Best Murder And Mimosas Podcasts (2024)

1
Behind the Beard: The Sinister Secret Life of Bruce MacArthur 30:28

1h ago30:28

30:28

Send us a text What if the person playing Santa at your local mall harbored the darkest of secrets? Discover the chilling tale of Bruce MacArthur, a seemingly festive figure who led a horrifying double life. From his struggles with his identity and personal life to his unsettling transformation into Toronto's most notorious serial killer, we explor…

1
A Daughter's Betrayal and a Father's Forgiveness 36:42

4d ago36:42

36:42

Send us a text What drives a young girl from a conservative Christian upbringing to become embroiled in a harrowing murder plot against her own family? This chilling episode uncovers the shocking transformation of Erin Caffey, who sought freedom from her sheltered life only to find herself entangled in a sinister scheme with her boyfriend, Charlie,…

1
Layers of Suspicion: The Tragic Case of Delcia Mejia and the Black Metal Chaos 30:46

5d ago30:46

30:46

Send us a text Can a school altercation lead to tragedy, or is there more beneath the surface? Join us as we unravel the heart-wrenching mystery of Delcia Mejia, a vibrant 16-year-old whose life ended too soon under baffling circumstances. Her stepfather Raul's perplexing behavior and sudden relocation to California add layers of suspicion to this …

1
Red Flags Ignored: The Francine Hughes Story of Survival and Silence 30:38

2M ago30:38

30:38

Send us a text Can recognizing the red flags in a relationship save someone from a lifetime of trauma? Join us as we unravel Francine Hughes' compelling story, examining how her journey from Kentucky to Michigan led her into a toxic whirlwind romance with Mickey Hughes. Her tale serves as a crucial case study in understanding how early signs of an …

1
Webs of Crime in Alaska 19:46

1M ago19:46

19:46

Send us a text What happens when a chilling video lands in the hands of someone who must decide between their safety and doing the right thing? Join us as we unravel the dark tale of Brian Steven Smith, whose gruesome acts rocked Anchorage, Alaska. With Valerie Kastler's harrowing discovery of murder evidence, we explore the stark realities and leg…

1
The Devil's Defense: Unraveling the Arne Johnson Case 22:42

2M ago22:42

22:42

Send us a text [EPISODE SHOW NOTES] Welcome to a chilling journey into the unknown on this episode of Murder and Mimosas. Join us as we uncover the haunting case of Arne Johnson and Debbie Glatzel. From the eerie encounters that plagued their new home in Newton, Connecticut, to the shocking murder trial that followed, this episode will leave you qu…

1
The Paranormal Lens on Crime Stories 20:51

1M ago20:51

20:51

Send us a text Alexandra Orton, the brilliant mind behind "Out There Crimes of the Paranormal," takes center stage as she delves into the intriguing world where true crime meets the supernatural. Inspired by Hulu's "Sasquatch," Alexandra unveils her journey from documentary filmmaking to crafting narratives that blend real-life mysteries with other…

1
Echoes of Injustice: The Unresolved Girl Scout Murders 27:27

1M ago27:27

27:27

Send us a text What if the key to solving a decades-old mystery lay hidden in overlooked evidence? Join us as we unravel the enigma of the 1977 Girl Scout murders in Oklahoma, a haunting case that still grips the community. We navigate the complexities surrounding Gene Leroy Hart's trial, where he was acquitted despite strong suspicions of jury tam…

1
Wicked Wednesday: Slenderman 26:04

1M ago26:04

26:04

Send us a text Sources: https://theslenderman.fandom.com/wiki/Proxy https://youtu.be/kbP1wUx8mYw?si=z2529UOJySJLndAP https://www.jsonline.com/story/news/crime/2017/09/29/prosecutors-concede-insanity-plea-morgan-geyser-slender-man-case/704778001/ https://www.nami.org/about-mental-illness/mental-health-conditions/schizophrenia/#:~:text=Although%20sch…

1
Premonitions Ignored: The Tragic Camp Scott Girl Scout Murders 42:23

2M ago42:23

42:23

Send us a text What if unsettling premonitions and ignored warnings could have saved lives? In this chilling episode, we recount the tragic night of June 12, 1977, at Camp Scott in Tulsa, Oklahoma, where three young Girl Scouts, Lori Farmer, Denise Milner, and Michelle Gousset, met a devastating fate. From their first evening filled with excitement…

1
PODCAST TAKEOVER Haunting Shadows: Unveiling the Texarkana Moonlight Murders 35:56

2M ago35:56

35:56

Send us a text What if a masked assailant haunted your town, turning your life into a nightmare? In this gripping episode, we journey back to the late 1940s to uncover the chilling Texarkana Moonlight Murders. We recount the terrifying attack on Jimmy Hollis and Mary Jean Larry, who miraculously survived an assault by a masked gunman on Lover's Lan…

1
🔒 Dark Secrets in the Opera House: The Tragic Case of Helen Minkus 21:54

3M ago21:54

21:54

Subscriber-only episode Send us a text What if the bustling corridors of a prestigious opera house concealed a dark secret? This episode unravels the haunting mystery of Helen Minkus, a brilliant violinist whose life was tragically cut short at the Metropolitan Opera House. We chronicle Helen's extraordinary rise from a humble farm in British Colum…

1
Echoes of Tragedy: The Push for Jhorden's Law 1:00:07

3M ago1:00:07

1:00:07

Send us a text Can a system that’s meant to protect ultimately fail those who need it most? On this heart-wrenching episode, we sit down with Renee, the grandmother of Jhorden King Royale Clay, whose life was tragically cut short due to severe abuse. Renee recounts the harrowing details of Jhorden's short life, including the sporadic supervised vis…

1
Deception and Demise: Unraveling the Richins' Tragic End 34:28

3M ago34:28

34:28

Send us a text What if a simple Valentine's Day sandwich could unravel a tale of love, lies, and financial betrayal? Join us as we navigate the tumultuous journey of Eric and Kouri Richins, from their whirlwind romance to a perfect family life shadowed by an ominous prenup request. Though their life seemed idyllic, Kouri's search for personal fulfi…

1
The Hyena of Auschwitz: Unmasking Irma Grese's Dark Legacy 34:08

4M ago34:08

34:08

Send us a text After surviving a migraine-related stroke, our guest, Judith A. Yates, a veteran criminologist with over 35 years in law enforcement transformed her personal ordeal into a mission to uncover the dark history of Irma Grese, the notorious "Hyena of Auschwitz." In this episode, she shares how her friendship with Holocaust survivor Esthe…

1
Insects and Injustice: Solving a Gruesome Crime 34:08

4M ago34:08

34:08

Send us a text What if a seemingly airtight alibi isn't quite as foolproof as it appears? Join us as we unravel the spine-chilling events of July 8, 2003, in Bakersfield, California, where Kelsey Spann's frantic 911 call led to the discovery of a gruesome crime scene. Joni Harper, her three children, and her mother were all found brutally murdered,…

1
Unmasking the Satanic Panic's Real Victims 30:48

4M ago30:48

30:48

Send us a text What if an entire town was swept up in a wave of hysteria that led to the wrongful conviction of three innocent boys? Uncover the final chapter of the West Memphis Three saga, as we dissect the flawed investigation, the rise of the satanic panic, and the unjust sentences handed down to Jessie, Jason, and Damien. We'll revisit the cri…

1
False Confessions and Judicial Failures 30:50

4M ago30:50

30:50

Send us a text Can a community's fear and paranoia lead to the wrongful conviction of innocent teenagers? Our latest episode grapples with this haunting question as we continue to dissect the infamous West Memphis Three case. We shine a spotlight on Damien Echols, whose troubled past and community suspicion made him a prime target during the satani…

1
Hot Pursuit: A Summer True Crime Collaboration 1:48:52

4M ago1:48:52

1:48:52

Send us a text What really happened to Robin Gardner on that fateful trip to Aruba in 2011? Join us as we kick off our summer true crime collaboration with Cynthia and Stephanie from the Dark Oak podcast. We'll uncover the complex and secretive life of Robin, who vanished while vacationing with her enigmatic companion, Gary Giordano. Was it a tragi…

1
Hot Pursuit: A Summer True Crime Collaboration 1:44:20

4M ago1:44:20

1:44:20

Send us a text What horrors can one endure in the shadows of supposed safety? Join us as we unravel the heartbreaking story of Anna Augustin, a young maid subjected to extreme abuse in 1930s Austria. With Annie and Johanna from the Fresh Hell Podcast, we explore Anna's tragic life and the chilling discovery of her body, serving as a haunting remind…

1
Blood Stains and Broken Hearts in Arkansas 26:59

4M ago26:59

26:59

Send us a text Experience the unsettling case of the West Memphis Three like never before. What could a single black tennis shoe found floating in a ditch reveal about a harrowing 1993 mystery? This episode of Murder and Mimosas takes you straight to the heart of West Memphis, Arkansas, on May 5th, where the disappearance of three young boys, Micha…

1
From Bomb Deals to PTSD: The Double Life of Billy the Liquor Guy 32:08

5M ago32:08

32:08

Send us a text Ever wondered what it's like to walk the thin line between law enforcement and the criminal underworld? Join us for an eye-opening conversation with Billy the Liquor Guy, a retired senior investigator for New York State's Petroleum, Alcohol, and Tobacco Bureau (PATB). Billy takes us through his pulse-pounding career highlights, from …

1
Grindr's Grim Reaper: The Lethal Online Enticements of Stephen Port 21:18

5M ago21:18

21:18

Send us a text What if a popular dating app became the perfect hunting ground for a serial killer? On this gripping episode of Murder and Mimosas, we unravel the bone-chilling story of Stephen Port, a man who transformed from a troubled child into a notorious predator using platforms like Grindr to lure his unsuspecting victims. We kick off with St…

1
The Hidden Horror in an Ordinary Neighborhood 44:15

5M ago44:15

44:15

Send us a text What happens when a seemingly ordinary, struggling single mother of seven becomes the mastermind behind one of the most gruesome child abuse cases in American history? This episode of Murder and Mimosas unpacks the dark and horrifying journey of Gertrude Baniszewski. We navigate through the tumultuous episodes of her life, from abusi…

1
The Soldier's Fate and the Con Man's Playbook 52:05

5M ago52:05

52:05

Send us a text Can a soldier become a drug smuggler and still believe that everything happens for a reason? Join us as we unravel the compelling life of Ronald J. Baker. From the harrowing battlefields of Vietnam to the high-stakes underworld of drug smuggling, Baker's story is filled with close calls, personal losses, and a relentless drive shaped…

1
Crimson Rituals and the Flight of the Teen Vampires 41:48

8M ago41:48

41:48

Send us a text Step beneath the shadow of a normal suburban home with us, and you'll find a world where the lines between reality and nightmare blur. In this macabre episode of Murder and Mimosas, we untangle the Wendorff family murders—a chilling tale of gothic subcultures, blood rituals, and a deadly romance. As we recount the night Jennifer Wend…

1
Darkness Behind the Laughter of Schoolchildren 29:40

8M ago29:40

29:40

Send us a text Discover the harrowing journey of Shanda Sharer, whose life was tragically cut short in a tale of friendships gone fatally awry. Join us as we delve into a story marked by adolescent betrayal, exploring the complexities of schoolyard dynamics and a love triangle that led to heartbreaking consequences. We'll guide you through the chil…

1
A Mysterious Death in the Arkansas Night and the Battle for Answers 46:41

8M ago46:41

46:41

Send us a text Peel back the veil of a small Arkansas town's darkest hour as we recount the chilling, unresolved "boys on the track" case. A summer night's illegal deer spotlighting spree for teenagers Kevin Ives and Don Henry tragically ends on the train tracks—but was it truly an accident? The initial ruling rapidly dissolves under scrutiny, with…

1
🔒 The Invisible Threads of Crime Storytelling 29:54

9M ago29:54

29:54

Subscriber-only episode Send us a text Ever wonder about the meticulous craft behind your favorite true crime shows? Alexandra Kitty, author of "Murder in a Sundown Town" and a guiding force for "A Time to Kill," shares her serendipitous shift from art teacher to true crime researcher. In a riveting session, we unravel the complexities of distillin…

1
Nebraska's Nightmare: The Teenage Killers' Trail 37:45

9M ago37:45

37:45

Send us a text Can you imagine the terror that swept through Lincoln, Nebraska, when a teenage couple embarked on a murderous rampage? Pour a mimosa and join me as we unravel the chilling tale of Charles Starkweather and Caril Ann Fugate, whose violent escapades in 1958 have become the stuff of true crime legend. Together, we'll explore Charles's d…

1
A Lament for Lost Childhood Amidst Liverpool's Grief 30:47

9M ago30:47

30:47

Send us a text Unravel the haunting narrative of James Bulger, a two-year-old boy whose disappearance from a Liverpool shopping center spiraled into a heart-wrenching tragedy. As we recount the day that changed a family forever, we hold space for James's memory, scrutinizing the chilling CCTV footage that marked his final moments and the unwavering…

1
Silent Screams Among Tokyo's Dazzling Lights 29:06

9M ago29:06

29:06

Send us a text Imagine the neon glow of Tokyo's nightlife hiding a sinister secret that ensnares the unwary. That's where we take you in our latest episode, as we unravel the tragic tale of Carita Bridgway, an Australian whose dreams were shattered amid the enigmatic world of Japan's hostess clubs. We dissect a puzzling narrative full of dubious ch…

1
Greed's Deadly Currency 24:31

9M ago24:31

24:31

Send us a text Could the desperate throes of poverty compel a seemingly ordinary woman to weave a web of deceit and murder? Join us as we recount the haunting, true tale of Martha Marek's life in early 20th-century Austria—a narrative drenched in manipulation and crime. From Martha's grim childhood and her unnerving dealings with an older man to he…

1
A Resort Shrouded in Shadows: The Mystery of Ricky's End 37:21

10M ago37:21

37:21

Send us a text Imagine the picturesque landscapes of Honduras, a place where Ricky embraced his passion for hotel management and became the heart of a resort community. His story, though, takes a dark and unexpected turn, leading us down a path of love, betrayal, and loss. In the latest episode of Murder and Mimosas True Crime Podcast, we honor Ric…

1
Carol Jenkins: A Sundown Town's Injustice 26:55

10M ago26:55

26:55

Send us a text When the shadows of a sundown town cloak a chilling tale of loss, the story demands to be told with the reverence it deserves. Together with Alexandra Kitty, a journalist with a keen eye for the often-overlooked narratives in true crime, we unravel the poignant story of Carol Jenkins—a young woman whose life ended tragically on the s…

1
A Treacherous Transformation from Officer to Offender 38:19

10M ago38:19

38:19

Send us a text Prepare to be captivated as we guide you through the dark descent of Russell Williams, a man whose outward success masked his inner deviance. Once a respected Canadian Air Force Colonel, Williams led a double life that spiraled from theft to unspeakable violence. Our journey begins with a deep dive into his turbulent upbringing, from…

1
Illness, Infatuation, and the Inevitable Downfall 40:14

10M ago40:14

40:14

Send us a text Can the perfect family facade hide a deadly secret lurking beneath? This episode uncovers the twisted tale of the Yoder family, where chiropractic care blends with covert operations, and an American Dream spirals into a haunting nightmare. Join us as we explore the complex web of relationships that trap the Yoders: Mary and Bill's se…

1
John Busby's Twilight Ambush: A Badge's Burden and the Quest for Justice 28:41

11M ago28:41

28:41

Send us a text As the sun dipped below the horizon on the fateful night of August 31, 1979, police officer John Busby's life changed forever—a tale of crime and courage we unpack over a round of Mimosas. Joined by my co-host Shannon, we chart the trajectory of betrayal that led to bullets flying and a family thrown into turmoil. The details of that…

1
The Many Faces of True Crime 43:48

11M ago43:48

43:48

Send us a text Could Gypsy Rose's early release and confessions crack open our understanding of her notorious past? This episode, Sierra and Danica, traverse the intricate world of Gypsy Rose, dissecting her complex history and confessions post-incarceration. We're peeling back the layers on her alleged sexual abuse, pill addiction, and eyebrow-rai…

1
Tales of Trauma and Terror with Katherine Knight 29:41

11M ago29:41

29:41

Send us a text What happens when the threads of a disturbed mind and unresolved trauma weave a tapestry of horror? Shannon and Danica, invite you to step into the shadows of Katherine Knight's life—a journey that goes much deeper than the murder of John. As we sift through the debris of Katherine's chilling past, from her family's dysfunction to th…

1
Bonnie Garland/ A Shattered Silence in Scarsdale 34:31

11M ago34:31

34:31

Send us a text Imagine the shockwaves that ripple through an idyllic town when the unthinkable shatters its calm—a young, promising life cut short in a place where crime is as rare as a misstep on the social ladder. That's the backdrop of today's episode, as we recount the haunting murder of Yale student Bonnie Garland, whose affluent upbringing in…

1
Richard Speck/ The Darkness of Chicago's Darkest Night 27:22

11M ago27:22

27:22

Send us a text Peel back the curtain on Chicago's darkest night with your hosts Danica and Sam, as we recount the twisted tale of Richard Speck, the man whose heinous actions sent shivers down the spine of a city and etched his name in true crime infamy. Sip on your Mimosa while we navigate through the stormy seas of Speck's life; from the death of…

1
A Lethal Partnership Unveiled 28:56

11M ago28:56

28:56

Send us a text Ever wonder what darkness lies behind the eyes of a killer couple? This episode peels back the layers of the sinister Moorhouse murders, where David and Catherine's twisted paths led them to the abduction of innocent Kate Moore. As Shannon and Danica dissect their chilling story, we reveal the impact of their traumatic histories on t…

1
Meredith Emerson/ A Hike into Darkness 30:36

12M ago30:36

30:36

Send us a text Could Gary Hilton's chilling legacy hold even more secrets? As we unpack the spine-tingling tale of his heinous acts, including the unsettling New Year's Day vanishing of Meredith Emerson and her beloved dog Ella, you won't want to miss a moment of our narrative journey. With Danica and Shanna at the helm, uncover the relentless purs…

1
Brittany Merritt/ The Murder of Her Father 48:08

12M ago48:08

48:08

Send us a text Today, we have special guest Brittany Merritt on to tell the story about her father's murder. What should have been a special time of year for this family quickly turned to one of loss and hurt. The confusion around what happened added to the pain, but Brittany wanted answers and began digging into the information herself. Persons of…

1
Goldmarks/ Murder for Christmas 30:29

12M ago30:29

30:29

Send us a text Sources: The Goldmark family prepared for a Christmas dinner with friends, but when the doorbell rang it was not Christmas joy at the door. Instead the guest was something much more sinister with plans that would be deadly for the family of four. https://www.historylink.org/Pages/Donate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_Club https:/…

1
Kelly Cochran/ The She Devil 25:04

1y ago25:04

25:04

Send us a text Kelly Cochran was not a faithful wife, honest person, or above the law despite what she may have thought. After one of her many lovers, Chris, goes missing the police hone in on Kelly and her husband. Tips slowly come in, one particularly disturbing one from the Cochran's neighbors who fear they may have eaten the lover at the Cochra…

1
Loretta Jones/ Justice Prevails 18:59

1y ago18:59

18:59

Send us a text Loretta Jones was a devoted single mother to four year old Heidi Jones. However, Heidi would sadly be the one to find her mother brutally killed in their home by a man Heidi refers to as Tom. Who is this Tom and why would he do something so evil? The case would go cold for many years, but as an adult Heidi would push hard to find jus…

1
Jake Wideman/ Pen-Pals turned Wives 32:36

1y ago32:36

32:36

Send us a text Jake Wideman becomes a murderer at a young age, but it doesn't seem to affect the women in his lives even if that meant possibly losing their jobs, money and having a murderous stepfather for their children. You will be shocked to find out how Jake is meeting his wives and that they agree to marry him even their intimate knowledge of…

1
Podcast Takeover: Book of the Dead/ Murder of Stephanie Parze 42:07

1y ago42:07

42:07

Send us a text We are eternally grateful for our amazing listeners and while this Thanksgiving became a whirlwind that sadly kept us out of the studio we couldn't leave you high and dry! Enjoy today's episode from an amazing podcast that also has a mother and daughter duo...Book of the Dead! If you love them as much as we do click the link and subs…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Murder And Mimosas Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide