Episode 6- February 14, 1982 Murder (Jane Doe- Valentine Sally)

In time crime

In this riveting episode, we venture into the unsolved case of a nameless victim known as 'Valentine Sally.' Discover a captivating story filled with twists, turns, and unspeakable acts. With a gruesome narrative unfolding on Valentine's Day, 1982, this episode uncovers the chilling circumstances behind a young woman's mysterious murder off the Arizona Interstate 40.

Delve deeper into a perplexing mystery that extends beyond misidentification and erroneous conviction. Learn how witness accounts, dental records and peculiar dental health clues become significant pieces in this complex murder puzzle. With the discovery of aspirin in one molar and an impending root canal, uncover the poignant life led by 'Valentine Sally' leading up to her tragic death.

Witness accounts add a unique layer to the narrative with a concerned local diner worker, Patty Wilkins' testimony, and a university student's claim of having given 'Valentine Sally' a lift. Explore the complexity of her life in Phoenix working as a dishwasher, and her final journey to the East coast before her untimely demise.

In a shocking twist, witness the initial misidentification of 'Valentine Sally' as Melody Cutlip based on controversial bite mark comparisons. The story takes an unbelievable turn when Melody returns home alive two years after her supposed death, leaving Valentine Sally's case as one of the most intriguing unsolved mysteries of our time.

This podcast deep dives into the escalated complications from the death of a potential suspect, the significant contribution of a cold case squad in 2005, and the final revelation of Valentine Sally's true identity as Carolyn Celeste Eaton from Missouri. As we present this haunting tale, we pay tribute to the memory of the tragically lost 'Valentine Sally' and shed light on a powerful story of resilience amid adversity.

Be prepared for an unforgettable journey through memory, justice, and relentless truth-seeking. Join us in our quest for answers in history's most intriguing mysteries and remember to follow us on Spotify, Apple, Google, or wherever you listen to your podcasts for more gripping revelations.

Don't forget to follow us on:

Instagram- Robin Bagayoko (@intimecrime) • Instagram photos and videos

Tiktok- In time crime (@intimecrime) | TikTok

Facebook- https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61557262126879

All links are in our linktree for easier access- https://linktr.ee/intimecrime

This podcast is available on most podcast platforms including, apple podcast, spotify, podbean, amazon, iHeart radio, player fm, samsung, pod chaser and boomplay.

Please feel free to email us with cases for dates already covered or comments at [e-mail]

Music by- Jeremy Blake