Questionable Forensics and the Double Homicide of Cheryl Williams and Carol Bareis

WILDCIDE

In 2004, three generations of women lived together in a home in Altamonte Springs, Florida: 68-year-old Carol Bareis, her daughter 47-year-old Cheryl Williams and Cheryl’s daughter Samantha Williams. On the morning of June 17, 2004, the once quiet street of Vagabond Way was crawling with law enforcement and crime scene techs processing the double homicide of Carol and Cheryl. The mother-daughter duo had been viciously attacked, stabbed a total of 131 times between the two of them. It didn’t take long for the investigation to hone in on 24 year-old Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin, an illegal immigrant from Honduras for good reason: there was DNA evidence, fingerprint evidence, shoeprints and the recovered murder weapon all pointing to what appeared to be an open-and-shut case. However, this case quickly turns into a shocking tale of how human biases and errors in forensic science failed everyone involved. We guarantee you that after hearing this case, you’ll wonder if forensic science is as accurate as we were lead to believe.

**Don’t miss the follow-up interview with Dr. Jeff Kukucka on Friday 4/12/2024 as he walks us through his research in implicit human bias in forensic science.**

Thanks for listening! If you want to support us, you can follow/subscribe on your favorite podcast listening app. While you’re there, please rate and leave us a review – we would really appreciate it! You can also visit our website at www.wildcidepodcast.com (MERCH NOW AVAILABLE ON OUR WEBSITE!)

Make sure to get updates by following us on Instagram (@wildcidepodcast) and Facebook (Wildcide Podcast). Don’t forget Wildcide Wednesdays- new episodes drop every Wednesday at 6am EST. Interviews with drop every other Friday at 6am EST.

​​Art for the podcast was created by Kelly Steen. Editing/Production for the podcast by Bltzwolff.

​WILDCIDE Podcast and any content posted is presented solely for general informational, educational, and entertainment purposes. The use of information on this podcast or materials linked from this podcast or website is at the user’s own risk. It is not intended as a substitute for the advice of a physician, professional coach, psychotherapist, or other qualified professional, diagnosis, or treatment. Users should not disregard or delay in obtaining medical advice for any medical or mental health condition they may have and should seek the assistance of their healthcare professionals for any such conditions.

References:

Cassels, L. (2020, January 28). Compensation claim filed for man freed after 11 years on death row • Florida Phoenix. Florida Phoenix. https://floridaphoenix.com/2020/01/27/compensation-claim-filed-for-man-freed-after-11-years-on-death-row/

Eighteenth Judicial Circuit Court. (2019b, February 8). Welcome to the state attorney’s Office, 18th Judicial Circuit: Welcome To The State Attorneys Office, 18th Judicial Circuit: https://www.sa18.org/own/sitewide/STATES%20RESPONSE.pdf

FSU Law Library. (2008, February 7). Digitized legal collections. Digitized Legal Collections. https://law.fsu.edu/research-center/digitized-legal-collections

Possley, M. (2018, November 11). CLEMENTE AGUIRRE-JARQUIN. Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin - National Registry of Exonerations. https://www.law.umich.edu/special/exoneration/Pages/casedetail.aspx?caseid=5406

Speck, E. (2020, January 7). Man exonerated in 2004 Double murder files federal lawsuit against Seminole County. WKMG. https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2020/01/07/man-exonerated-in-2004-double-murder-files-federal-lawsuit-against-seminole-county/

Sullivan, D. (2018, November 16). In Tampa, man embarks on life after years on death row. Tampa Bay Times. https://www.tampabay.com/features/humaninterest/in-tampa-man-embarks-on-life-after-years-on-death-row-20181116/

Supreme Court of Florida. (2009, March 26). Findlaw’s Supreme Court of Florida case and opinions. https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/fl-supreme-court/1045628.html. https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/fl-supreme-court/1045628.html