Best Butter Pie Podcasts (2024)

1
Episode 1 - A Season Preview. 39:36

28m ago39:36

39:36

Oli and Jack are back for another season of the Butter Pie Podcast. We cover all things North End, season expectations, transfer window and more.

1
Can You Don't? | Cherry Pie. Disney. Russia. Dick Bangs. 1:20:27

10m ago1:20:27

1:20:27

We all gotta go someday... but if you were able to choose how you die I highly doubt it would involve chickens pecking food out of your mouth. Let's talk about that, going a little crazy over a bird trying to eat your daughter's French fries, getting a used diaper off Amazon, Bryan again bragging about how good he would be at sucking dong, and more…

1
Summer Olympics, 90's Beauty Pageants, Health Scares, and Goodwill Hunting! 1:13:32

7d ago1:13:32

1:13:32

LIVE from Hickory! It's an all-new Carolina Reeper Show! This episode is a Totally Request Live Hour. It’s like a better-looking episode of TRL on MTV but instead of Carson Daily, it’s me Jon Reep, and my pal Marc Hunt. In this episode, we get to the bottom of "Is Diet Mountain Dew Racist?", talk about the hot topic of the Olympics Opening Ceremony…

1
Can You Don't? | 30 Tokens. Hong Kong Hank. Gnomes. Holding Ham. 1:32:16

1h ago1:32:16

1:32:16

There's nothing quite like taking the family out to dinner and the booth next to you is funneling margaritas into their assholes. Let's talk about that, trying to fly a kite at midnight in perfectly calm conditions, what the heck is with Montana and all their casino combo businesses, needing tokens from the government to watch porn, and more on tod…

1
Gorgeous Grandmas, Biden is Out, and Ken Speeracee! 1:04:37

8h ago1:04:37

1:04:37

Welcome to an all-new Carolina Reeper Show! This episode is like a Gorgeous Grandma wearing a Tin Foil hat drinking a Citrus Vanilla Ice Cream Float. Did you know today is Gorgeous Grandma Day? Who’s the hottest grandma you know? Also, who is Ken Speeracee and what are his theories? Where is Joe Biden? Who’s the next Democratic Presidential Candida…

1
Episode 134 - Horses

2h ago

—

Episode 134 Notes: A nice little podcast in which we discuss horses and their relationship to man…..after dark Also…Movie Talk, Billy Scott, Incubus and a heaping helping of Butter Pie! (See episode 131) Songs featured in Episode 135: “Strange World” and “News of the Universe” – La Luz “If You Find Me Gone” and “Last Love Song on This Little Planet…

1
Can You Don't? | Angry Gamer. Concussion. Donkey Elk. Prism. 1:18:22

2h ago1:18:22

1:18:22

Bryan wants to give Joe a rimjob. Joe definitely didn't write this episode description. Bryan can't read. Let's talk about that, splashing piss all over your girlfriend, getting so mad during online gaming that you pack a hammer and actually do something about it, Joe completely screwing up a jump off a bridge, and more on today's episode of Can Yo…

1
Trump Assassination Attempt, Richard Simmons, Shannon Doherty & Dr. Ruth! 1:19:48

20m ago1:19:48

1:19:48

It's an all-new Carolina Reeper Show! In this episode...Former President Trump got shot by a misguided 20-year-old dork with bad aim. So we’ll talk about it. Celebrity deaths are in the news! Jon and the gang will take time to remember Richard Simmons, Shannon Doherty, Dr. Ruth Westhiemer, and Joe Bonsall of the Oak Ridge Boys. Also, pal Marc Hunt …

1
Can You Don't? | Flour. Gameboy. Snail. Tickle Bitch. 1:24:12

26d ago1:24:12

1:24:12

Can you imagine running out to warn others of an incoming storm... and then getting struck by lightning?! Let's talk about that, getting way too angry at youth sporting events, your coworker insisting on tickling you everyday, squirting an interesting concoction on women in order to talk to them, and more on today's episode of Can You Don't?! *** W…

1
Hickory Crawdads with Kurtis, Shark Week and Idiotic TikToks! 1:08:12

7d ago1:08:12

1:08:12

Welcome to an all-new Carolina Reeper! This episode is like a chaotic caption this contest with Kurtis while eating a hotdog in a hurricane at a Hickory Crawdads game! In this episode, Jon and the gang talk about Hurricane Beryl, Jon shares some of his new favorite Idiotic TikToks, we celebrate Shark Week, get a Mystery History Lesson from Intern I…

1
Can You Don't? | Hand Lick. Sex Worker. Liver. Butter. 1:04:58

1M ago1:04:58

1:04:58

Would you like to round-up to 9 butters today? Don't worry... if that made sense to you before hearing today's episode, that would be extra concerning. Let's talk about that, licking random stranger's hands before every handshake, the ugliest goat you will ever see, dropping your phone while trying to put on a new screen protecter, and more on toda…

1
Happy Birthday America! 1:04:17

29d ago1:04:17

1:04:17

It's an all-new Carolina Reeper Show! This episode is where Patriotism, Performance, and Pyrotechnics, Collide in a Cacophony of Loud Kabooms that produce Mushroom Clouds! We’re gonna give you fuel, give you fire, give you that which you desire. We're celebrating the 4th of July.. Happy Birthday, America! We’re gonna look at some fireworks gone wro…

1
Can You Don't? | Tax Fraud. Jugs of Fun. Columbia. Lockbox. 1:40:25

17d ago1:40:25

1:40:25

What's the most amount of money you have ever blown on a carnival game? Could you imagine that number being YOUR ENTIRE LIFE SAVINGS?! Let's talk about that, super neat facts about sex, an edible drone blowing your cover during war, having huge eyeballs the older you get, and more on today's episode of Can You Don't?! *** Wanna become part of The G…

1
Jamaica, Goodwill Hunting, Idiotic TikToks and Hawk Tuah! 58:22

20d ago58:22

58:22

Welcome to an all-new Carolina Reeper Show! This episode is like Jamaican Jambalaya of Jerk Chicken and Catfish Goulash with Cornball Nuggets. I’m back from Jamaica, I survived and we’ve got stories to tell. Also, we’re gonna talk about the Hawk Tuah Girl and how Mike Judge predicted the future. Plus, I have more residual checks to give away. Who w…

1
Can You Don't? | Ski Goggles. Colon Cough. Bob Barker. Lockdown. 1:23:40

24d ago1:23:40

1:23:40

Have you ever hired someone to do some work around the house and it appears they cut every corner possible along the way? Let's talk about that, AirBnb renters literally taking your house from you, using lasers to scare off 12,000 geese, your windshield disappearing while you're driving down the freeway, and more on today's episode of Can you Don't…

1
Father's Day, Jamaica, and Colonoscopies! 1:02:57

24d ago1:02:57

1:02:57

Welcome to an all-new Carolina Reeper Show! This week's episode is like an Intimate Invasive Intrusive Anal Father from Jamaica, Mon! It's National WANNA GET AWAY DAY... so I talk about my upcoming trip to Jamaica. We talk about my recent colonoscopy and I place bets with my crew about whether I'm getting a Father's Day gift or not. What's the best…

1
Episode 133 - The High Top Table of Podcasts

26d ago

—

Episode 133 notes And here we are again to regale you with Jaime’s B-day story, The Taylor Swift Imperial Phase, a man and his dream, and the finest cinema late 80’s NBC had to offer Musically we feature The Cloud Nothings, Toner, Suzie True, Egg Drop Soup, St Vincent, and Haley and the Crushers. On that last note, please check out “Unsubscribe fro…

1
Can You Don't? | Foam Dinner. Toothbrush. House Fire. Puppeteer. 1:49:45

2M ago1:49:45

1:49:45

Wowowowowowowowow! Come have some fun with us as we celebrate the two year anniversary of Can You Don't?! *** Wanna become part of The Gaggle and access all the extra content on the end of each episode PLUS tons more?! Our Patreon page is LIVE! This is the biggest way you can support the show. It would mean the world to us: http://patreon.com/canyo…

1
Can You Don't? | Sticker. Pee Slap. Chinchilla. Boat Fence. 1:26:27

1M ago1:26:27

1:26:27

No matter how old or wise we get, we are never safe from doing some idiotic shit. Let's talk about that, accidentally giving a millionaire a dollar thinking he was homeless, finding a gun while working at PetSmart, pissing off the HOA by painting a picture of your boat on your fence, and more on today's episode of Can You Don't?! *** Wanna become p…

1
Karaoke Chaos with Kurtis, JoJo is a No Go and Goodwill Hunting! 1:00:54

1M ago1:00:54

1:00:54

Welcome to an all-new episode of the Carolina Reeper Show! This episode is a whirlwind of whimsy, wrapped in a witty wisecracker. UPDATE! We have a new segment, Karaoke Chaos with Kurtis! Kurtis performs crowd favorites at Romeo and Brewliet Taproom & Pourhouse in Hickory. He is a professional karaoke singer after all! You don't want to miss this! …

1
Can You Don't? | Drunk Monkey. Cartwheel. Pink. Middle Child. 1:46:21

2M ago1:46:21

1:46:21

What would your response be if you caught some random dude fingering your car on your security camera? Let's talk about that, farting your pencil across the room, a wallet that runs away when you are spending too much money, Flavor Flav becoming the spokesperson for women's water polo, and more on today's episode of Can You Don't?! *** Wanna become…

1
The Memorial Day Edition! 1:18:22

2M ago1:18:22

1:18:22

In this brand new edition of Carolina Reeper Jon spends some quality time with The Alan Jackson talking Memorial Day festivities and our preferred bathroom habits while vacationing. Also! Jon shares some news about his upcoming OnlyFans account... What would you pay money to see Jon do? Plus! Jon and Alan have some Idiotic TikToks qued up that you …

1
Episode 132 - The Bleedies

2M ago

—

Sometimes the episodes are good. Sometimes they…aren’t so good. This one falls into the second category. Things start out good with talk of eclipses and earthquakes before sliding into an episode of TSS after dark and eventually starting to get shakey about 30 minutes in. The bands are good at least. We talk about the amazing Castle Rat, METS, Spac…

1
Can You Don't? | I'll. Miss. You. Grace. 1:37:49

2M ago1:37:49

1:37:49

Joe's family was hit with some heartbreaking news this week... *** Wanna become part of The Gaggle and access all the extra content on the end of each episode PLUS tons more?! Our Patreon page is LIVE! This is the biggest way you can support the show. It would mean the world to us: http://patreon.com/canyoudontpodcast *** New Episodes every Wednesd…

1
Stenhouse, Segal, Rachtman, and Isaiah! 1:04:14

2M ago1:04:14

1:04:14

It’s an all-new Carolina Reeper Show with Jon Reep! This episode is noteworthy! You might want to write this down because it’s National Memo Day. In this episode, the crew discusses the Ricky Stenhouse Jr. vs Kyle Busch fight at this week's Nascar race, Steven Segal singing about “The Punani” and Riki Rachtman trying to steal Jon’s laptop on a flig…

1
Bigfoot, Buttermilk Biscuits and Goodwill Hunting! 1:25:37

3M ago1:25:37

1:25:37

Welcome to the all-new Carolina Reeper show! This episode is going to be generous, kind-hearted, and compassionate. By the way…It’s National Decency Day. Have you no decency sir!? Also, we’re going to talk about buttermilk biscuits, bigfoot, and hygiene routines... You’ll not want to miss this segment! Also, my pal Marcus Stamos is in the house so …

1
Can You Don't? | Microphone. Bookmark. Alpaca. Noodling. 2:26:31

2M ago2:26:31

2:26:31

WHAAAAAAAAAT?! 100 Episodes is an amazing milestone and we couldn't have done it without your support! As you would probably expect, this episode gets a little wild and completely off the rails. BUT, we had a blast taking a stroll down memory lane and for almost no reason at all decided to dress up in western wear. It's ok. No one cares. Huge and t…

1
Episode 11 - The Good, The Bad, The Lowe. 38:25

3M ago38:25

38:25

Oli and Jack are back to cover the end of season review on Preston North End, we cover the overriding thoughts on the season, current squad and to where we need to recruit come summer transfer window.

1
Comedian Chris Munch, Mother's Day, and Residual Checks! 1:10:59

2M ago1:10:59

1:10:59

This episode is gonna be a little cringy, a little lip-smacking, and it might even give you dry mouth. This episode is gonna be a little cringy, a little lip-smacking, and it might even give you dry mouth. Comedian Chris Munch will Zoom into the show with his cast of characters including Steven Stephens, Pastor Bobby, and Chad the Mulit-Level Marke…

1
Can You Don't? | Birds. Belly Button. Honeycomb. Biscuit Boot. 1:23:08

3M ago1:23:08

1:23:08

Have you ever been proper bird watching? Are you currently a bird watcher? Did you know that it's officially called birding? Did you also know you can piss the entire birding community off by accidentally capturing a rare bird when you were actually just trying to photograph a waterfall in Oregon? Let's talk about that, sexually biting your lip at …

1
Episode 131 - Butter Pie

3M ago

—

Furious Podcasting Settle in for a big ole piece of butter pie and some furious podcasting as we briefly recount trips to Italy and training camp, almost getting arrested over a popular novel of yesteryear, Lou’s secret girlfriend, and Jaime’s take on “Poor Things” For a little extra treat, listen to the end to hear a delightful rendition of an old…

1
Sour Patch Kids x OREO Review 41:05

3M ago41:05

41:05

The crossover we've always wanted...yet nobody else seems to have? OREO is firing on all of its creamy cylinders shortly after breaking free from its chocolate-covered captives. Hopefully this only leads to more of that creativity and playfulness that they seemed to have been missing for a while now.…

1
Tepper Tantrum, The Kid Rock Comedy Jam and $5 Self Defense Classes 1:05:01

3M ago1:05:01

1:05:01

Welcome to an ALL-NEW Carolina Reeper! This episode is gonna make you flip your lid or pop your top. Either way hats off to David Tepper for throwing another Tepper-temper tantrum. We’ll discuss. Also, my pal Marc Hunt is here so we’re gonna play Goodwill Hunting, as we unbox gifts that we got each other at a Goodwill. Plus, we’re gonna talk about …

1
Can You Don't? | Earthquake. Flamethrower. Bus. Vegetation. 1:22:37

3M ago1:22:37

1:22:37

There's a lot of situations one wouldn't want to be in when an earthquake randomly hits... but being in the middle of getting a vasectomy seems pretty high up that list. Let's talk about that, listening to people orgasm for science, low qualifications for being put in charge of potentially saving people's lives, lying about being pregnant in order …

1
From the Darkness Came a Cinnamon Delight - Milk's Favorite Podcast 1:08:10

3M ago1:08:10

1:08:10

We're back! But how does that make us fEeEeEel? We don't know. But, we know that a darkness is fading. Long gone are the days of chocolate and marshmallow. We welcome a new era of creativity led by fried dough and cinnamon. Long may it live.By Wonder Creme

1
Can You Don't? | Ladder. Toes. Free Chicken. Nips. 1:32:31

3M ago1:32:31

1:32:31

What did the guy who got his dong chopped off by his wife get for his birthday?! He was given an appointment to get all his toes chopped off too! HAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHA! Let's talk about that, blowing your load in a birdhouse per your partner's request, passing out while washing your pants in the sink, Joe going on a HOT AIR BALLOON RIDE, and more on …

1
Can You Don't? | Loop. Pom Pom. Yes. Wrong Address. 1:30:07

4M ago1:30:07

1:30:07

Bryan pooped in his bed. I know you are all extremely shocked to hear this news. Let's talk about that, almost breaking into the wrong house, grinding up and smoking human bones in order to get high, bringing a hat pom pom to the vet because you thought it was a dying animal, and more on today's episode of Can You Don't?! *** Wanna become part of T…

1
Flashbacks! with Nate Bargatze and Dusty Slay 34:29

3M ago34:29

34:29

Here come the flashbacks!... I'm on the road this week, performing with Kid Rock in Nashville, but I was able to put together a couple of great interviews we've done in the past with comedians Nate Bargatze and Dusty Slay for your listening pleasure. Enjoy! Download and Listen to the CAROLINA REEPER with Jon Reep Podcast: https://link.chtbl.com/tbx…

1
Episode 10 - Osmagic Osmajic. 25:08

4M ago25:08

25:08

Oli and Jack are back to cover the Watford (hardly) and the Huddersfield game midweek, in which a Montenegrin striker scored his first and PNE’s first league hattrick since Joey Garner. We cover all bases including the backline, Norwich preview and if we could actually do this.

1
The Partial Eclipse of the Heart, Idiotic TikTok's and Residual Checks for Everyone! 1:14:40

4M ago1:14:40

1:14:40

Have you heard of Factor meals? Factor’s delicious, ready-to-eat meals make eating better, every day, easy. Wherever tomorrow takes you, be ready with pre-prepared chef-crafted and dietician-approved meals delivered right to your door. Head to FactorMeals.com/reep50 and use promo code "reep50" to get 50% off. It’s an ALL-NEW CAROLINA REEPER Show! T…

1
Can You Don't? | Tennis Balls. Cowboy. Childbirth. Garden Hose. 1:32:40

4M ago1:32:40

1:32:40

Imagine two rival gangs facing off in an alley. The hatred they have for each other has been stewing for a little over 35 years and FINALLY... it's time to settle the score. Now, imagine that all the gang members are riding unicycles. Let's talk about that, whether or not flipping a coin is truly 50/50 odds, getting terrorized by random cows for ov…

1
Episode 9 - Cautiously Optimistic. 30:04

4M ago30:04

30:04

Oli and Jack are back. Discussing all things North End, the season as a whole, the run in and looking forward to the summer.

1
NC State Final Four, The New Roadhouse, and the "Governance of Rooting in Collegiate Athletics" 1:16:17

4M ago1:16:17

1:16:17

Welcome to another jam-packed edition of the CAROLINA REEPER show! Today’s episode is like a couple of Determined DJ’s Defeating of Bunch of Delusional, Duke Blue Devils. How bout that WolfPack? Final Four baby. Here we come! What do you think of movie remakes? We’re going to get into the new Roadhouse. Have you seen it? Sebastian is in the house a…

1
Can You Don't? | Tongue. Cupcake. Four Eyes. Rubik's Cube. 1:36:01

4M ago1:36:01

1:36:01

Imagine bringing a newborn baby to a rave... and then getting upset when everyone else around you wasn't super supportive about you bringing a f*&$ING newborn baby to a rave. Let's talk about that, weird ass things you never knew about the human body, actually owing money after trying to get money for amputating your own legs, getting addicted to s…

1
Episode 130 - Psyop

4M ago

—

February 9th? Not likely. This is the last of the “pre-Italy” podcasts. Hopefully I will be able to get these out faster than one per month. Anyway, as part of a little “Sunday Morning Surprise” we discuss the subversive nature of both Tele-Tubbies and a certain NFL power couple, the majesty of AntsCanada, and the shining gem of the internet: Elita…

1
Can You Don't? | Large Python. Baby Jumping. Bagel. Good Acid. 1:30:07

4M ago1:30:07

1:30:07

Pro Tip: If the success of your murder plot pivots on having a large python eat one of your intended targets, you should probably rethink your entire murder plot. Let's talk about that, decking a mascot while on acid at a basketball game, happily filming content for your mom's OnlyFan's account, ordering a hot air balloon ride using Uber, and more …

1
Jon's Birthday Show! NCAA Stolen Valor, Idiotic TikTokets & Goodwill Hunting! 1:03:34

4M ago1:03:34

1:03:34

Almost LIVE, from Hickory! It's an All NEW Carolina Reeper Show! This episode is like an Easter Bunny, UnBoxing a BBQ’ed Basketball, at a Birthday Party! Easter is right around the corner... tune in for the Popsicle "Rabbit Food" Easter story! (Spoiler: it wasn't food) It's Jon's Birthday Show! How old do you think I am? Leave it in the comments! I…

1
Wolfpack Basketball, Idiotic TikToks and Mukbanging with Mom'osa! 1:19:45

4M ago1:19:45

1:19:45

Almost LIVE, from Hickory! It's an All NEW Carolina Reeper Show! This episode is like a Hungry Pack of Wolves, Feasting on a Helpless Little Baby Ram Lamb. Did you watch the ACC tournament? Who won? Did I piss you off with my video posts? We’re gonna share some of our favorite Idiotic TikTok videos and see what my co-host Intern Isaiah, our residen…

1
Can You Don't? | Slingshot. Stemming. Butt. Went Floppy. 1:25:11

5M ago1:25:11

1:25:11

Imagine being trapped in a warehouse with a bunch of murderous Stephen Hawkings going 15 mph. The sound of their evil laugh alone is enough to strike fear into the hearts of any man. Let's talk about that, police trying to interrogate a pigeon accused of spying, getting stabbed with a bundle of pens by stranger on an airplane, sledding dead bodies …

1
The Oscars vs. Joe Biden, Idiotic TikToks, Duke Trips and Goodwill Hunting! 1:05:01

5M ago1:05:01

1:05:01

Have you heard of Factor meals? Factor’s delicious, ready-to-eat meals make eating better, every day, easy. Wherever tomorrow takes you, be ready with pre-prepared chef-crafted and dietician-approved meals delivered right to your door. Head to FactorMeals.com/reep50 and use promo code "reep50" to get 50% off. It’s an ALL-NEW Carolina Reeper Show! T…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Butter Pie Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide