From Sumptuary Laws to Senate Suits: Dress Codes in History and Today

Stanford Legal

From the recent Senate dress code controversy to landmark legal cases, explore the nuanced intersection of the law and fashion, gender identity, and cultural expression. Join Pam Karlan and Rich Ford to delve into the intricate world of dress codes and the law, examining their historical roots and contemporary implications.The discussion begins with the recent Senate dress code controversy, unravelling the political and cultural factors at play. The hosts delve into the historical context, touching on sumptuary laws in medieval Europe and the Great Male Renunciation, offering valuable insights into the evolution of societal norms. Pivotal legal cases such as Jespersen v. Harrah’s and the challenges surrounding gender-specific dress codes and religious exemptions are dissected. Throughout the episode, engaging anecdotes and thought-provoking analysis provide listeners with a profound understanding of the legal complexities shaping our attire, identities, and societies.

Connect:

• Episode Transcripts >>> Stanford Legal Podcast Website
• Stanford Legal Podcast >>> LinkedIn Page
• Rich Ford >>> Twitter/X
• Stanford Law School >>> Twitter/X
• Stanford Law Magazine >>> Twitter/X
• Rich Ford's Book >>> Dress Codes: How the Laws of Fashion Made History

Chapters:

(00:00:00) Introduction

Pam Karlan and Rich Ford introduce the episode, Rich’s book 'Dress Codes, How the Laws of Fashion Made History’

(00:01:08) Senate Dress Code Drama

The recent elimination and subsequent reinstatement of the dress code in the U.S. Senate; specific mention of John Fetterman & Kyrsten Sinema.

(00:03:55) Solicitor General's Office

Analysis of the gendered nature of dress code challenges faced by the first female Solicitor General, Elena Kagan, in navigating the formal attire expectations.

(00:06:53) Dress Code Messages

Examination of the message behind politicians & tech industry dress choices to send a message

(00:09:47) The Personal Side of Dress Codes

Rich Ford's personal experiences and anecdotes, including his participation in Esquire's Best Dressed Real Man contest.

(00:10:39) Sumptuary Laws and Fashion in the Middle Ages

Discussion on medieval sumptuary laws and their detailed regulations on attire, reflecting societal hierarchies and power dynamics.

(00:12:27) Earrings as Signifiers: From Medieval Italy to Modern Campuses

Exploration of earrings as symbols, from distinguishing religious groups in medieval Italy to contemporary cultural identifiers on college campuses.

(00:15:04) The Great Masculine Renunciation and Gendered Attire

Examination of the historical shift in men's fashion during the 1700s, marking the beginning of subdued, practical attire and its implications on gender roles.

(00:17:30) Modern Title VII Challenges

In-depth analysis of modern legal cases involving gender and dress codes specifically discussing Jespersen v. Harrah, and the Amy Steven’s case involving transgender rights & how gender expression is changing.

(00:22:18) Sex, Race, & Dress Codes

Reflection on cases where hairstyles were the center of dress-code legal cases, particularly affecting members of a particular race.

(00:26:28) Religious Exemptions and Dress Codes: A Global Perspective

Exploration of religious exemptions from dress codes, and the clash between cultural expression and state regulations.

(00:27:02) Conclusion