This week we are telling a tale of the city that doesn't sleep, New York City! A little brownstone house is a home to quite a few ghosts, and all of them have a story to tell. Especially Mark Twain. BONUS! Peter's computer becomes possessed. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPo…

It's Mardi Gras! Let's drink up with a glass-smashing party ghost and have a seance in a poker-player ghost's fixer up. We're off to Louisiana to New Orleans' infamous Muriel's Jackson Square to meet some spirits that still hang around this haunt. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyP…

This week we hit the big 50! Let's count down the wildest, wettest, weirdest, water cryptids in this world! We are also releasing a bonus bite on Patreon this week! Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at Itch.io. …

This week we head to Boston, MA to learn about the spooky happenings of the Omni Parker House Hotel. There is a crazy cast of famous guests who have checked in, and some never checked out. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com Go to the arcade and play FREE games …

Hey there This week we introduce you to the Loveland Frogman, a cryptid from Loveland Ohio that might have actually just been Peter in a frog costume. We (sort of) answer the questions like: "did vacuums lead to feminism?" and "what is the difference between a frogman and a lizardman?" Grab your banjo, swoop your bangs, and sit down for a slice of …

Let's pour some milk out for our homies and learn about the history and traditions of Imbolc. We learn about a goddess that should be your role model, what latitudes are, how the groundhog stole all the fame, and some faerie folklore. Need a reason to spring clean? Imbolc. Need a reason to celebrate the end of Dry January? Imbolc. Visit us on our w…

This week listen to Britt wine to Peter about a demonic piece of furniture, The Dybbuk Box. Be careful what you're regifting after the holidays, it just might be possessed. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com Go to the arcade and play FREE games on Steam or at I…

This week Britt takes Peter back to Australia for an exciting tale that will get your heart racing. We learn about the questionable career choices of Frederick Federici and the history of Melbourne's beautiful Princess Theater. We also try to speak with an Aussie accent and fail miserably, mate. At least Britt has her favorite mug. Visit us on our …

We plan Peter's burial this week and talk about the Chase Family Vault! Is it a phenomenon caused by natural disasters? Angry ghost who needs some space? Or is it Aliens? Listen and learn! Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at CreepyPizzaPodcast@gmail.com Go to the arcade and play FREE games …

Starting off 2022 with a Haunted Doll story is a weird way to come back from winter break, but at least she's not a murder-doll, right? This week we tell the story of Okiku the Haunted Doll. Britt confronts some childhood clown trauma and Peter is now a rabbit frog. Happy New Year, y'all. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share yo…

Need a way to keep your crotch goblins in line? Try Gryla and her Yule Lads! Britt has a top ten that is not a top ten to close out the year. We're hoping to get a copy of Gryla's cookbook for Yule, instead of an invitation to dinner. Listeners, if you have some new ideas for moderns Yule Lads, let us know! This week is our Holiday Special! And our…

*This week we had some technical issues on Britt's Audio - most likely because she was recording in the haunted room. Our sincere apologies* CALLING ALL LISTENERS! Have a spooky story about the holiday spirit? send us an email, we'll read it on the show! This week we're studying a case of demon possession and a case of MURDER. Britt tells Peter abo…

CALLING ALL LISTENERS! Have a spooky story about the holiday spirit? send us an email, we'll read it on the show! Episode 40! Do you know what that means? We're at another top ten! This week Britt sails through a list of ghost ships, while Peter navigates some terrible puns. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share your paranormal …

CALLING ALL LISTENERS! Have a true ouija board story? send us an email, we'll read it on the show! In this week's episode, Britt and Peter really dig their graves by saying a certain demon's name like a bazillion times. Join us for a slice of Ouija true stories and spooky history of the demon Zozo. We also tell a paraphrased story from the Amazig b…

This week we have another first episode of a 3 part series. Britt goes into the origin of the talking boards from spiritualism, and how the Ouija board became what it is today! We also tell a paraphrased story from the Amazig book True Ghost Stories: Real Haunted Ouija Boards by Zachery Knowles Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to sh…

We are off to the most haunted place in India! Peter and Britt figure out their next jobs and have a new scent for the Creepy Pizza perfume line in this week's episode. We hear local folklore and the stories of hauntings in this beautiful ancient site. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share your paranormal stories? Email us at Cr…

What does a mobster with syphilis, a dog charged with murder and Quakers have in common? In this week's episode we learn about the Eastern State Penitentiary, Peter and Britt spend too much time talking about how nice it would be to be in solitary confinement for a couple of days, Britt talks about spooky ghosts of bad guys and the ghost of a good …

The CP crew would like to wish you a Happy (Belated) Halloween! The history of Halloween is deep and intricate, and we seem to try and sum it up in under an hour. Britt explains the history and why she would be a bad demon, Pope Bon Iver is a thing now, and we uncover the conspiracy of Big Candy. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to …

This week is the stunning(?) conclusion to the cliffhanger from last week's monster round-up. We're talking about the one and only Moth Man! Britt had to edit out about 20 sneezes, Peter is stuffy in more ways than one, the snuffle game is strong with both of them. Need a costume for a Christmas party? how about a green metal suit? Listen and learn…

In this week's episode, Britt and Peter take a hike, figuratively, through the Myths, Legends, and Monsters of the Appalachian trail! We are serving creepy up by the slice in this episode! We have true crime, we have magic, stinky monsters, ugly aliens, lawnmowers, grumpy sasquatches, and more! Careful while trekking through this episode, there may…

If you're going to buy property, maybe don't ask your real estate agent about old cemeteries and execution grounds, or do, we're not your parents. This week's episode is a real bummer, we're talking about the famous San Diego haunt, The Whaley House. Britt's hungover from the ghost hunt, where the only spirits she saw were whiskey, but at least Pet…

This week we pop over across the pond to learn about a haunted former Pub and Inn. The Ancient Ram Inn has all the amenities you could want in a spooky stay, Ghosts, Pagan Burials, Witch Burning, a saucy Succubus, and More! Except running water. We'd still stay there. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Want to share your paranormal stories…

This week we learn about some puppers that and good dogs from beyond the grave! This top ten is more like a top nine with a bonus IRL ghost dog story from Britt's Childhood. Don't worry, this is a short episode but we've got a lot of good tangents and puns. We're sorry. Listen to learn about the Ghost Dogs of America! This is NOT sponsored by barkb…

This week we join the mile-high club with a story of the Margret Brown House in Denver Colorado. But most of the episode we make bad jokes about the Titanic and talk about how much of a badass Margret Brown was. Pick out the Creepy Pizza Signature Scent, coming soon, maybe, but probably not. Join us in the GHOSTCAGE! We also announce the name of ou…

This week we head back to Scotland to learn about a ghost and his awkward afterlife, the best and most loyal pupper, and the other happening in the Greyfriars! Britt is like Bane, but with bad jokes and depression. Peter has been to Edinburgh, Scotland! But doesn't remember a thing. #onbrand. And we come up with a new cocktail for the poltergeist s…

Is it a cannonball? Is it pieces of an alien ship? Is it just a metal ball? ONLY ZAAT KNOWS! This week Britt tells Peter about the strange and interesting Betz Sphere! We watch and give commentary on the ZAAT! Movie trailer (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aKbGciL9h5E) and come up with some highly unlikely conspiracy theories of our own! Check out …

Chariots of Furry! Return of the Baby-Snatchers! This week we talk about Changelings, a fae creature that is switched out for human babies. Learn how to identify a changeling, what to do if your sweet bebe is switched out, and how to get your child back! Brad Pitt - have your people call our people. Sorry, it was a long day, Britt cusses a lot. Vis…

This week on Creepy Pizza we've got dancing, we're got leeches, we've got saints, and we've got bad puns! We head to Strasbourg, Alsace (which is now in France) to learn about the dance felt 'round the world. Peter learns what a himbo is, again. Britt gives gross recipes, and we lose our listeners over the battle of the batman. Visit us on our webs…

In this week's episode, we tell the story of La Llorona, how her man did her wrong, listen to some real experiences, and start our cult... we mean community. Britt goes into a horrible laughing fit after finding her spirit animal. Peter has made brunch plans. Lizzo, we're sorry for what Britt did to your song, singing isn't her strong suit. Visit u…

In this week's episode, we're going to Japan to learn about 10 different Japanese Yokai. This is Britt's T-T-T-T-TOP TEN, so they aren't in a specific order, just Yokai she thought were cool. We try to come up with some good consequences and fail. How do hyenas keep circling back into our episode? Is there a cousin of the Squonk living in Japan? Li…

The Creepy Pizza Pals head down unda' for our first story from Australia! Britt tells Peter about the Monte Cristo Sandwich and the Homestead it was named after.* Not quite a top ten, but there are ten ghosts. Including but not limited to; screaming boys, screaming babies, laughing babies, streaming women, and judgemental stares. Want to plan your …

During the PNW heatwave, Britt tells Peter the chilling stories of the American Folklore/Urban Legend of the Black Eyed Kids. Are they ghost? Aliens? Faeries? Britt's future kids going out on Halloween? Who knows! All we do know is they are creepy. Listen to learn more! Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Go to the arcade and play FREE game…

WE'VE MOVED! To fit better with our day-jobs, we're moving the release date to Tuesdays, because we want to give you the best podcast we can. We also have Kevin the editor for every episode now! Tuesday this fits better with his schedule. Now if Britt's ghost would stop messing with the recordings. This week we are down in Austin, TX for the ghosts…

Hello Robert. We're Sorry. In this week's episode, we head back down to Florida, to the Florida Keys, we find the foremost haunted doll in the world. Once again Britt talks about a creepy haunted/possessed doll. This is the story of Robert the Doll, the before-there-time influencers Gene and Anne, Myrtle Reuter the turtle, and where they all ended …

Happy 4th, Peter and Britt are proud to be a Merkin! (You'll get it when you listen) This week's episode is probe-ably our freakiest yet! Britt tells the tale of Betty and Barney Hill and their alien abduction experience. In one of our sidebars we create a new fearsome critter. There is a lot of bad singing. You will be hypnotized by our puns. We t…

This weekly special is a slice with all the toppings. Sit down in the Pizzeria for a tantalizing tale that takes you to Romania. No not vampires, but we're getting there. In this episode, Britt tells Peter of all the spooky happenings in a forest just outside of Cluj-Napoca, Romania. Welcome to the Hoia-Baciu forest, we got ghosts, cryptids, time t…

In this week's episode, Britt takes Peter on a journey back in time to France in the 1760s for a chilling tale of an unsolved mystery, that we claim to solve. This is the story of the Beast of Gévaudan, la Bête du Gévaudan, a terrifying beast that ravaged France. We co over the fashionable hunting techniques, propose a new version of the Goonies bu…

Hello Listeners... This is Janey. Enjoy this episode of Creepy Pizza where Britt takes Peter to St. Augustine, to see the St. Augustine Lighthouse. We're feminists, not Confederates. We make up new words, again. Peter aspires to live that Lighthouse keeper vibe. We hear about the cigar-smoking, prank-pulling, ghosties. Bonus: This week has an extra…

This week we head back to Scotland for a haunted house that's more like a castle, an island that rocks, and the fanciest dishes from the meaniest of pirates. We're heavy on the tangents this week, but they're worth it. Join us for a slice of spooky ghosty Scottish Haunting. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Find us on Instagram @CreepyPiz…

This week we do another countdown! Britt's top ten but it's not in the right order for a top ten. We discover some fearsome critters, where they came from, and pick out some favorites. Peter comes up with a game plan on not how to get eaten. Britt thinks most of the deadliest creatures are cute. Have a squonking good time learning about the FEARSOM…

Hello Pizza Pals! This week in the pizzeria Britt tells Peter about the tragedy of the DeFeo Family, the Lutz Family, and the HGTV nightmare of the Amityville horror house. Don't trust a good deal on a home without checking diedinhouse.com, always buy a new sleeping sponge, don't trust imaginary friends! Enjoy a slice of demon bacon pizza. Visit us…

What could be scary about a little soft stuffed toy doll? Everything. Britt opens up a whole can of nope this week for Peter who does not want to hear about it, but really, who does want to know the true story behind a haunted Raggedy Ann doll? Well, besides you. Remember if the ghost says it's a little girl, it's probably a demon, and if it's a de…

We hit episode 10! And to celebrate we are releasing the lost pilot episode we recorded before we actually made this a thing. Britt tells Peter a story that has EVERYTHING. Ghost, Aliens, Government Conspiracies, Butterized Dogs, Real Estate Moguls, and MORE! We apologize for everything. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Find us on Instag…

This week, Britt takes Peter back to his hometown(kinda) with the story of the Lizzie Borden House and the still-unsolved ax murders of Andrew and Abby Borden. Britt spouts out theories on who the murder is and why there are hauntings at the Borden House. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Find us on Instagram @CreepyPizzaPodcast And on Tw…

In this week's episode, Britt tells Peter about the Fox Sisters, the Hydesville Events, their rise to fame, and their inevitable decline. It's got ladies showing their ankles, bad boys of paranormal, an all-star cast of bored teenagers, and the ghosts that started it all, Mr. Splitfoot. This episode will have you knocking your knees and cracking yo…

In this episode, we head to the Jersey Shore, well, actually the Jersey Pine Barrens, to learn about the creepy cryptid, the Jersey Devil. We go off on a pun tangent, again. Sneeches get Leeches. Benjamin Franklin rears his head again, and Britt really needs to go back to First Grade history. We plan a canon ball play date. When in doubt blame the …

In this episode, we venture down to San Jose, California to tell you about No-Chill-Britt's favorite place in the world, the Winchester Mystery House and Sara Winchester. Peter and Britt pick on Welsley, discuss the pros and cons of ghost contractors, plan out our future architectural plans for the Oswald Myster McMansion, and Peter has only 7 year…

This week we talk about the many ghosts who haunt Waverly Hills Sanitorium of Louisville, KY. We also discuss how (not) cool we were in high school, how cute Selena Gomez is, and come up with a new business venture to bring more gargoyles into the lives of the American people. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizza.com Find us on Instagram @Creepy…

This week we go over Britt's Top 10 - 1 = 9 Ghost of the White House. We learn about the spooky stories of the residents of the White House who still linger, catching visitors at a disadvantage. Britt confesses her affection for Abraham Lincoln and confuses Coolidge with Cool Ranch. We stan Dolley Madison & Alice Roosevelt. We also go over the weir…

This week's episode we dive into the true story behind the book and film The Exorcist, the exorcism of Roland Doe. Britt accidentally summons a demon, we talk about picking up the archangel Michael at a bar, and go over the instructions for a cat baptism, and learn how get a prescription for a Catholic Priest. Visit us on our website www.CreepyPizz…