Best Showtunes Podcasts (2024)

1
"Locker Room Meat and Showtunes" w/ Keegan Hirst 52:21

16d ago52:21

52:21

This week Keegan Hirst (Happy Healthy Homo Podcast) shows gay versatility that will shock and AWE. Sure, he was the first professional rugby league player to come out as gay, but more importantly...he played Bill Sykes in his high school production of OLIVER! A theater queen! We also discuss: - water park dads - hosting a gay podcast with your gay …

1
Performance 790

2h ago

—

Listen to the Show Right Click to Save Guests St Edwards Mary Moody Northen Macbeth KOOP Fall Membership Drive What We Talked About The Roommate Emmys Real Women have Curves Adrien Warren/Tina Turner LA – Fiddler with Jason Alexander Hair Artifacts Stereophonic extends Thank you to Dean Johanesen, lead singer of "The Human Condition" who gave us pe…

1
“Family Trauma and Messy Hookups” w/ Cody Rigsby 54:26

1h ago54:26

54:26

Fitness celeb and professional chatty binch Cody Rigsby joins us for a gay ass ep full of therapy, sluttery, and more. In addition to his podcast "Tactful Pettiness," we discuss: - how to remove yourself from an unwanted hookup - doing Dancing With The Stars with a Spice Girl - the insanity of the Peloton pandemic boom - a way to forgive your fam w…

1
Performance 789

1d ago

—

Listen to the Show Right Click to Save Guests City Theatre Into The Woods The VORTEX Funny, Like an Abortion What We Talked About RIP Jame Earl Jones James Earl Jones in Pictures New York shows this fall Shows around the country Skyscraper musical Broadway Votes 2 queers a lesbian meets at Home depot Desantis cuts hurts schools All In Lear deBesson…

1
"My Friend Casts Survivor, The Amazing Race and Big Brother" w/ Jesse Tannenbaum 50:05

8d ago50:05

50:05

This week, Emmy Nominated Casting Director Jesse Tannenbaum (SURVIVOR, THE AMAZING RACE, BIG BROTHER, and more) helps us answer the age-old question: why are we so obsoosed with reality televish? We also discuss: - dating a famous pop star - Legally Blonde: The Search For Elle Woods - getting outed while studying abroad - how Jon Lovett booked 'Sur…

1
"Blowjobs In Heaven" w/ Margaret Cho 54:47

9d ago54:47

54:47

GAG! This week Margaret Cho (icon, legend) makes her LONG awaited Gay Ass Podcast debut after performing in Gay Ass Live Show at Netflix Is A Joke Fest. We get into: -the best bl*wj*b on Fire Island -watching Carrie Bradshaw be fashion roadkill -her love of tops -gay cruises (with gay icons) -the character actRESS of all acTRESSes Plus! We welcome …

1
"The Forbidden Fruit of VH1" w/ Sam Sanders 59:11

23d ago59:11

59:11

Category is: Podcast Royalty! Sam Sanders (Vibe Check) makes his long awaited gay ass pod debut and honey his ADVICE? Please be seated. We get into: -navigating friendship breakups -battling the boys of Las Cultch -the 78 year old character actress still kicking her face -sad straight couples -fucking your personal trainer Plus! Oh Mary’s Hannah So…

1
"Trust Your Gay Gut" w/ Gary Janetti 51:55

1M ago51:55

51:55

This week Eric’s handsome hero Gary Janetti does the thing he’s been dreading all week: coming on this gay podcast. In addition to his recent NY Times Best Seller “We Are Experiencing A Slight Delay,” we discuss: -the one season wonder “Bette” -making out with Brad Goreski within thirty minutes of meeting -the soap opera that proved gay people exis…

1
"Twink Hercules Made Me Gay" w/ Monét X Change 44:10

1M ago44:10

44:10

Season five is HERE! And for this gay ass premiere we welcome the icon, the legend, THE...Monét X Change! In addition to celebrating her new series MONET'S SLUMBER PARTY on Dropout TV, we discuss: -the problem with dick pills -making your own gay shit happen -f*ckable cartoons -the Broadway show Monét should step into Plus! We welcome Ryan Rudewicz…

1
Episode 9: Showtune My Heart: "God Help the Outcasts" with iCritic 41:14

2M ago41:14

41:14

Welcome to the first episode of a new ongoing bonus series called "Showtune My Heart," in which Toon My Heart host Tracy Herold and a guest will discuss a song from an animated film from a Christian faith perspective. In this episode, Tracy is joined by Kevin T. Rodriguez, also known as iCritic, to discuss the song "God Help the Outcasts," written …

1
Episode 8: First Impressions: Inside Out 2 17:13

3M ago17:13

17:13

Disney Pixar's Inside Out 2 is smashing box office records left and right, but is the sequel worth all the hype and a fitting follow up to the studio's beloved original "emotional rollercoaster" of a movie? Host Tracy and daughter Darcy weigh in with their thoughts (and feelings, of course) about 2024's first $1 billion box office film, and the ret…

1
"Texts From Our Bullies" w/ Johnnie Ingram 58:28

3M ago58:28

58:28

For the FINAL ep of the season we go out with a handsome bang-- Johnnie Ingram (Emmy winning co-creator of WE'RE HERE) stops by gay ass pod for a quintessential gay ass ep- honest, horny, and hilar. We discuss: -shirts vs skins -how BOTH of us recently heard from our bullies -casting the queens in WE’RE HERE -the men of montreal plus we ask, "shoul…

1
"Frociaggine" w/ Vinny Thomas 53:00

3M ago53:00

53:00

Genius comedian/actor/writer Vinny Thomas comes on the podcast only three years after being asked. Come on, edgelord! We discuss: -the pope saying f*g -Andy Cohen money -the bird from I, Tanya -Chicago (the city) -the cast of Finding Nemo plus we ask, "did you know Rose Byrne was Australian?" ********************************************************…

1
Episode 7: Inside Out and the Value of Sadness 1:28:54

3M ago1:28:54

1:28:54

Pixar is an animation studio known for producing films that tug on the heartstrings, but perhaps its most emotional movie-- quite literally-- is Inside Out. Now, with the release of Inside Out 2 just around the corner, Toon My Heart host Tracy Herold is taking a closer look at the original, and the lessons it has to teach us about emotional and men…

1
"A Sturdy Thigh" w/ Jake Cornell 42:49

3M ago42:49

42:49

Comedian/heartthrob Jake Cornell comes on the podcast THREE YEARS after his first appearance, and oh how these f*gs have grown. We discuss: -tickets for Pride (being pro or anti) -finding your gay family -Jake's DMs -Gaga's pharmaceutical journey plus we ask, "what are you manifesting in terms of LOVE?" *********************************************…

1
"We’re Soaring (Flying)" w/ Adam Bradley 35:11

4M ago35:11

35:11

Today, herstory is made. Sub-Radio lead singer (and bisexual king) Adam Bradley makes his Gay Ass Debut. In 2022, Adam and the band took over the internet with "Stacy's Dad," a cover of our favorite song from 2003. Lusting over hot dads? Come on gay ass pod, babe. We also discuss: -Troy and Gabriella -coming out late -a cappella -how Sub-Radio land…

1
"Some Gay Little Soup" w/ Terry Hu 33:48

4M ago33:48

33:48

For this BONUS EP, Terry Hu goes down memory lane as we dig up some gay high school DRAMA. We also get into: -the girthmaster -Terry's new movie 'Prom Dates' on Hulu -playing female roles as a non binary actor -tumblr plus we ask, "what gay foods did our moms eat while pregnant with us?" *************************************************************…

1
“Crystal Bitch Manifestress” w/ Baby Reindeer's Nava Mau 30:36

4M ago30:36

30:36

Nava Mau is STUNNING in the Netflix global hit "Baby Reindeer" and somehow found the time to do That's A Gay Ass Mother Tucking Podcast. We discuss: -manifesting "Baby Reindeer" -drag queens in Mexico -girly pop -meeting Jessica Gunning before seeing her as Martha on set plus we ask, "are you a crystal bitch?" **************************************…

1
"International Male" w/ Jesse Tyler Ferguson 56:14

4M ago56:14

56:14

It's okay to meet your heroes y'alll!!! Jesse Tyler Ferguson makes his gay ass debut with an episode that will make you spell S-L-A-Y (the theater queens get it). In addition to Jesse's podcast DINNER'S ON ME, we discuss: -Jesse's appearance on Watch What Happens Live -DMing his husband Justin on twitter dot com -underwear catalogues -TV money -Pat…

1
"Instagram Is A Dating App" w/ James Scully 1:00:42

4M ago1:00:42

1:00:42

James Scully (of 'Fire Island' and OH, MARY!) fame makes his first appearance of MANY on this gay ass pod. This delicious man and I discuss: -James' musical theater BFA -being gay in Texas -OH MARY!'s celeb backstage list -meeting boyfriend Julio Torres plus we ask, "can underwear parties heal?" *****************************************************…

1
Episode 6: First Impressions: Migration 10:44

4M ago10:44

10:44

Landing in theaters late in 2023, and now available on Peacock and other streaming networks, Migration flew under a lot of people's radar. But while the latest animated film from Illumination, the studio behind Despicable Me, Minions, The Secret Life of Pets, Sing, and The Super Mario Bros. Movie didn't soar to the same levels of box-office success…

1
"Do We Have The Same Therapist?" w/ Matt Gould 39:09

4M ago39:09

39:09

A Jewish gay on Broadway? I'm in HEAVEN. Lempicka composer/co-writer Matt Gould stops by for this special BONUS EP(!!). In addition to a gay Broadway conversay, we discuss: -the gayest thing we took our high school girlfriend's to see -how Seymours have gotten too hot -having a fireman dad -leaning into the grey area plus we ask, "do you have tix t…

1
"Shirtless Cooking" w/ Jon Kung 51:59

5M ago51:59

51:59

We're celebrating a FULL PAGE feature in Variety Magazine with a guest who is not just a snack, he is the hole meal. Cookbook author and social media star Jon Kung (@jonkung) has been gay all over the globe and he has the stories to prove it. We discuss: -getting caught in a Hong Kong gay bar -dating someone with the same name -horny cartoons -a ce…

1
"Skinny Dip" w/ Kevin McHale 56:59

5M ago56:59

56:59

This week television darling and podcast star Kevin McHale (Glee) stops by for a top ten episode of the ages (...gayges). In addition to a Beyoncé TED Talk, we get into: -being closeted while filming "Glee" -Kevin as a horny toddler -the meet cute of the century -that Lea Michele meme -Charles Melton plus Eric asks, "did you tuck on Secret Celebrit…

1
"RUN, F*****!" w/ John Early 1:05:58

5M ago1:05:58

1:05:58

John Early and Eric Williams met in college fifteen years ago, and they have decided to hash out their long & complicated history on this podcast. Topics include: -"Paris" -steam room sucking -singing Britney on network television -cursed auditions -carving out your own path plus Eric asks, "what really happened with RACHEL?" **********************…

1
"Girl Cave" w/ VINCINT 53:29

5M ago53:29

53:29

Pop star (and self proclaimed rom com freak) VINCINT makes his long awaited gay ass debut and honey? She has the range. We discuss: -Eric's obsession with Charlie Puth -how gospel is gay -Jessie J -Beyoncé -forging your own path plus we ask, "what did JoJo Siwa say?" ********************************************************************** New MERCH i…

1
"Pisser On The Dance Floor" w/ Dakota Wright 58:39

5M ago58:39

58:39

For to drink, Dakota Wright is this week's gay ass cocktail / perfect guest. He not only makes incred videos with husband Jackson at America's beloved chain restaurants, he also has beautiful unfiltered stories meant for this gay gay pod. We get into: -hoe tales -being gay in the south -Lindsay Lohan's downfall -the villain that is Bethenny Frankel…

1
"Carol Fetishist" w/ Tracy E. Gilchrist 52:27

6M ago52:27

52:27

Legendary Lesbian™️ Tracy E. Gilchrist has interviewed just about every celebrity in the world as the former editor in chief of The Advocate (and current VP/Executive Producer of Entertainment), and now it's HER time to answer the Q's. We dive into: -summer camp -the time Kate Winslet almost made Tracy pass out -what really happens during the AIDS …

1
Happy Hour #106: On Wednesdays we Podcast Pink - ‘Mean Girls’ 1:56:11

6M ago1:56:11

1:56:11

Get in, losers. We’re talking about Mean Girls. From it’s earliest self-help origins all the way through to todays “the-trailer-didn’t-say-it-was-a-musical” movie, Jimi and Tommy contemplate the traps of adaptations, memes from old movies, the Jimmy (and Jimi) awards, and Tina Fey’s (literall) love letter to high school theatre. It is, most definit…

1
"The Cookie Closet" w/ Bridger Winegar 59:31

6M ago59:31

59:31

"You shouldn't have!," we tell Bridger Winegar (the 'I Said No Gifts' host), as he gifts this pod with his gorgeous gay presence. After discussing whether Bridger would be a faithful or a traitor, we get into: -the Oprah talk show performance that birthed a gay boy -introducing your first boyfriend to the family -the Mormon home -cookies plus we as…

1
"Underwhelmed By Men" w/ Parvati Shallow 1:04:50

6M ago1:04:50

1:04:50

The Peoples' Princess Parvati Shallow (The Traitors, Survivor) is here, queer, and gay ass guest of the YEAR. While healing from whiplash, we discuss: -the headband origin story -Parvati's first (unbelievably hot) kiss with Mae Martin -cult life -how to bet on yourself plus I ask, "...is Peter a dick?" **********************************************…

1
"The Horny Field" w/ Leland 52:42

6M ago52:42

52:42

The Hills Are Alive With The Sound Of LELAND! The Pop icon and Rusical Overlord joins us this week to dive deep on Troye Sivan, Drag Race, and a cute visit to Cher's house in Malibu. We also get into: -homemade caramel frappucinos -the character actress Leland sees in Larchmont -being "one song away" -Gwyneth Goes Skiing plus we ask, "did you also …

1
"Throw The Crown In The Trash" w/ Omar Rudberg 15:18

6M ago15:18

15:18

On this special BONUS EP, international heartthrob Omar Rudberg (Young Royals) comes by to celebrate today's premiere of the final season on Netflix. We get into: -who Omar blames his queerness on -high school isolation -huge music news -who he's most excited to see at the Oscars plus we ask, "...would you marry into the British Royal Family?" ****…

1
Episode 5: First Impressions: Disney's Wish 17:53

6M ago17:53

17:53

Disney's Wish didn't get a very warm welcome from critics or audiences when it came out in theaters last year, but does it have any redeeming qualities that might make it worth seeing now that it's out on streaming and blu-ray? In this bonus "First Impressions" episode, host Tracy and daughter Darcy (age 8) give their initial thoughts on Disney's n…

1
"Honey, That's The Devil" w/ Roz Hernandez 58:31

7M ago58:31

58:31

Ghost Huntress Roz Hernandez (Living for the Dead) takes a break from the dead to make us scream "I LIVE!!!" We discuss: -queer hoarding -having a clown for a dad -Community Theatre -homoflexible gays -exorcisms plus we ask, "whose your queer elder?" ********************************************************************** For this week's bonus episod…

1
"Girl, F*ck You" w/ Luxx Noir London 42:15

7M ago42:15

42:15

Luxx Noir London (RuPaul's Drag Race) gives her take on this current season and Eric starts subconsciously saying "boots". We also discuss: -that famous What Would You Do clip: "YOU'RE BI" -Lux's fight with Poo Crave (not a typo) -having your parents watch you on TV -JLo's acting plus we ask, "is Plain Jane giving fun shade or c*nty gay?" (PS this …

1
"The Beauty of Men" w/ Gideon Glick 54:38

7M ago54:38

54:38

Gideon Glick (Maestro) gives PERFECT pod this week and it is music to our gay ass ears. In addition to discussing Gideon's bar mitzvah theme, we get into: -coming out via blackmail -cruising in Paris -how incestuous the cast of Spring Awakening was -Gideon's very gay wedding and more. Plus we ask, "why do gays really love character actresses?" ****…

1
"Dead Elphaba" w/ Jessica Vosk 1:00:00

7M ago1:00:00

1:00:00

Jessica Vosk (Wicked) is a Jersey slut and her boyfriend has a perfect butt. We talk about that AND -the BTS of being Elphaba on Broadway -awful exes -the time Jessica tried to get dicked down in Missouri -Waiting For Guffman plus we ask, "what will bring Jessica back to Broadway?" Ooh-ah-ah-ah! *****************************************************…

1
"Midwestern Trauma and Porn" w/ Kevin James Thornton 49:55

8M ago49:55

49:55

A horny midwesterner with trauma? AGAIN? Yes, internet and global comedy star Kevin James Thornton comes on the podcast to answer "is there a god?" "do mannequins have areolas?" and other pressing questions. We also get into: -Kevin's access to Playgirl as a kid -sad acting school teachers -Cosmo Magazine's (f*cked up) advice -getting older and giv…

1
Happy Hour #105: New Podcast, New Podcast - ‘On the Town’ 2:05:57

8M ago2:05:57

2:05:57

The Bronx is up, the Battery's down, and Jimi and Tommy are right here delving into the Americana classic of a musical On the Town. Lenoard Bernstein (or is it Bernstein), Betty Comden (the bombshell that she is) and Adolph Green (he’s there too) have devised a wonderful, timeless(?) classic in this show which might, indeed, be the FIRST true music…

1
"Dick Hunger" w/ Dan Savage 1:05:58

8M ago1:05:58

1:05:58

And Just Like That, we're back! Dream guest Dan Savage brings in the new season with an instant classique ep. While Dan has fought for LGBTQ rights and fostered honest discussions about sex for decades, he also happens to be hilarious and a fucking fox. We get into: -living with your husband's boyfriend -why demisexuality is not an orientation -the…

1
Podcats Is BACK!! 55:08

8M ago55:08

55:08

After a brief (three-to-four-year) hiatus, Dan and Ej are back to talk all things Jellicle. Much has changed during this time (one of us got married! One of us had another kid! Both of us worked together on a less successful podcast!). But one thing that has not changed is our unwavering commitment to all things ALW and Cats-related. In this episod…

1
Episode 4: Encanto and Grace vs. Works 1:07:19

9M ago1:07:19

1:07:19

In this episode of Toon My Heart podcast, host Tracy Herold is talking about Bruno-- and the entire amazing Madrigal family! Disney's Encanto worked its way into the hearts of streaming viewers across the world when it landed on Disney+ on Christmas Eve 2021, with its relatable characters, way too catchy tunes, and unique setting and story. But is …

1
"Sneak Peek" w/ Eric Williams 4:46

10M ago4:46

4:46

While there is no gay ass pod episode this week, enjoy a preview of this week's patreon bonus ep! For the full thing, head to patreon.com/gayasspodcast For $5 a month you get: Bonus Episodes Live Show Video Select Video Episodes and more! In this sneak peek, Eric grapples with running into Diane Keaton in Palm Springs over thanksgiving. ***********…

1
"Kindle Porn" w/ Chaz May and Kendahl Landreth 48:26

10M ago48:26

48:26

Internet stars Kendahl Landreth and Chaz May discuss their viral hit, relationship sh*t, and their inspir-gay-tions. We get into: -meeting for the first time on a (tragic) zoom call -boys in dance class -"reading books" -the hottest person in the Grinch plus we ask, "is Chaz's Candice Bergen impression good?" ***************************************…

1
"Lesbian Belle" w/ Jackie Cox 49:27

10M ago49:27

49:27

Jackie Cox (RuPaul's Drag Race) makes her gay ass debut and the bells are JINGLIN'. We discuss: -Jackie and Jan’s Jingle Jam -her first kiss (at Disneyland) -BTS from Whoopi Goldberg's appearance on Jackie's season -singing trawma plus we ask... "did YOU know that about Whoopi?" (listen and find out.) ***********************************************…

1
"Scarlet Takes A Tumble" w/ Jason Michael Snow 53:15

11M ago53:15

53:15

Jason Michael Snow (Book of Mormon) makes his gay ass podcast debut with tales of Broadway, sex, and a Carrie Bradshaw wig. In addition to wondering how Scarlet (of Takes A Tumble) is doing, we discuss: -who was f*cking at Book of Mormon -Clue -open relationship rules -the magic of a zig zag part -Avril Lavigne plus we ask, "are showmances bad?" **…

1
"Cowboy Pool Party" w/ John Halbach 47:58

11M ago47:58

47:58

This week, the handsome John Halbach ("Eastsiders") takes a break from his gay ass job to do this gay ass pod. Before he reveals the character actress that must be protected at all costs, we get into: -8th grade bullies -gaying up two desert homes with your gay husband -Eastsiders' problematic porn star -The Brady Bunch Movie -serving Nathan Lane A…

1
"Céline Dion" w/ Bowen Yang (Re-Release!) 46:17

11M ago46:17

46:17

Mon dieu! We are celebrating next week's live show with a re-release of Dame Bowen Yang's gorgeous ep. This was recorded exactly two years ago and what a way to celebrate our anniversary <3 We get into: -scheduling drama -Proud Gay Oompa Loompa -Celine Dion's chokehold over Quebec -Kim Kardashian's week at SNL plus we ask, "will people like FIRE IS…

1
"Mouth Stuff" w/ Sam Leicht 58:19

11M ago58:19

58:19

Fitness star and theater f*g Sam Leicht (@leichtning) is here to discuss his favorite Elphaba, how he met his stun of a hus, and his new gorgeous PrideFit app. We also get into: -gay pilots -the problem with Fire Island -overcoming fitness trawma -Sam's gay Wisconsin wedding plus we ask Sam, "how can you be hot AND nice?" **************************…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Showtunes Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide