A Message to Garcia: Unpacking Hubbard's Timeless Essay

Bookey Best Book Summary App

Chapter 1 Introduction and Background of A Message To Garcia

"A Message to Garcia" is a widely read essay written by Elbert Hubbard in 1899. The piece was initially published in "The Philistine," a magazine produced by Hubbard himself, and was later distributed in massive quantities both as a standalone booklet and as part of his anthology of essays, the "Little Journeys to the Homes of the Famous."

Background of Elbert Hubbard:

Elbert Hubbard was born in 1856 in Bloomington, Illinois, and had a varied career before becoming a writer. He started as a soap salesman with the Larkin Soap Company, but he is best known as a writer, philosopher, and influential figure in the Arts and Crafts Movement in America. In 1895, Hubbard founded the Roycroft Arts and Crafts community in East Aurora, New York, which became a major hub for the movement. Hubbard was known for his progressive social views and his advocacy of simple living, high thinking, and artistic quality which was reflected in the Roycroft community.

Context of "A Message to Garcia":

The essay emerged in a particular historical and cultural context during the Spanish-American War when a leader in Cuba, General Calixto García, needed to be contacted to coordinate military action. The essay narrates the story of Lieutenant Andrew Rowan, who successfully delivered a critical message from President William McKinley to García. The tale was meant to exemplify diligence and initiative. Rowan's unquestioning acceptance of the task and his ability to accomplish it without further questions is presented as an exemplary model for all workers.

Hubbard's message in the text championed individual initiative and responsibility, qualities he saw lacking in many workers of his time. His call was for readers to undertake their duties with as much commitment and high virtue as Rowan did.

Reception and Legacy:

Shortly after its publication, the essay became phenomenally popular. It was translated into several languages and reached a circulation of over 40 million copies worldwide. Its themes struck a chord particularly with business leaders of the time, becoming a staple in business culture and corporate literature.

Hubbard's essay has been cited in countless speeches and business leadership books, presenting it as a motivational tale that emphasizes the virtue of carrying out a task with complete dedication and little fanfare. Indeed, the narrative continues to be invoked in discussions on work ethic and personal responsibility.

It's important to note that while "A Message to Garcia" promotes characteristics such as initiative and diligence, its interpretation has also stirred debate, particularly regarding its suggestion that employees should follow orders without questioning them. Critics argue that this perspective overlooks the importance of understanding the broader context of one's work and engaging critically and constructively in organizational environments.

Despite these criticisms, the core message of the essay about the importance of individual drive and commitment in achieving success remains influential and relevant in various sectors, including business and military contexts.

Chapter 2 Analysis of Main Characters and Plot

"A Message to Garcia" by Elbert Hubbard is more of an extended essay than a typical story with a plot and characters. The primary focus of the book is on the qualities of dedication, initiative, and responsibility.

The key figure in Hubbard's essay is Andrew Rowan, a lieutenant in the United States Army. The core content revolves around an event during the Spanish-American War. Rowan is given an assignment to deliver a critical message to General Calixto Garcia, the leader of the insurgents in Cuba. Garcia's cooperation is needed by the U.S., but his whereabouts are somewhat unknown and the territory is dangerous.

The essay emphasizes Rowan’s acceptance of the mission and his execution of it without questioning or hesitation. Rowan's determination and resourcefulness in completing the mission are highlighted as exemplary behaviors.

Hubbard uses Rowan’s story as a parable to discuss the importance of individual initiative and diligence in accomplishing tasks. The message he conveyed is that everyone should strive to be like Rowan, someone who gets things done swiftly and without needless questions. This is reflected in the widespread distribution and enduring popularity of the essay, especially in a business context, where these traits are highly valued.

Thus, while "A Message to Garcia" lacks a complex plot or a cast of characters, its central theme is conveyed through the example of Lieutenant Rowan's unwavering commitment to completing his assignment.

Chapter 3 Theme Exploration and Analysis

"A Message to Garcia" is not a lengthy novel but a brief, widely disseminated essay written by Elbert Hubbard in 1899. Its brevity does not detract from its influential impact, particularly in business and military contexts as an expression of valor and diligence. The essay uses the story of First Lieutenant Andrew S. Rowan's challenging mission during the Spanish-American War to deliver a message from President McKinley to General Calixto Garcia, a leader of the Cuban insurgents, in the heart of the Cuban jungle. This essay has been revered in military circles and business leadership fields for its depiction of initiative and perseverance. Here’s a deeper look at the primary themes elaborated within the essay:

1. Initiative and Self-Reliance

One of the main themes of the essay is the value of taking the initiative and being self-relying. Hubbard admires the fact that Rowan took the message without questioning his superiors. He did not ask about the specifics of accomplishing his task but instead set off on his mission, trusting in his own abilities and resourcefulness to complete the task. The essay highlights that the willingness to carry out a task without burdening others with questions or doubts is a crucial trait of successful individuals.

2. Duty and Responsibility

Rowan’s unquestioned acceptance of his mission transcends mere obedience and enters the realm of an intrinsic sense of duty and responsibility. The essay uses his example to chastise those who falter under less demanding circumstances, emphasizing that every task or job is a personal mission that should be approached with the same level of commitment.

3. Efficiency and Execution

The narrative stresses the importance of executing one's duties efficiently without procrastination or hesitation. Hubbard points out the indispensability of individuals who can carry out their assignments swiftly and smoothly, especially pointing out the rarity and value of such traits in organizational and military structures.

4. Leadership and Inspiration

Implicitly, Hubbard also touches on leadership qualities—particularly, the ability to inspire action and respect through personal example. "A Message to Garcia" has been used to mentor countless military officers and business leaders on the essence of impactful leadership—not through words but through decisive action.

5. Perseverance and Courage

Although the specifics of Rowan’s journey through the Cuban wilderness are not detailed in the essay, the implied difficulties and the unknown challenges he faced underscore the theme of courage and endurance. The message is that one's mettle is tested not during comfortable times but during unexpected challenges that require a deep well of courage.

6. The Value of Work

Hubbard lamented the scarcity of individuals who simply carry out tasks without excessive handholding. Through Rowan’s story, Hubbard extols the virtue of hard work and the importance of completing job responsibilities without the need for external motivation or reward.

7. Critique of Inefficacy

Conversely, Hubbard sharply criticizes individuals lacking the initiative or will to work independently. This critique is pointed especially at those in positions where effective action is vital, highlighting the detrimental effects of ineptitude and inefficiency on organizational and national success.

"A Message to Garcia" continues to be culturally significant, particularly within military and corporate training programs, for the strong values its themes encourage. Its promotion of assertive action and responsibility and its critique of inefficacy resonates across various sectors, advocating for a robust work ethic and resilient spirit. However, contemporary interpretations sometimes question the expectation of non-questioning loyalty and the implications it might have on personal autonomy and ethical behavior in complex situations.

Book https://www.bookey.app/book/a-message-to-garcia

YouTube https://www.pbslearningmedia.org/resource/a-message-to-garcia-lesson-plan/elbert-hubbard-an-american-original/

Amazom https://www.amazon.com/Message-Garcia-Original-1899/dp/1936830957

Goodreads https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/62845.A_Message_to_Garcia