An obsessive fan, a fanfiction author, and a first time viewer go through every episode of Supernatural.
…
continue reading
Join Dr. Chrisha Anderson and Catherine McKenna for complex feelings, fangirling, and fun as they begin a second season of their Supernatural podcast--focused on the new series, "The Winchesters." With a pro-Destiel and queer Dean outlook, and special attention to LGBTQ+ content, they hope you'll come along for the ride. Special thanks and credit to our amazing contributors: Logo: Gio_Gui Music: VooDooBlooze Disclaimer: The information presented in this podcast is intended to be for entertai ...
…
continue reading
Welcome to the Witchytalk Podcast podcast, where amazing things happen. Cover art photo provided by Sharon McCutcheon on Unsplash: https://unsplash.com/@sharonmccutcheon
…
continue reading
See you in the new year!By Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
Sam and Dean disagree what to do with Jack while Jack is winning all of ours hearts. Also a new Price of Hell is in town who may or may not be Colonel Sanders. We discuss how much we love Jack, Asmodeus, and the best line Buck-Leming ever wrote. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
The Nephilim is born, his name is Jack, and we love him! Seriously, what else is there to say? (How about all the interruptions from the youths?) Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
End of Season 12, time for our watchalong episode! Get your copy and sync up with us! We discuss the bad Crowley writing that we have to deal with again, how the redheads should work together, and how hard it was for demons to make pop culture references before writing. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading
The British Men of Letters have been defeated and it's time to finally deal with that whole nehpilim thing. We discuss how different this episode felt compared to the rest of the season, how Jess didn't see any of that coming, and what would have been the ultimate Martha episode. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading
Sam and Dean are trapped in the bunker with Toni and time is running out. That is until they come up with the coolest way to escape! Oh and it's time to be done with the British Men of Letters. We discuss how Toni serves no purpose, electrodes means science, and give all the details about the concrete wall scene. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Fa…
…
continue reading

1
12.21 - There's Something About Mary
1:10:32
1:10:32
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:10:32We hate the opening, we hate Toni, and we hate how Crowley is being written. We think Samantha Smith's acting is fantastic though! We discuss yet another death in the woods, cottage-core apartments, and how we think nephilim should live their lives. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading

1
12.20 - Twigs & Twine & Tasha Banes
1:08:46
1:08:46
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:08:46Sam and Dean go help Max and Alicia Banes after their mom went on a hunting trip and hasn't been home in a few days. Elsewhere, Mary carries the mytharc as the B plot. We discuss how Tasha looks very young to have adult children (and do some math), how it's impossible to think like Cas, and have questions about the shifter's accent. Patreon Bluesky…
…
continue reading
Cas finally comes back, steals the colt, and goes after Kelly. Problems come up along the way. We discuss how Dean made Cas a mixed tape, that Cas has a mixed tape from Dean, and cannot get over this mixed taped. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
Sam and Dean get sent a case from not-really-Mick and end up having to deal with a god, all while the British Men of Letters bug the bunker. We discuss how this episode is easily forgettable, that this is the season of dying in the woods, and question why we don't see Cas in Heaven. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading
In an episode with a lot of scene jumping, we do our best to keep up with all the different plot threads that includes Mick's flashbacks, Kelly's doctor visit, Lucifer faking out Crowley in a way that's hard to believe, and the failed attempt at stopping Dagon. We want to know why Mick Davies went to Hogwarts, was an orphan from a Charles Dickens n…
…
continue reading
Mick wants to tag along on a hunt, the guys run into Claire, and the guys like how The British Men of Letters have money. We discuss our recent travels, how the episode makes us nervous, and have questions about weremice. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading

1
12.15 - Somewhere Between Heaven and Hell
54:24
54:24
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
54:24Crowley shows Lucifer why he's more prepared while Sam and Dean have to hunt down a rogue hell hound. We discuss Jess and PG's visit together, how hell hounds work, and the show's not so subtle nod to The Walking Dead. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
Mary convinces Sam to listen to the British Men of Letters and learn of their plans to wipe out vampires. The problem is the Alpha Vampire knows about it too and he wants a word. We discuss how Dean goes on a date with Ketch, our excitement to see the Alpha Vampire again, and the problem with biometrics. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading
Unfortunately, we will not be coming back this month from our hiatus. As a thank you for your patience, here is a free bonus episode from our Patreon.By Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
We have several different trips planned and will be taking a break before coming back later in July.
…
continue reading
Lots of storylines that don't exactly come together in the end despite the music's best efforts. We talk about Mary's mom voice, how stupid Crowley is being, and all the time travel problems. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading

1
12.12 - Stuck in the Middle (With You)
1:43:31
1:43:31
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:43:31Mary lies about working with the British Men of Letters so that Sam, Dean, and Cas will come with her and Wally the Red Shirt in hunting a demon. But this is no ordinary demon! Martha is back as we point out the Tarantino references, our head canon of where Charlie is, and how the lying comes from Mary's side of the family. Patreon Bluesky Instagra…
…
continue reading
Dean has been hit with a nasty spell from a dying witch and he begins to forget everything he knows, everyone he cares for, and soon how to breathe. It's really funny until it's really sad. We discuss the movie that inspired the title, the awesome bunny on screen, and the amazing waffles. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading

1
12.10 - Lily Sunder Has Some Regrets
1:24:09
1:24:09
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:24:09Cas is called to go help an old friend and has to once again learn that Sam and Dean are the only friends he can trust. We are joined by Opal, one of our winners from the Fandom Trumps hate auction as we discuss Jess's mistake, the production design details, and how you don't remove certain pizza toppings. Opal on AO3: https://archiveofourown.org/u…
…
continue reading
Sam and Dean are being held by the US government in a secret facility. With no one knowing where they are, they resort to desperate measures in order to escape. One with cosmic consequences. We discuss how great Camp is, how attractive Mick is, and why the characters forget to call Cas. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading
Lucifer has decided to go bigger and that means getting the President of the United States to say yes! We talk about malls and how so many are just sad, how long it took Jess to understand the title, and how getting pregnant doesn't work like that. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
Lucifer is back and wants to live that rockstar lifestyle without actually playing any of the music. What could go wrong? We discuss forks, our strange moment of silence, and twerking. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading

1
12.06 - Celebrating the Life of Asa Fox
1:12:29
1:12:29
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:12:29After the death of a hunter Jody was close with, Sam and Dean join her at his wake only to find Mary got him started in the hunting world. We complain how these hunters die easily, question how Asa never heard of the Winchesters, and how everyone needs a Talkboy Tape Recorder. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading
Not wanting to think about his feelings, Dean finds a case that leads them back to the Thule. (But not enough Aaron Bass.) We talk pogs, Jensen's great physical comedy, and awkward talking to ourselves. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
Sam and Dean learn once again that people can be worse than monsters when they discover a girl with powers she can barely control. We like the episode, hate the British Men of Letters, and how everyone has mommy issues. Like everyone. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
Mary finds a case, Sam and Dean are overprotective, and Cas and Crowley go on their own Lucifer-hunting adventure while Rowena is stuck helping the archangel. We read our first podcast review in over a year, love Mary's haircut, and can't stand the cold open couple. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading
Sam? Still abducted! Dean and Mary? Still awkward! Cas? Still delivering great lines! Crowley? Still making Rowena's life miserable! We discuss how this episode upset Jess, the Buck-Leming Bingo Card, and how Rowena always looks good no matter what. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
Mary is back, it's all kinds of complicated, and the British Men of Letters think they know how to break Sam Winchester. Amateurs! We are instantly sent into a nostalgia spiral, talk about how much we already dislike the British Men of Letters, and how wonderful Mary is. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading
Time for the season 11 watchalong where we get a much-improved episode from the same writing duo from our previous watchalong, but we still have lots of questions for some of the choices (mostly from the awful husband.) Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
We get to return to doing a watchalong and go back to season 10 (which we skipped during the WGA and SAG-AFTRA strikes). It's time to rewatch one of the worst episodes in this show's history and we are not kind to it. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading
Amara has beat Chuck and reality is about to end. Team God is desperate so they decide to turn Dean into a bomb, but he would rather use his words. We read two emails from listeners and get into our fandom histories, discuss how Jess never saw this ending coming, and found ourselves wanting more from Season 11. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Face…
…
continue reading
God and Lucifer are reunited and it's time to...start with "I feel" statements? We discuss how Jess's dream is crushed, how Garth is needed for all the things, and the Mega Coven! Want to join us for an episode? Check out Fandom Trumps Hate: https://fandomtrumpshate.dreamwidth.org/ https://fandomtrumpshate.tumblr.com/ Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumb…
…
continue reading
God is stepping in to help the boys, but Sam and Dean are convinced they'll need to rescue Lucifer in order to have a chance against Amara. Oh and Metatron is a hero now? We discuss the clunky pacing, question whether or not that was really Kevin, and imagine God as a bad roommate. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading
Chuck is back and he's ready to bring his final book. God: An Autobiography. New book means he needs Metatron's help in editing and doesn't seem to care that Amara is going to end the world. Jess can't believe it happened as we discuss Robbie Thompson's fantastic final episode and farewell to the fans. (Apologies for some dog barking in the backgro…
…
continue reading

1
17.6: "The Winchesters'" Finale - The Music Story
1:38:24
1:38:24
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:38:24We'd love to hear from you! Reach out to us via this link to let us know what you're thinking! Join Chrisha and Catherine for a chaotic episode where all of the things that can happen in the background at Catherine's apartment do while they try to talk all about the music in the finale of The Winchesters. Topics range from just how exactly Dean did…
…
continue reading
Sam and Dean just can't find Amara because the writers won't let them. But they will get to take a case that one of them will say isn't a case until it's clear it is a case. We've lost track of how many times this happens. We read an email from a listener which prompts us to discuss favorite holiday gifts and then discuss this rather lackluster epi…
…
continue reading
Everyone is desperate to stop Amara. Crowely, Lucifer, the angels, and even Rowena. (Totally not dead, by the way.) Like a person lost in a desert who finally comes across water, we are so thankful the myth arc has returned even if it is the awkward writing of Buck-Leming. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr Facebook…
…
continue reading

1
17.5: "The Winchesters'" Finale - The Akrida Story
1:14:49
1:14:49
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:14:49We'd love to hear from you! Reach out to us via this link to let us know what you're thinking! CONTENT WARNING: There is a discussion of suicide and suidical ideation as it pertains to the characters of Akrida Kyle & Lata from The Winchesters and Dean from Supernatural. Please be aware and kind to yourselves, Wayward Friends. The portion that discu…
…
continue reading
Sam and Dean take on ANOTHER random case because they have no leads on Amara and the show thinks it can fool us into thinking Sam or Dean will die. We're missing the myth arc so we give this episode a bit of a hard time as we get distracted by PG's Zoom screen (a lot), relate to Dean yelling at a tree, and wonder about this urgent care. Patreon Blu…
…
continue reading

1
17.4: "The Winchesters'" Finale - The Jack Problem (Plus Baby, Cas, & A Bit Of Destiel)
1:17:56
1:17:56
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:17:56We'd love to hear from you! Reach out to us via this link to let us know what you're thinking! In this episode, Chrisha and Catherine start the discussion with Jack and his odd behavior at the end of Supernatural and during The Winchesters' finale before moving on to talk about Baby, The Winchesters' title card and its connection to the Akrida, and…
…
continue reading
In a delightful breath of fresh air, Bobby and Rufus return via flashback to deal with a creature Sam and Dean are also hunting in the present. Jess could not have been happier with this episode as we discuss Sam and Dean's mandatory "we have no leads" conversation, Bobby and Rufus's mandatory "we have no leads" conversation, and how Bobby keeps an…
…
continue reading

1
17.3: "The Winchesters'" Finale - The Dean Story
1:20:16
1:20:16
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:20:16We'd love to hear from you! Reach out to us via this link to let us know what you're thinking! In this episode, Chrisha and Catherine discuss how the car scene at the end of the episode should have been, as a giant infodump, dull--and yet it was not (thanks, Ackles and Thompson!). They also discuss the clapbacks to the Supernatural finale, how dyin…
…
continue reading

1
17.2: "The Winchesters'" Finale - The Monster Club Story
1:35:25
1:35:25
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:35:25We'd love to hear from you! Reach out to us via this link to let us know what you're thinking! In this episode, Chrisha and Catherine catch up on what's been going on behind the scenes with each other, the writers' and actors' strikes and victories, the ongoing trash-fires at networks and streamers, and their gratitude to folks behind The Wincheste…
…
continue reading

1
17.1: Re-Released Reaction Episode - "The Winchesters'" Finale
55:45
55:45
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
55:45We'd love to hear from you! Reach out to us via this link to let us know what you're thinking! Note: This is a re-release of Chrisha and Catherine's reaction episode to The Winchesters' finale, which was originally released on March 8, 2023. A full analysis of "That's No Way to Say Goodbye" will be released in January, 2024. In this raw audio episo…
…
continue reading

1
16.2: "The Winchesters" E12 - Red String Edition
1:13:41
1:13:41
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:13:41We'd love to hear from you! Reach out to us via this link to let us know what you're thinking! In this episode, Chrisha and Catherine look into the theme of mirrors and misdirection, which is particularly prevalent in this episode but has been a running theme throughout the series. They also examine the parallels this episode has with multiple epis…
…
continue reading
We're taking a break and will be back in mid-January! Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading

1
16.1: "The Winchesters" E12 - Witches & Clowns (And Biggest Fears)
1:16:08
1:16:08
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
1:16:08We'd love to hear from you! Reach out to us via this link to let us know what you're thinking! In this episode, Chrisha and Catherine talk about the penultimate episode of The Winchesters, "The Tears of a Clown." Topics include: the concern about Ada considering giving up her soul; Dean's narration about the lies we tell ourselves and what self-lie…
…
continue reading
Sam and Dean pay their respects to an old timer wrestler after his death only to discover there's a demon following the tour. We discuss our random encounters with strangers, Dean's handshake with Gunner, and our first celebrity crushes. Patreon Bluesky Instagram Tumblr FacebookBy Matt, PG, & Jess
…
continue reading

1
15.2: "The Winchesters" E11 - Red String Edition
53:42
53:42
Play later
Play later
Lists
Like
Liked
53:42We'd love to hear from you! Reach out to us via this link to let us know what you're thinking! In this episode, Chrisha and Catherine talk jackets and callbacks, Lata's relationship with Maggie, queer media texts, the implications of this being an autobiographical story (told from Dean's perspective), and the interesting messaging behind the song "…
…
continue reading