Best Breakfast Serial Podcasts (2024)

1
Local Crime and Other Spooky News 1:14:05

3M ago1:14:05

1:14:05

This week on the Kyle, Matt. and Jarred deep dive into a plethora of local crime stories both in the current news cycle and from their own personal histories, as well as a one or 2 non-local but still creepy news stories. Everything from a PA man dressing like Ghostface and killing his neighbor with a chainsaw, possible urban legends or not from Ja…

1
Horror So Mid it's Meh: Sleepy Hollow 2:00:35

4M ago2:00:35

2:00:35

This week the boys put are back to talking about not great Horror Films but this time Kyle and Matt refused to let Jarred call it bad so introducing this newest subcategory of the Horror So [Blank] it's [Blank] Series with Horror So Mid it's Meh. This week the guys talk about the 1999 Tim Burton film Sleepy Hollow with Johnny Depp, Christina Ricci,…

1
Horror So Good It's Great: Smile 2:14:34

4M ago2:14:34

2:14:34

This week the boys put on spin on everyone's favorite Horror Movie Commentary Segment instead of watching and discussing a Horror Movie So Bad It's Good, the guys actually watch a movie that Kyle and Matt had seen and liked, and Jarred...actually wanted to see! This week the guys watch and react to an actual Good Horror film, in this spin on the HS…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good: Dead and Breakfast 2:08:44

4M ago2:08:44

2:08:44

This week the boys return to everyone's favorite movie discussion segment Horror So Bad It's Good. This week Kyle and Matt introduce Jarred to a movie that has a very special nostalgic place in their hearts: Dead and Breakfast. This early 2000s Comedy Musical Fantasy Horror kind of Zombie flick, starring a surprising amount of famous people and at …

1
Spirit Photography 1:12:47

4M ago1:12:47

1:12:47

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt & Jarred are talking about the history of Spirit Photography. From its early beginnings, some of the sorted characters who used the perfect mixture of grief and technological ignorance to convince people they captured the image of the dearly departed, modern-day ghost hunter…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good?: Hellraiser: Hellworld 1:56:40

5M ago1:56:40

1:56:40

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. This week the guys unanimously decided that it was movie day! The return of everyone's favorite horror review series Horror So Bad It's Good. This week the terrible horror film that the boys will be watching and determining if it is really so bad it's doubled all the way back around to…

1
Banshees 1:09:57

5M ago1:09:57

1:09:57

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt & Jarred are back deep diving into more dark history and lore of a well-known cryptid: This week...Banshees. The guys go over the folklore surrounding this possibly fae, maybe an owl, but definitely an omen of death. The guys breakdown how these often misrepresented creature…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good?: Sleep Away Camp 2 2:01:04

5M ago2:01:04

2:01:04

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. This week Matt is indisposed so like a substitute teacher day in grade school, that TV gets rolled in and Kyle and Jarred have a movie day! The return of everyone's favorite horror review series Horror So Bad It's Good. This week the terrible horror film that the boys will be watching …

1
Slide Rock Bolter 1:02:29

6M ago1:02:29

1:02:29

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt, and Jarred discuss: Colorado's Massive Cryptid The "Slide Rock Bolter". This whale-sized Cryptid is said to be responsible for the destruction of an entire town. Surviving on a diet of predominantly tourists, and having nothing to do with the dangers of unregulated capitali…

1
The Stanley Hotel 1:19:54

6M ago1:19:54

1:19:54

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt, and Jarred to discuss: The Stanley Hotel. The Hotel that inspired Stephen King's The Shining. Listen to the guy's deep dive and be distracted while discussing the history of the building as well as the many potential ghosts that very nicely haunt these halls. The guys talk …

1
50 States of Strange: Utah 1:57:23

6M ago1:57:23

1:57:23

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt, and Jarred to continue their ongoing series spanning the strangest lore and crimes from all 50 States this week (The Found Episode: Recorded before our end-of-year break): Utah. We read and react to our first few fan-submitted stories and topics from Carissa ("Leonada") cov…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good?: Silent Night (2012) 1:32:43

7M ago1:32:43

1:32:43

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths, & Mayhem. The Boys are back in 2024 with a brand-new completely unannounced season of Dark Rum. Like seems to happen every year the boys ended their previous season even though they don't have seasons and now they're back, and what better way to celebrate the return than with a return to everyo…

1
The Exorcism of Anna Ecklund 1:31:33

8M ago1:31:33

1:31:33

You all thought spooky season was over? Not on our watch. Tune in on this fine day for a little exorcism story. And remember, be kind and stay weird.By What If I Told You

1
The Great Returm 1:33:26

9M ago1:33:26

1:33:26

We're baaack! And we have missed you more than ever. Tune in for a little life/true crime update before we dive right back into the world of the unknown. Thank you for sticking around. Be Kind and Stay Weird.By What If I Told You

1
The Dark Rum Halloween Special 2023 1:07:51

9M ago1:07:51

1:07:51

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths, & Mayhem. It's Halloween, the one day a year when everyone is on board for spooky so the boys decided to double down on the spookiness. On today's show, we are joined by Rev Dan Todd, founder of New Jersey Ghost Detectives, member of the Sacred Order of St. Michael Order of Exorcists, and Chief…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good: Totally Killer 2:09:48

9M ago2:09:48

2:09:48

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths, & Mayhem. The Boys needed a nice relaxed day so they are back to discuss another horror film so bad it's actually pretty good. This time they are leaving the realm of campy 80's and 90's horror films and take a look at the brand new 2023 Slasher flick with a Time Travel Twist "Totally Killer". …

1
A Paranormal Interview with Jott-Nyx Paranormal Investigators New Jersey 1:30:34

9M ago1:30:34

1:30:34

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt, and Jarred are joined by Tim and Erica of Jott-Nyx Paranormal Investigators New Jersey to discuss: How they started in paranormal investigations, crazy paranormal experiences, their experiences in multiple famous haunted houses and places, their private and public investiga…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good?: Breach (2020) 1:31:07

10M ago1:31:07

1:31:07

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths, & Mayhem. Kyle is out so Matt and everyone's favorite research refuser Jarred are back to break down another movie that's so bad it's good???? This week the guys breakdown a movie that on paper should have been at least ok, a horror sci-fi flick that is equal parts alien and zombies in space, w…

1
Dark Rum Runnas Part 2 1:48:23

10M ago1:48:23

1:48:23

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt, and Jarred return to the mixed up realm of Rum Runnas-type content but on a completely different show. The guys scoured the internet to find some creepy and spooky news stories to react to everything from: Increases in Loch Ness Monster Sightings, an escaped murderer not to…

1
50 States of Strange: Alaska 2:09:57

11M ago2:09:57

2:09:57

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt, and Jarred to continue their ongoing series spanning the strangest lore and crimes from all 50 States this week: Alaska. Covering everything from the Sdonalyasna (The People Stealers) to the real life monster Robert Hansen (The Butcher Baker), and the shape-shifting Otter c…

1
50 States of Strange: Louisiana 1:33:21

11M ago1:33:21

1:33:21

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt, and Jarred to continue their ongoing series spanning the strangest lore and crimes from all 50 States this week: Louisiana. Covering everything from Rougarous to the Honey Island Swamp Monster, Voodoo Queens to the Jazz Loving Serial Killer The Axe Man. The guys talk about …

1
50 States of Strange: Hawaii 1:41:53

12M ago1:41:53

1:41:53

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt, and Jarred to continue their ongoing series spanning the strangest lore and crimes from all 50 States this week: Hawaii. Covering everything from Nights Marchers to the Xerox Killings, The Menehune to The Green Lady, and much more. The guys talk about all of this and much m…

1
Dark Rum Runnas 1:27:53

12M ago1:27:53

1:27:53

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle, Matt, and Jarred try a little something new. The boys bring a little bit of Rum Runnas flair to Dark Rum. The guys scoured the internet to find some creepy and spooky news stories to react to. So enjoy this Rum Runnas Podcast Network Crossover with no actual host changes. Follow …

1
Horror So Bad It's Good?: Dracula 3000 1:17:06

1y ago1:17:06

1:17:06

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle gave Jarred a hand and together they finally caught Matt, so the boys are back! That doesn't mean the fun of talking about horribly good Horror B movies has to end (or maybe it did). This week the guys discuss: Dracula 3000. NOT a sequel to Dracula 2000, no matter how little sense…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good: Curse of Crom 2:00:56

1y ago2:00:56

2:00:56

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Matt's still out so Kyle and Jarred return to watch and discuss another Horror B-Film: Curse of Crom: The Legend of Halloween. Tune in to our full breakdown and reaction as we watch what happens when a very average girl whose "dad" really doesn't like her, delivers Chinese food to a cr…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good: Sleep Away Camp 2:08:26

1y ago2:08:26

2:08:26

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Matt's still out so Kyle and Jarred return to watch and discuss another cult classic 80's Horror movie: Sleep Away Camp. A delightfully absurd romp through, probably the worst-run summer camp in existence, staffed by some of the worst people to ever be allowed near kids, and filled wit…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good?: Bats 1:40:14

1y ago1:40:14

1:40:14

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Matt is still on the loose, so Kyle and Jarred return to everyone's new favorite series Horror So Bad It's Good, this time discussing: Bats. This 90's Horror B Movie that released with a star studded cast and a surprising amount of Box Office success, exists in the same vein as Jaws, B…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good: Intruder 1:37:53

1y ago1:37:53

1:37:53

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Matt is no where to be found so Kyle and Jarred return to everyone's new favorite series Horror So Bad It's Good this time discussing: Intruder. The extremely low budget 1989 grocery store slasher flick, filled with a remarkable amount of well known people. From both Raimi's, Bruce Cam…

1
Sci-Fi So Bad It's Good: Battlefield Earth 1:30:12

1y ago1:30:12

1:30:12

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle is out so Matt and everyone's favorite research refuser Jarred are back to break down another movie that's so bad it's good, this week jumping from B List Horror to A List Cast B List Delivered Sci-fi with: Battlefield Earth. A scientologist helmed movie based off the works of the…

1
50 States of Strange: Pennsylvania 1:37:17

1y ago1:37:17

1:37:17

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt are joined by returning audience analogue Jarred to continue their ongoing series spanning the strangest lore and crimes from all 50 States this week: Pennsylvania (The state where all 3 guys now call home). Covering everything from Ghost Buses, Goblin Monks, Hanging Brid…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good: The Special 1:18:37

1y ago1:18:37

1:18:37

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Matt's away so Kyle and Jarred get to watch yet another terribly awesome horror film and discuss it, this week: The Special. Breaking this C List 2020 Horror Film down scene by scene. Going over everything bad, hilarious, weird and nonsensical; and even a few good things about this sex…

1
50 States of Strange: Arkansas 1:42:31

1y ago1:42:31

1:42:31

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt are joined by returning audience analogue Jarred to continue their ongoing series spanning the strangest lore and crimes from all 50 States this week: Arkansas. Be it ghost lights, a woman in black, the white river monster, or the terrifying Gowrow. The guys talk about al…

1
Horror So Bad It's Good: Event Horizon 58:09

1y ago58:09

58:09

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle is out so Matt is joined by audience analogue Jarred to talk about their reactions to a nostalgic Sci-Fi Horror film: Event Horizon. Breaking down everything about this late 90's box office flop with a cult following. The film that asks the question; What's the fastest distance be…

1
50 States of Strange: Texas 1:27:51

1y ago1:27:51

1:27:51

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt, joined by their unwilling guest host Jarred, return to their ongoing series through the 50 States of Strange. This week they are covering Texas. Covering everything from a pre-Jack the Ripper serial killer to the Chupacabra, El Cucuy to La Llorona, and many monsters and …

1
Horror So Bad It's Good: Chopping Mall and Ice Cream Man 1:19:03

1y ago1:19:03

1:19:03

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Matt is out so Kyle is joined by unwilling cohost Jarred to talk about their reactions to nostalgic Horror B Movies: Chopping Mall and Ice Cream Man. Starting with the the 1986 Killer Robot filled ridiculousness of Chopping Mall, to the surreal insanity of a murdering Ice Cream Man fro…

1
50 States of Strange: Rhode Island 1:23:07

1y ago1:23:07

1:23:07

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt return to stories from the dark side with unwilling cohost Jarred, returning to their new ongoing series 50 States of Strange to discuss all of the spookiest and creepiest stories from Rhode Island: from River Monsters to Witches, Headless Skeletons to the Glocester Ghoul…

1
Do You Know The Bunnyman? 53:05

1+ y ago53:05

53:05

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt, joined by unwitting cohost Jarred, return to stories from the dark side discussing: This time they are discussing the VA urban legend of The Bunny Man. A legend that has a few different origins ranging from: An accident near an asylum involving patients a trail of dead b…

1
50 States of Strange: New Jersey 1:10:59

1+ y ago1:10:59

1:10:59

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt, with tag along guest host Jarred, return to stories from the dark side starting a new series on the show breaking down bizarre and creepy stories, legends and events from each of the 50 states. Starting with the state that Kyle and Matt are most familiar with, their home…

1
Scream 5 & 6 2:01:17

1+ y ago2:01:17

2:01:17

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt return to stories from the dark side and joined by special guest Jarred (Rum Runnas Podcast) discussing: the newest 2 installments in the Scream franchise, Scream 5 & 6. Continue this journey with the guys as they break down everything about these meta genre defining slas…

1
Scream 3 & 4 1:45:59

1+ y ago1:45:59

1:45:59

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt return to stories from the dark side discussing: the next 2 installments in the Scream franchise, Scream 3 & 4. Continue this journey with the guys as they break down everything about these meta genre defining slasher sequels, as well as reassess their lists of their favo…

1
Scream 1 & 2 2:18:48

1+ y ago2:18:48

2:18:48

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt return to stories from the dark side discussing: Scream 1 & 2. With the upcoming release of Scream 6, Kyle and Matt are revisiting the movie series that is near and dear to both of their hearts. Starting in the beginning with the original. The guys watch and discuss every…

1
The Flatwoods Monster 58:18

1+ y ago58:18

58:18

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt return to stories from the dark side discussing: The Flatwoods Monster. A creature from West Virginian Folklore that stems from a single incident in Braxton County West Virginia in September of 1952. Where 7 children and adults claimed to have seen what is commonly descri…

1
Shades of Death Road Revisited! 35:06

1+ y ago35:06

35:06

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt return to stories from the dark side discussing: Their return to Shades of Death Rd on a Rum Runnas Halloween Ghost Hunt. Recounting their experiences of what happened when they visited the famous haunted road and more specifically held a ghost hunt with a spirit box at G…

1
The Great Molasses Flood of 1919 37:10

1+ y ago37:10

37:10

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt return to stories from the dark side discussing: The Great Molasses Flood of 1919. A terrible tragedy that claimed the lives of 21 people and left 150 injured, brought about by a lack of safety and oversight by the people running the operation. The accident resulted in an…

1
Puca 38:24

1+ y ago38:24

38:24

The Dark Rum Podcast where we discuss Monsters, Myths & Mayhem. Kyle and Matt return to stories from the dark side discussing: The Puca. A mischievous shapeshifter that often takes the form of a horse, known predominantly in Celtic lore but similarities can be found in cultures ranging from Channel Islands to Scandinavian countries. A bringer of go…

1
Rum Runnas Present: Dark Shonen React to The Wraith (1986) 1:33:55

1+ y ago1:33:55

1:33:55

A special crossover episode between Rum Runnas Podcast, Dark Rum Podcast and Talk Shonen! Jarred, Kyle and Matt come together to talk about and give their opinion on a movie near and dear to Kyle's Heart: The Wraith (1986)! The guys discuss this 80's B-Movie starring Charlie Sheen all while reacting to it and rewatching it in real time as the show …

1
The Legend of the Wendigo 55:37

1+ y ago55:37

55:37

We just had to hit you with one more spooky one! Tune in to hear all about the Wendigo and get creeped out. https://what-if-i-told-you-podcast.myshopify.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendigo https://allthatsinteresting.com/wendigo https://www.legendsofamerica.com/mn-wendigo/ https://mythus.fandom.com/wiki/Wendigo https://cryptidspot.com/cryptid…

1
The Life and Death of Kurt Cobain 1:46:22

1+ y ago1:46:22

1:46:22

You may not have known that we both hold Kurt (and Nirvana) near and dear to our hearts. Please join us as we talk about Kurt's life, and his controversial death. https://what-if-i-told-you-podcast.myshopify.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurt_Cobain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_of_Kurt_Cobain https://www.britannica.com/biography/Kurt-C…

1
SPOOKY BONUS: Mothman 31:45

1+ y ago31:45

31:45

It is time for the last spooky bonus episode! Enjoy. https://what-if-i-told-you-podcast.myshopify.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mothman https://folklife.si.edu/magazine/mothman-point-pleasant-west-virginia https://www.wboy.com/only-on-wboy-com/paranormal-w-va/the-legend-of-mothman-paranormal-w-va/ https://www.mothmanmuseum.com/ https://wvtouris…

1
SPOOKY SEASON: The Real Amityville Horror 1:01:27

2y ago1:01:27

1:01:27

No explanation need. You already know. https://what-if-i-told-you-podcast.myshopify.com https://allthatsinteresting.com/amityville-horror-house https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronald_DeFeo_Jr. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Amityville_Horror https://nypost.com/article/amityville-horror-house-real-story/ https://www.biography.com/news/the-real-amit…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Breakfast Serial Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide