Best The Pony Cast Podcasts (2024)

1
WA569 - Reshoot - Vol 1 2:27:17

2h ago2:27:17

2:27:17

Today our friend SP gave us a great gift! We have always wanted a greatest hits show but that would take so much time to put together that it is almost impossible. Enter our friend SP who shouldered the task. For weeks and possibly months he combed through the first ten episodes of Wholesome Addiction stitched it together for us then had our reside…

1
337 – Magic 1:53:13

23m ago1:53:13

1:53:13

Merry tells Sandyman that he is “dirty and insolent”, and the obvious jokes about your podcast hosts write themselves. Join The Man of the West and The Lord of the Mark for one of the saddest hours in our heroes’ lives in the last of our five episodes on The Scouring of the Shire. Sam’s heart is broken by the devastation in his hometown, the hobbit…

1
Cast 568: Abby Reads a Story 10:01

3d ago10:01

10:01

This week we were out and Abby took up the mantle and decided that will not stand - so she read you guys a story. It is awesome!By Abby

1
Cast 567: Guest - Dahlia Is Dopey 54:25

6d ago54:25

54:25

This week we are joined by one of THE most fun guests we've had in a while! Dahlia is Dopey joins us and is incredible from the word go. Not only does she deliver with Beef in their love of horror movies but she is a full-on geek like us! We love her and we bet you will too!By Beef, Jake, Sean

1
Cast 566: Learning New Things 1:18:43

13d ago1:18:43

1:18:43

Sometimes we forget of the cast that there are folks out there that haven't been along for the same ride as us for the last 12 years. When we find one they are treasure. Recon Rita describes such a person to us and we are stoked!By Beef, Jake, and Sean

1
336 – Let’s Go 1:35:24

13d ago1:35:24

1:35:24

The Gaffer hopes that Sam’s behaved hisself and given satisfaction; we hope we’ve done the same for you. Join The Man of the West and The Lord of the Mark as the ruffians hack, burn, and ruin everything they touch in the fourth of five episodes on The Scouring of the Shire. Flashbacks tell us about Lotho’s “business dealings”, as well as his mother…

1
335 – Just What I Needed 1:26:07

20d ago1:26:07

1:26:07

The voice is right, and your face is no worse than it was, Sam. Also true for Alan and Shawn. Join The Man of the West and The Lord of the Mark as our hobbit heroes are just what the Shire needs in the third of our five episodes on The Scouring of the Shire. Sam gets a bit tongue-tied; Farmer Exposition, uh Cotton, acts as bait; and the big ruffian…

1
Cast 565: Love Songs and Abby Hates the Celtics 1:28:46

20d ago1:28:46

1:28:46

I didn't see some of this coming. We hit the ground running this week with talk of Walton Goggins and the car started to lose traction around love songs. By the time we got to Abby's hate of all things basketball, I think we were way past Tokyo drifting and into a spin but hey, that's about normal for the likes of us.…

1
Smarty Pass Sneak Peek: Elevator Hostage 1:42

25d ago1:42

1:42

Uh oh, Molly is late to a Smash Boom Best taping of Elevators vs. Escalators! But things get worse when she runs into the all-knowing elevator at Brains On HQ, who demands she play a special sneak attack! Will Molly make it to the taping on time?By American Public Media

1
334 – Shake It Up 1:51:27

27d ago1:51:27

1:51:27

It is rather a comic cavalcade that hosts this episode, but at least we’re not under arrest. Yet. Join The Man of the West and The Lord of the Mark as Frodo and friends drive the two-feather Shirriff to exhaustion in the second of our five episodes on The Scouring of the Shire. The hobbits don’t let nothin’ get in the way as they deliver bad news t…

1
333 – Triple Nelson: The PPP Turns 333 2:09:55

1M ago2:09:55

2:09:55

It’s time for yet another party of special magnificence as The Prancing Pony Podcast releases its third highlight episode: it’s almost time for our vinyl box set and reunion tour. Join The Man of the West and The Lord of the Mark as they play listener-selected moments from the last eleventy-one episodes! From our visit to the butt store to the Witc…

1
Cast 564: Old, Cranky, and Here For It 1:14:08

1M ago1:14:08

1:14:08

We are old, except for Abby. We are cranky, except for Abby. We are also here for it this week for a great show, except for Beef who wanted to be elsewhere. Yep, that's right, we were holding Beef up this time on the show which makes him oh so friendly and happy when he chimes in. To be fair, Jake and Sean talked for nearly 40 minutes before we sta…

1
332 – Hello Again 1:38:21

1M ago1:38:21

1:38:21

No admittance between sundown and sunrise; except for Shawn, he can come and go as he pleases. Join The Man of the West as he welcomes back The Lord of the Mark as Frodo and friends return to a much-changed Shire in the first of five episodes on The Scouring of the Shire. Merry calls out a fellow Bucklander, Sam recognizes an old friend, and the ho…

1
Episode 074: Fat Brain Toys Air Toobz, HASBRO My Little Pony, Husqvarna Lawn Toys, SUPER7 Sesame Street, and More! 1:03:02

1M ago1:03:02

1:03:02

NEWS Quick Mentions: LEGO – LEGO Wicked Announced HASBRO/PLAYMATES - Entering Partnership Producing Power Rangers Toys MCFARLAND - 40-Year-Old-Virgin Movie Maniacs Discussion Topics Fat Brain Toys - Air Toobz / Toys on the Square HASBRO - My Little Pony Makeup Collection Husqvarna - Toy Lawn Equipment SUPER7- Sesame Street ReAction Figures Wave 2 C…

1
Cast 563: Pony Play 1:18:49

1M ago1:18:49

1:18:49

I know, I know, its hard to believe but we have finally found something that Jake can't handle - Pony Play. Beef follows up quickly with a hard pass as well and I can't figure out for the life of me what the two of them are on about. Pony girls are hot right? Right?By Beef, Jake, and Sean

1
Cast 562: Dirty Talk 1:32:11

2M ago1:32:11

1:32:11

This week on the cast we are back with Mother's Day and dirty talk. Wait that sounded bad, let me try that again, Mother's Day full stop. Then afterwards we talk about sounding sexy with different accents. Okay, perhaps that sounds better. We also do some letters and we get kudos from a 20-year-old blue-haired girl.…

1
331 – Questions After Nightfall 27 1:30:19

2M ago1:30:19

1:30:19

Tom talks in trochaic tetrameter today, triggering a trend. Join The Man of the West and The Sage of the South in his last episode (this season) as we answer listener questions in our 27th Questions After Nightfall! From popular misconceptions about Tolkien to keeping Gandalf on-task, from the nature of hope to the nature of Gothmog, our listeners …

1
Pegasus vs. Centaur: a mythological debate 37:29

2M ago37:29

37:29

Today’s legendary debate features two mighty, mythological horses. It’s Pegasus vs. Centaur! In a never-before-seen matchup between father and daughter, we’ve got Greeking Out creator and host Kenny Curtis here to defend Centaurs and Greeking Out writer Jillian Hughes ready to fight for the Pegasus. Who will be crowned the Smash Boom Best? Vote bel…

1
330 – And Here’s To You, Master Barliman 1:50:00

2M ago1:50:00

1:50:00

Dark shapes and dreadful things are terrifying Barliman; James and Alan will try not to make it any worse. Join The Man of the West and The Sage of the South as the hobbits conclude their visit to Bree in the final episode on Homeward Bound. Barliman is deeply confused about this whole king thing, the hobbits wonder exactly what Barliman means by “…

1
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles vs. My Little Pony: a friendly debate 37:05

2M ago37:05

37:05

Today’s debate is a friendly debate between two groups of special besties. It’s Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles vs. My Little Pony! Putting on the bandana for team Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles is actor and improviser Alsa Bruno, while playwright and performer Heather Meyer is ready to sparkle for team My Little Pony. Which buddy bunch will be crowned …

1
Smarty Pass Sneak Peek: Sanden vs. a Velociraptor 1:42

2M ago1:42

1:42

How many times have you asked yourself: which is better, Sanden or a Velociraptor? On the one hand, Velociraptors hunt in packs, but on the other hand, Sanden Totten is funny. Sanden has great hair, but Velociraptors have been featured in several movies. It’s impossible to decide. Well, grab your Smarty Pass because with the help of a fun game we’l…

1
Wholesome Addiction 561: Beef is 13 1:21:05

2M ago1:21:05

1:21:05

Thats right you guys Beef has been casting for 13 years! We are so proud of him. Our friend Wing was so proud he stopped by the cast to hang out and enjoy the Beefness which makes him our most frequent guest on the show.By Beef, Jake, and Sean

1
329 – Hello Pony, My Old Friend 1:30:53

2M ago1:30:53

1:30:53

Not all wounds can be healed, and not all episode descriptions can be clever. Join The Man of the West and The Sage of the South as we accompany Gandalf and the hobbits on their journey home from Rivendell in the first of our two episodes on Homeward Bound. Frodo provides an accounting of his wounds, Nob’s grammar skills nearly cause a tragedy, and…

1
Stripes vs. Polka Dots: a stylish debate 33:50

2M ago33:50

33:50

Today’s debate is a charming challenge between two patterned phenoms. It’s Stripes vs. Polka Dots! Voice actor and podcaster Merk Nguyen is ready to straighten the record for team Stripes, and actor, playwright and improviser Shanan Custer is ready to round out the story for team Polka Dots! Who will be crowned the Smash Boom Best? Head on over to …

1
328 – Alive and Kicking 1:38:24

2M ago1:38:24

1:38:24

Wormtongue wishes he could leave Saruman; James is stuck with Alan for a few more episodes: make of that what you will. Join The Man of the West and The Sage of the South as we get to Rivendell in time for a party in the last of our three episodes on Many Partings. Saruman offers some parting words to the hobbits; the Keepers of the Rings offer tot…

1
Wholesome Addiction 560: Listener Letters 55:29

2M ago55:29

55:29

Sometimes I don't know what to make of the show or how to describe it. But with Abby lobbing Bull Testicles and hidden stripper poles over the plate it gets way easier.By Abby, Beef, Jake, and Sean

1
Trains vs. Planes: A transporting debate 29:49

2M ago29:49

29:49

Today’s debate is more about the journey than the destination! It’s a match-up between the winged wonders of our skies and the locomotives that love making tracks. It’s Trains vs. Planes! In one corner we’ve got Forever Ago producer Nico Gonzalez Wisler ready to roll for team Trains, and in the other we’ve got actor, director, and teacher Allison V…

1
327 – Promised You a Miracle 1:34:26

3M ago1:34:26

1:34:26

Legolas is at a loss for words after visiting Aglarond with Gimli; Alan is at a loss for words after… well, never, really. Join The Man of the West and The Sage of the South as The Fellowship of the Ring head out on their farewell tour in our second of three episodes on Many Partings. Treebeard speaks his mind about orcs, gives excuses about Saruma…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

The Pony Cast Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide