was house-sitting for her uncle in Pocatello, Idaho, determined to show her family she was responsible. She invited her boyfriend, Matt, over to keep her company, but what started as a normal evening took a creepy turn. Lights began flickering…

1
#423 - I Am Denzel - "Hurricane" Rubin Carter - Part 4 2:09:41

2h ago2:09:41

2:09:41

This week, we finish up this epic tale, waiting to hear if Rubin will be convicted, for a second time, in his retrial. He is sent back to prison, and furious to be convicted with the same, shifting evidence. This time, Bob Dylan & Muhammed Ali aren't there to help, either. Rubin never gives up the legal fight, but the state also isn't backing down.…

1
187: Stabbed 20x to Head, Neck & Torso - But She Did It Herself? | The Disturbing Case of Ellen Greenberg 1:07:05

1h ago1:07:05

1:07:05

In 2011, 27-year-old Ellen Greenberg was found dead in her apartment after sustaining 20 stab wounds. Her cause of death according to law enforcement? Self-inflicted. But was this really self-inflicted, or is there more to the story, as her family believes? A very special thank you to Ellen’s parents Joshua and Sandee Greenberg for joining us on to…

1
186: Teen Sisters Plot Murder, Doctor Pimps Out Teen Girl, Alexee Trevizo Walks Free? & Madeline Soto’s Mom’s Interview Released 40:35

19m ago40:35

40:35

Today’s episode dives into everything happening this week in true crime. From new cases to updates on existing ones and more. Going on TOUR!! Get your tickets now at: https://annieelise.com/blogs/events Beam: Head to https://www.shopbeam.com/ANNIEELISE and use code ANNIEELISE for an additional 40% off. Don’t forget supplies are limited and you can …

1
66. A Troubled Family Dynamic (MURDERER: Nathan Matthews) 58:12

14d ago58:12

58:12

Send us a text On today's episode of LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss the sad case of young Becky Watts. Becky Watts was a young girl grappling with severe anxiety and anorexia after moving in with her father, stepmother, and stepbrother Nathan. As Becky’s struggles grew, she confided in friends about her fear of Nathan, who allegedly bullied and mocke…

1
#422 - Blood Out Of A Turnip - "Hurricane" Rubin Carter - Part 3 2:21:01

1h ago2:21:01

2:21:01

This week, we catch up with Rubin, as a convicted murderer. The original witnesses are now recanting their stories of seeing Rubin at the murder scene. Meanwhile, Bob Dylan has written a popular song about him, and Muhammed Ali has taken up his cause. This leads to the charges being set aside, and a retrial. Problem is, while out on bail, he's also…

1
185: Millionaire Heiress' INSANE Plot To Murder Ex-Husband Unravels | Jared Bridegan and Shanna Gardner 1:13:03

16d ago1:13:03

1:13:03

In 2022, a man was gunned down in the middle of the road after dropping his 10 year old twins off at his ex-wife’s house. The investigation into the murder led to multiple arrests and shocking revelations. We're going on TOUR!! Get your tickets now at: https://annieelise.com/blogs/events Hiya Health Get 50% when you go to https://www.hiyahealth.com…

1
184: Husband Decapitates Newlywed Wife, Son Disembowels His Father, & 4-Month-Old Baby Force-Fed Gasoline 30:00

13d ago30:00

30:00

Headline Highlights: Today’s episode dives into everything happening this week in true crime. From new cases to updates on existing ones and more. Going on TOUR!! Get your tickets now at: https://annieelise.com/blogs/events Beam: Head to https://www.shopbeam.com/ANNIEELISE and use code ANNIEELISE for an additional 40% off. Don’t forget supplies are…

1
65. Fishing for Answers (MURDERER: Scott Peterson) 1:06:38

21d ago1:06:38

1:06:38

Send us a text On today's episode of LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss the murder and disappearance of Lacey and Connor Peterson. What if your perfect love story hid a chilling secret? Join us as we unravel the disturbing case of Lacey and Connor Peterson. From Lacey's modest beginnings to meeting Scott Peterson, a man with charm and a dark side, we'll …

1
#421 - Dead Men Don't Smoke - "Hurricane" Rubin Carter - Part 2 2:11:34

7d ago2:11:34

2:11:34

This week, we start with Rubin's career going downhill, fast. Fighting three times in one month. From there, it gets worse. After a night out at a local night spot, he is accused of going into a bar, with an accomplice, and murdering 3 people, in cold blood, while making one very unlucky man's life even worse. There is very little evidence, and Rub…

1
183: Wade Wilson: Tattoo Faced Killer Innocent? New BOMBSHELL Jail Calls Released! 1:14:29

11d ago1:14:29

1:14:29

Wade Wilson Deep Dive - https://youtu.be/wbgB47SKEYM?si=HXViFge0s5yl9ubP Going on TOUR!! Get your tickets now at: https://annieelise.com/blogs/events In October 2019, two women were brutally murdered in Florida. Within hours, an arrest was made in the case and recently, the defendant was convicted of both murders. But is he truly guilty? Or was he …

1
S2E90 – Just Hanging Out In a Pocket Dimension With a BBQ’d Admin. HBU? 39:52

1d ago39:52

39:52

The Cephalosquad catch up with the extra crispy administrator and try to coax some information out of him. Please support Dugongs & Sea Dragons on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/DugongsAndSeadragonsBy © Travis Nielsen

1
182: Teen Ritual Murders, Suitcase Killer Trial, Mica Miller Updates, & Treadmill Dad Destroyed 41:17

8d ago41:17

41:17

Headline Highlights: Today’s episode dives into everything happening this week in true crime. From new cases to updates on existing ones and more. Beam: Head to https://www.shopbeam.com/ANNIEELISE and use code ANNIEELISE for an additional 40% off. Don’t forget supplies are limited and you can only shop it through my link. Mica Miller Full Episode: …

1
64. The Idaho Four (MURDERER? TBD) 55:06

28d ago55:06

55:06

Send us a text On today's episode of LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss the brutal murders of four students in the small town of Moscow, Idaho. In 2022, in the small town of Moscow, Idaho, four university students were embarking on another year of school. They were immersed in the typical college experience—joining sororities, making friends, working har…

1
#420 - My History Is Violence - "Hurricane" Rubin Carter 2:20:15

7d ago2:20:15

2:20:15

This week, we start the multi part journey of a man who was played by Denzel Washington in a movie, and had Bob Dylan write a song about him. In part one, we learn the origins of his violent reactions, with beating up a teacher, then a preacher, and being turned in to the police, by his father for other crimes. His anger grows, as spends his time i…

1
181: Dark Secrets: The Black Swan Murder Case & Controversy | Deep Dive of Ashley Benefield 1:57:46

18d ago1:57:46

1:57:46

On September 27, 2020, Ashley Benefield shot her husband, Doug, in the heat of an argument. Ashley claims she shot him in self-defense after years of abuse. However, she was arrested and charged with murdering Doug just two months after his death. This case has gripped the nation and left many people wondering what truly happened. Was this self-def…

1
S2E89 – The Chase Is On Part 2 – Seagulls and Darkness and Turtles Oh My!!! 26:51

10d ago26:51

26:51

The Cephalosquad continue their thrilling chase down the hospital corridor to catch up with the deep fried administrator. Please support Dugongs & Sea Dragons on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/DugongsAndSeadragonsBy © Travis Nielsen

1
180: Olympics Child Rapist, Teen Puts Baby in Dumpster to Save Relationship, Taylor Swift Mass Stabbing, Missing 12 Year Old Found with 34 Year Old 31:07

15d ago31:07

31:07

Headline Highlights: Today’s episode dives into everything happening this week in true crime. From new cases to updates on existing ones and more. After the recording of this episode, a third victim tragically passed away due to injuries sustained from the stabbing at the Taylor Swift themed dance class. Our deepest condolences go out to all the fa…

1
63. Family Massacre (MURDERER: Don Spirit) 41:13

1M ago41:13

41:13

Send us a text On this week's episode of LOTW, Becky and Bevy discuss the viral case of the Spirit, Stewart, and Kuhlmann family massacre. Don Spirit, the murderer in this case, had a lengthy and troubling criminal history, marked by a series of offenses that painted a portrait of a troubled individual. However, it was his final, shocking act that …

1
#419 - Success On Spite - Jimmy Hitchcock 1:39:57

14d ago1:39:57

1:39:57

This week, we look at a man who started out with a chip on his shoulder, and never lost it. Luckily for him, that landed him a decent NFL career, and the goodwill of the state of North Carolina. This probably also led him to allegedly being involved in a shooting, then being tied up in quite a large scandal involving his post NFL career, real estat…

1
179: Social Media Influencer Turned Cult Leader & Human Trafficker | The Deep Dive of Kat Torres 1:02:14

29d ago1:02:14

1:02:14

If you could go back in time to early 2022, and look at Influencer Kat’s Torres’ Instagram account, you wouldn’t necessarily think this was someone who was going to be at the center of a massive criminal scandal. She did a pretty good job of looking like this sweet, innocent person. But behind her glamorous facade, was anything but glamorous. It wa…

1
S2E88 – The Chase Is On Part 1 – On Your Marks, Get Set, Go!!! 26:24

15d ago26:24

26:24

The Cephalosquad track down the still living university administrator and begin a thrilling chase to catch up with him. Please support Dugongs & Sea Dragons on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/DugongsAndSeadragonsBy © Travis Nielsen

1
178: Alison Chao's SHADY Disappearance, Sonya Massey Murdered by Cop, Fraud Scheme in the Hamptons Ends up Deadly, and 12 Year old Charged with Murder After a Sleepover 35:21

22d ago35:21

35:21

Headline Highlights: Today’s episode dives into everything happening this week in true crime. From new cases to updates on existing ones and more. Beam: Head to https://www.shopbeam.com/ANNIEELISE and use code ANNIEELISE for an additional 40% off. Don’t forget supplies are limited and you can only shop it through my link. Mica Miller Full Episode: …

1
62. Abused and Pregnant (MURDERER: Ben Blakeley) 48:27

1M ago48:27

48:27

Send us a text On this week's episode of LOTW, Becky and Bevy will discuss the case of Jayden Parkinson. Jayden Parkinson was a young woman grappling with significant challenges when she met Ben Blakeley. To her, Ben appeared as a beacon of hope amid family turmoil. Their romance began promisingly but quickly descended into a nightmare as Ben's beh…

1
#418 - Prison Poppins - Ted Turner - Part 2 1:57:47

1M ago1:57:47

1:57:47

This week, we finish up this insane tale with his father being a murderer, and never having to stay in prison. Meanwhile, Ted has o ne of the shortest careers, of all time, then starts a career as a full time gangster. As part of a safe cracking/housebreaking crew, they went all over the country to steal. Ted breaks out of prison, several times, ma…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Stab In The Dark Podcast

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide