Go offline with the Player FM app!
Podcasts Worth a Listen
SPONSORED


1 SISTER WIVES: The Brown Family Plans Garrison's Funeral, Gives NEW Details About His Passing. Justin Baldoni v Blake Lively UPDATES, First Pictures Of Micah Plath’s Broken Nose Have Surfaced!… 36:16
What Can Moral Dilemmas Tell Us About Ourselves? ~ Peter Railton
Manage episode 426437400 series 3403620
You are driving a car. The brakes stop working. To your horror, you are approaching a busy street market. Many people might be killed if you run into them. The only way to prevent a catastrophe is by turning fast to the right. Unfortunately, a lonely pedestrian might be killed if you do so.
Should you turn? Many people say you should. After all, killing one is better than killing many. But following the same logic, would you kill an individual to collect their organs for people in dire need of one? In this case, too, you would kill one to save many. Yet very few are willing to do so.
Why?
These are variations of the infamous “trolley problems”. Originally formulated half a century ago, these trolley problems continue to elicit heated conversations. They have a whole meme culture built around them. Yet for years, I was not convinced of their value. They seemed to squeeze ethics into narrow funnels of “yeses" and "noes", neglecting much of real life's texture.
I have changed my mind. And I’ve done so largely thanks to Peter Railton.
A professor of philosophy at UC Michigan, Railton used to share my scepticism about the trolley problems. But he, too, changed his mind. Having in-depth conversations about them with his students, Railton came to see these problems as revealing some important about morality. Combined with recent evidence from psychology and neuroscience, Railton believes that these insights can reveal a lot about the human mind more generally.
I will let him tell you why.
SUPPORT
Do you like On Humans? You can become a member of the generous group of patrons at Patreon.com/OnHumans!
MENTIONS
Names: Philippa Foot; Judith Tarvis Johnson; Joshua Greene; Daniel Kahnemann; Amos Trevsky; Antonio Damasio; John Stuart Mill; Michael Tomasello; Philip Kitcher (see episode 2); Oliver Scott Curry; David Hume
Dilemmas & games: Trolley problems (Switch, Footbridge, Loop, Beckon, Wave), Gummy Bear task (from Tomasello et al.); Gambling Tasks (from Damasio et al.); Ultimatum Game
Terms: Utilitarianism; consequentialism; deontology; rule utilitarianism; trait utilitarianism; virtue & character ethics
Articles: Links to academic papers and more can be accessed via OnHumans.Substack.com.
Keywords: ethics, moral philosophy, morality, moral progress, trolley problem, morality, moral psychology, fMRI, neuroscience, cross-cultural psychology, behavioural economics, comparative psychology, gay rights, moral anthropology, cultural anthropology, philosophical anthropology, sharing, sociality, cooperation, altruism, prosociality, utilitarianism, deontology, consequentialism, virtue ethics, Chinese philosophy, daoism, taoism, Confucianism
84 episodes
Manage episode 426437400 series 3403620
You are driving a car. The brakes stop working. To your horror, you are approaching a busy street market. Many people might be killed if you run into them. The only way to prevent a catastrophe is by turning fast to the right. Unfortunately, a lonely pedestrian might be killed if you do so.
Should you turn? Many people say you should. After all, killing one is better than killing many. But following the same logic, would you kill an individual to collect their organs for people in dire need of one? In this case, too, you would kill one to save many. Yet very few are willing to do so.
Why?
These are variations of the infamous “trolley problems”. Originally formulated half a century ago, these trolley problems continue to elicit heated conversations. They have a whole meme culture built around them. Yet for years, I was not convinced of their value. They seemed to squeeze ethics into narrow funnels of “yeses" and "noes", neglecting much of real life's texture.
I have changed my mind. And I’ve done so largely thanks to Peter Railton.
A professor of philosophy at UC Michigan, Railton used to share my scepticism about the trolley problems. But he, too, changed his mind. Having in-depth conversations about them with his students, Railton came to see these problems as revealing some important about morality. Combined with recent evidence from psychology and neuroscience, Railton believes that these insights can reveal a lot about the human mind more generally.
I will let him tell you why.
SUPPORT
Do you like On Humans? You can become a member of the generous group of patrons at Patreon.com/OnHumans!
MENTIONS
Names: Philippa Foot; Judith Tarvis Johnson; Joshua Greene; Daniel Kahnemann; Amos Trevsky; Antonio Damasio; John Stuart Mill; Michael Tomasello; Philip Kitcher (see episode 2); Oliver Scott Curry; David Hume
Dilemmas & games: Trolley problems (Switch, Footbridge, Loop, Beckon, Wave), Gummy Bear task (from Tomasello et al.); Gambling Tasks (from Damasio et al.); Ultimatum Game
Terms: Utilitarianism; consequentialism; deontology; rule utilitarianism; trait utilitarianism; virtue & character ethics
Articles: Links to academic papers and more can be accessed via OnHumans.Substack.com.
Keywords: ethics, moral philosophy, morality, moral progress, trolley problem, morality, moral psychology, fMRI, neuroscience, cross-cultural psychology, behavioural economics, comparative psychology, gay rights, moral anthropology, cultural anthropology, philosophical anthropology, sharing, sociality, cooperation, altruism, prosociality, utilitarianism, deontology, consequentialism, virtue ethics, Chinese philosophy, daoism, taoism, Confucianism
84 episodes
All episodes
×
1 An Essential Difference? Males, Females, and the Spaces In Between ~ Augustín Fuentes 1:01:43

1 The Rest is History: From the Origins of Farming to the Dawn of Modernity ~ Johannes Krause 1:03:25

1 A Human Like No Other: The Rise of Homo Sapiens ~ Johannes Krause 1:10:09

1 What Is a Human? The New Science of the Genus Homo ~ Chris Stringer 1:06:17

1 An Unusual Ape: The Deep Origins of Our Human Oddities ~ Dean Falk 50:17

1 The Big Picture: From the Origin of Life to the Rise of Humans ~ Tim Coulson 1:04:14

1 What About India? Part II: Success and Stagnation In the World’s Largest Democracy ~ Bishnupriya Gupta 30:28

1 What About India? Part I: Mughals, British, and the Causes of Poverty ~ Bishnupriya Gupta 1:07:13

1 Why Patriarchy? Foragers, Farmers, and the Origins of Gender Inequality ~ Angarika Deb 54:39

1 Bonus | Evolution Beyond the Selfish Gene (with Eva Jablonka) 19:30

1 Bonus | The Real Lessons From The World Happiness Report (with Lara Aknin) 16:26

1 Bonus | Some Myths About Human Mating (with Katie Starkweather) 11:57

1 Encore | The Mindbending Conversation That Topped 2024 (with Donald Hoffman) 1:28:37

1 Live from London | Yasheng Huang on the Origins of Modern China 1:25:51

1 A New Theory on the Broadest Patterns of History ~ Ideen Ali Riahi 1:08:29

1 Is War Inevitable? Lessons from East Asia ~ David C. Kang 51:21

1 Is War Natural After All? Revisiting the Debate ~ Luke Glowacki 1:06:04

1 Nobel-Prize Special | Daron Acemoglu on Why We Should Celebrate Humanity 20:44

1 This Might Be The Nicest Thing About Human Nature ~ Lara Aknin 55:25

1 What About China? Part III: A Brief History of China’s Future ~ Yasheng Huang 30:36

1 What About China? Part II: Explaining the Chinese Miracle ~ Yasheng Huang 1:05:57

1 What About China? Part I: The Deep Currents of Chinese History ~ Yasheng Huang 1:12:59

1 Does It Matter Who Brings In The Meat? ~ Katie Starkweather 48:44

1 Why Agriculture? Climate Change and the Origins of Farming ~ Andrea Matranga 58:22

1 What Can Moral Dilemmas Tell Us About Ourselves? ~ Peter Railton 1:11:39

1 The Birth of Modern Prosperity, Part IV: Grasping Towards Equality (with Branko Milanovic) 36:26

1 The Birth of Modern Prosperity, Part III: Power to the People (with Daron Acemoglu) 36:09

1 The Birth of Modern Prosperity, Part II: Laboratories of the New Era (with Brad DeLong) 35:25

1 The Birth of Modern Prosperity, Part I: The Shape of the Story (with Oded Galor) 29:39
Welcome to Player FM!
Player FM is scanning the web for high-quality podcasts for you to enjoy right now. It's the best podcast app and works on Android, iPhone, and the web. Signup to sync subscriptions across devices.