Best Andrew Garber Podcasts (2024)

1
The Sacrifice of Lucinda Mills: A Kentucky Family's Descent Into Madness 10:45

15m ago10:45

10:45

Join us this week as we tell a chilling story from Martin County, Kentucky. This episode recounts the harrowing events of January 9, 1933, when the quiet community of Tomahawk was rocked by a gruesome discovery. The lifeless body of a 72-year-old woman was found in her mountain cabin, the victim of a bizarre ritual led by her own son, John H. Mills…

1
Wings Over Appalachia: The John Paul Riddle Story 16:43

5d ago16:43

16:43

This week we tell the story of a man from Pike County, Kentucky, who made his mark in aviation history. Join Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins as they tell the story of John Paul Riddle, from his humble beginnings in Appalachia to his pioneering contributions to aviation. His passion for flight led him to become a daredevil barnstormer, a co-founder of t…

1
Beneath the Lakes: The Lost Communities of Loyston and Butler 14:58

12d ago14:58

14:58

This week on the Stories podcast, we tell the story of two Appalachian towns, Loyston and Butler, that were submerged beneath TVA lakes but refused to disappear. Join Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins as they recount the fascinating tales of these communities that were dramatically transformed by the Tennessee Valley Authority. Listen to the audio versio…

1
Granny Dollar, The Cherokee Matriarch of Lookout Mountain 12:48

19d ago12:48

12:48

Join Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins as they tell the story of Nancy Emmeline Callahan Dollar, affectionately known as Granny Dollar. This Cherokee matriarch lived on Lookout Mountain near Fort Payne, Alabama, and became a legendary figure in her community. Born in 1826, Granny Dollar's life was a rich tapestry of Cherokee heritage, history, and surviv…

1
The Saltville Massacre: A Tale of Courage and Cruelty 9:03

26d ago9:03

9:03

This week on the Stories podcast, we tell of the harrowing events of the first Battle of Saltville and its tragic aftermath. Join Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins as they recount the significance of Saltville's salt mines during the Civil War, a resource as valuable as gold for preserving food. We also shed light on a lesser-known but profoundly impactf…

1
The Mystery of the Beale Treasure 14:27

1M ago14:27

14:27

In this week’s episode of Stories of Appalachia, we tell the captivating tale of the Beale Treasure—a story that has fascinated treasure hunters and cryptographers for well over a century. Join Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins as they share the story of the mystery surrounding a massive cache of gold, silver, and jewels allegedly buried in Bedford Count…

1
A Bristol Millionaire's Tragic End In New Orleans 13:22

1M ago13:22

13:22

In this episode of the Stories podcast, we tell a crime story involving a wealthy heir from Bristol, Tennessee/Virginia, whose life ended tragically in New Orleans. James Mahoney, a man of many talents and pursuits, found himself entangled in a web of mystery and murder that has intrigued many for decades. Join Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins as they t…

1
A Cherokee Murder That Hastened The Trail of Tears 17:05

2M ago17:05

17:05

In this episode of Stories of Appalachia, we tell the story of the prelude to the infamous Trail of Tears—the murder that inflamed Cherokee tensions and provided the legal framework for the tragic forced relocation of the tribe from the southeast to what’s now Oklahoma. Join Rod Mullins and Steve Gilly as they unravel the complex tale of Jack Walke…

1
When The Whirlwind Came: The 1929 Tragedy at Rye Cove, Virginia 16:24

2M ago16:24

16:24

In this episode of Stories of Appalachia, we tell the story of one of the most devastating natural disasters to strike southwest Virginia: the Rye Cove cyclone of 1929. A day that began like any other would end in tragedy as a powerful tornado tore across the community of Rye Cove, leaving death and destruction in its wake. Listen as Steve Gilly an…

1
Social Detective Trailer 1:29

2M ago1:29

1:29

Social Detective is an investigative podcast that covers unsolved cases involving Kansas & the surrounding states. You can find us at https://linktr.ee/crimecakes We do take case suggestions. --- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/maryanne-mccullough/support

1
The Long Hunter’s Legacy: James Smith’s Survival in Appalachia 13:27

2M ago13:27

13:27

Today we tell the remarkable story of James Smith, a frontiersman and longhunter whose fight for survival in the Appalachian wilderness in 1767 after a hunting expedition tested his knowledge, ingenuity and determination to live. Listen to our podcast on Spreaker, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Audible, or on your favorite podcast app, and consider suppo…

1
The Story of the Humming Bird Car: An Appalachian Innovation on Wheels! 14:18

2M ago14:18

14:18

In this episode of Stories of Appalachia, we tell the remarkable tale of Talmadge Judd, a backyard innovator from Kingsport, Tennessee, whose vision and mechanical abilities led to the creation in 1945 of the Humming Bird, an automobile far ahead of its time. With no blueprints, Judd built the Humming Bird in just four months—a subcompact marvel th…

1
Searching For Kendra Battello & Colby Sheppard 1:23:31

3M ago1:23:31

1:23:31

The search for a missing Kendra Battelo has taken unexpected twists & turns. When Kendra, a woman with history of domestic violence from her partner Colby Sheppard went missing. It was all hands on deck from the MMIW due to her Muskagee Native American ethnicity, help from OurBlackGirls.com since Kendra is also of African American descent but the g…

1
The Mendota Gunslinger? The Story of Texas Jack 17:49

3M ago17:49

17:49

Today we tell a story with echoes of the Wild West…along with a twist! We unravel the mysterious life of Jack Vermillion of Mendota, Virginia, a man who many say once walked the dusty streets of Tombstone, Arizona, alongside the legendary Earp brothers. Join hosts Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins as they journey through the tangled tales of a figure man…

1
Devil John Wright of the Cumberlands 30:53

3M ago30:53

30:53

In the heart of Appalachia, a legend looms as large as the mountains themselves. Today, we tell the story of John Wesley Wright. Born in the Elkhorn Valley of Kentucky, John Wright's life was a mix of adventure, violence, and survival. From his early days as a Confederate soldier making a daring escape from Union forces, Wright's exploits during th…

1
Deathwind in the Wilderness: The Lewis Wetzel Story 12:36

3M ago12:36

12:36

Today we venture into the untamed wilderness of the late 18th-century Appalachian frontier, along the Ohio River. In this episode of Stories of Appalachia, Steve and Rod unearth the life and lore of Lewis Wetzel, a man whose name is etched in the annals of history as a fearless pioneer, frontiersman, and Indian fighter. Join us on a journey through…

1
Searching for Kevin Collins an interview with filmmaker Andrew Kappel 30:46

3M ago30:46

30:46

Interview with filmmaker/creative producer Andrew Kappel. Through his experience in true crime with shows on Investigation Discovery one case has stayed with him. The 2/10/1984 disappearance of Kevin Collins. Kevin was one of the first child disappearances that appeared on milk cartons & the front of National publications. Andrew discusses what he …

1
Appalachian Goliath-The Tale of Tennessee's Strongest Man 10:46

3M ago10:46

10:46

Step into the world of Appalachian giants with the incredible tale of Joseph Jefferson Copeland, known to all as Big Joe, the strongest man in Tennessee. In this episode of Stories of Appalachia, Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins bring to life the legend of a man whose feats of strength and size became the benchmark for tales of might in the 19th century…

1
Executed Without Answers LaRette Trailer 2:24

4M ago2:24

2:24

Trailer--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/maryanne-mccullough/support

1
The Punch Jones Diamond, Appalachia's Hidden Gem 13:03

3M ago13:03

13:03

In this captivating episode of Stories of Appalachia, we delve into the lucky discovery that forever altered the lives of a father and son in Monroe County, West Virginia. Join Steve Gilly and Rod Mullins as they recount the day in 1928 when a simple game of horseshoes unearthed a treasure that would remain hidden in plain sight for 15 years. Hear …

1
Shawna Beth Garber update Suspect Talfey Reeves has been identified (deceased November 15,2021) 30:41

4M ago30:41

30:41

Shawna Beth Garber’s case has had renewed interest with independent investigators considering links in her case to Dennis Rader. To keep the victims not the perpetrators visible in media we are sharing her case, facts from the Macdonald County Sheriff’s Department, Othram Inc’s tireless efforts for justice & to restore Shawna’s name. Recently a new…

1
Anthony LaRette: Executed Without Answers 1:10:55

4M ago1:10:55

1:10:55

This podcast examines Serial Killer Anthony Joe LaRette Jr who was executed November 29, 1995 for the murder of Mary Fleming in St Charles, Missouri. Before he was executed he confessed to over 30 murders. 15 of which have been solved. Through network collaboration of resources can we bring answers to families of the other victims? Request invite t…

1
The Hanging Judge's Executioner 15:07

4M ago15:07

15:07

Discover the fascinating tale of George Maledon, the legendary hangman for Arkansas' Hanging Judge Parker, and his peculiar path to Tennessee's Mountain Home veterans cemetery. Uncover a piece of Old West justice on our latest podcast episode. Be sure to subscribe to the Stories podcast...we're on Spreaker, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Audible or where…

1
Executed Without Answers: Serial Killer Forgotten 52:19

4M ago52:19

52:19

Serial Killer Anthony LaRette murdered 18 year old Mary Fleming on July 25, 1980. Once captured Anthony LaRette made an acquaintance with Detective Patricia Juhl from Pinellas Florida. Their friendship unearthed LaRette’s secrets. Murders that spanned the United States. Many in Kansas where he was currently residing. The murder of Tracey Miller of …

1
Insinuation A DOC-U-Series 2:58

4M ago2:58

2:58

Insinuation is a DocUSeries hosted by myself MaryAnne with the Social Detective & Deborah Norman host of @dying2bfound we’ve combined our academic & background knowledge in crime investigations to delve into flaws in our justice system. Discuss how the everyday insinuations on social media, neighborhood chatter & throughout school systems can affec…

1
The 1970 Hurricane Creek Mine Explosion 10:38

4M ago10:38

10:38

Today we tell the story of the deadliest mine disaster in Eastern Kentucky history, the explosion in shafts number 15 and 16 at Hurricane Creek near Hyden, Kentucky. The Stories podcast is on Spreaker, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Audible or wherever you get your favorite podcasts. Be sure to subscribe! Thanks for listening and for sharing our stories …

1
Frontier Justice: Russell Bean and Andrew Jackson 15:36

4M ago15:36

15:36

Russell Bean was the son of William Bean and his wife, Lydia, the first people to settle in what's now Tennessee and for whom Bean Station is named. Russell, considered the first child of European descent to be born in the future Tennessee, was a large, strong man with a temper who most folks avoided that temper came to a boil. Andrew Jackson was a…

1
The Greene-Jones War 22:22

4M ago22:22

22:22

In the 1880s and 1890s a bloody feud was happening across two Appalachian counties, with conflicts over hogs, shootings, ambushes, cabins set on fire and the threat of the governor to call in the state militia to stop it. This feud was NOT between the Hatfield and McCoy families in Kentucky and West Virginia. This one was about a hundred miles to t…

1
The Kingdom of the Happy Land 12:47

5M ago12:47

12:47

After the Civil War, as the South lay in ruins, a group of freedmen decided to depart the Mississippi plantation on which they had been held as slaves in search of a promised land. They found it...in the mountains of Appalachia. Come along with us as we tell the story of one of the first successful black communities in the south, the Kingdom of the…

1
Billy Dean Anderson: Appalachia's Most Wanted Outlaw 12:11

5M ago12:11

12:11

Billy Dean Anderson was born in Fentress County, Tennessee, and, by all accounts, lived a normal law-abiding life as he grew up, even becoming a volunteer preacher in his church. Then it all went horribly wrong. He and some other men held up a theater in Jamestown, beginning a life of crime in two states. He eventually made the FBI most wanted list…

1
Amos Owens: The Cherry Mountain Moonshiner 18:02

5M ago18:02

18:02

After the Civil War a young man bought Cherry Mountain in Rutherford County, North Carolina and used the wild cherries found there to add flavor to his distilled product, illegal of course, that became a runaway hit. Not only was his distinctive "Cherry Bounce" popular in his part of Appalachia, but it was also the favored beverage on riverboats fr…

1
Dr. John R. Brinkley: The Goat Gland Doctor from Appalachia 38:00

5M ago38:00

38:00

John Romulus Brinkley was born in Burnsville, North Carolina, to a former Confederate medic and his housekeeper. From those humble beginnings young Brinkley grew up to become a traveling "Quaker doctor," a medical huckster and conman in both Knoxville, Tennessee and Greenville, South Carolina, a student at several "eclectic medical schools," a succ…

1
The Tragic End of Outlaw Joe Brown 9:35

6M ago9:35

9:35

Joe Brown was a hell-raiser, thug and violent alcoholic who terrorized the town of Whitmer, West Virginia at the turn of the 20th century. He did, that is, until he went a step too far. That, folks, is our story today. Be sure to subscribe to the Stories podcast on your favorite podcast app so you don't miss any of our stories of Appalachia. Thanks…

1
Rachel Pratt Missing In Garden City (Special Guest Patrick Hassen. Not Adding Up Podcast 1:13:58

6M ago1:13:58

1:13:58

We were planning on releasing an update on the anniversary of Rachel’s disappearance however we’ve been struck down with a respiratory virus. I’ve lost my voice. Until that is released please refresh yourselves with Rachel’s case. Share your thoughts on our Reddit Kansas Cold Cases. Let’s make this the year Garden City Police find information on Ra…

1
The 1921 West Virginia Capitol Fire 13:16

6M ago13:16

13:16

On January 3, 1921, a massive fire broke out at the West Virginia state capitol in Charleston. Not a big deal, you might be thinking, fires happen all the time. This one, though, had a twist or three, as you'll find out. Be sure to subscribe to the Stories podcast, at Spreaker, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube Music, Audible or on your favorite pod…

1
The Tragedy at the Cowee Tunnel 11:47

6M ago11:47

11:47

On December 30, 1881, 30 convicts, along with their guards, were shackled and deposited on the banks of the Tuckaseegee River near Dillboro, North Carolina, with a job to do: cross the river in a boat and then start digging out the Cowee Tunnel for the Western North Carolina Railroad. 19 of the 30 didn't make it across alive. Today we tell that tra…

1
3 of Clubs Tawnya Knight Kansas 41:07

6M ago41:07

41:07

Tawnya Knight vanished on December 6, 1996 in Spring Hill Kansas. Her remains were located 6 months later. Her case is shrouded in lies & insinuations. Those falsehoods possibly cost the investigation as well as the family evidence & answers in Tawnya’s case. @serialnappernik https://coldcasechronicles.com/tawnya-knight https://www.facebook.com/jus…

1
Bettie Simms, The Queen of the Moonshiners 13:49

6M ago13:49

13:49

In the early 1900's a young mother in Polk County, North Carolina, had a decision to make. She had separated from her abusive husband and had several young children to feed, house and clothe, with very few job prospects. So she started her own business...moonshining. Bettie Simms was good at that chosen profession but, as so often happens, she had …

1
Unanswered Scream: The Case Of Stacey Colbert 26:51

7M ago26:51

26:51

On March 24, 1998 a family member of Stacey's contacted the Columbus Police Department as they had not been able to contact Stacey for a couple of day's and she had not reported to work. Her apartment was found to be unlocked with no evidence of a burglary or theft. Neighbors reported to the police that on the evening of March 22, 1998 they were aw…

1
Appalachian Christmas Traditions 11:13

6M ago11:13

11:13

With Christmas fast approaching, Rod and Steve talk about the history and the folklore behind Christmas in Appalachia... You can subscribe to the Stories podcast at Apple Podcasts, Spotify, PlayerFM, Spreaker, Audible or on your favorite podcast app, whatever that might be. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year, y'all!…

1
Tinker Dave Beaty, Union Guerrilla/Outlaw 17:22

7M ago17:22

17:22

David Crockett Beaty was a farmer in Fentress County, Tennessee...until the start of the Civil War. He became a guerrilla fighter in that war, on the side of the Union, with his most well-known rebel counterpart being Champ Ferguson, with whom he had a running war all its own. Today we tell the story of Tinker Dave Beaty, Union guerrilla/outlaw. Be…

1
Missing Corey Dean Williams 14:52

7M ago14:52

14:52

Corey Dean Williams was last seen by friends/acquaintances in Upshur County Texas on 07/27/2022 at approximately midnight when he left in his vehicle, 1995 white Mercury Cougar. On 07/28/2022 Williams's vehicle was located stuck in the sand and abandoned in Upshur County, Texas. Upshur County Crime Stoppers posted that they will give up to a $1,000…

1
The 1902 New River Coal Strike -The Battle of Stanaford 12:47

7M ago12:47

12:47

In 1902 coal miners struck the mines along the New River, seeking better wages and better working conditions. The strike continued until February 25, 1903, when a massive gun battle broke out between miners and coal company men, including detectives from the Baldwin-Felts agency and local law enforcement. The battle was fierce, with both sides exch…

1
The Fentress County Witch 10:27

7M ago10:27

10:27

In 1843 a prominent man in Jamestown, Tennessee, distributed a broadsheet, under an assumed name, accusing the wife of a tavern owner of being, among other sordid things, a "witch of the most extraordinary power." That, as you can imagine, led to legal action in the Fentress County courts. Today we tell the story of the Fentress County witch, anoth…

1
Predators With Badges 31:35

7M ago31:35

31:35

Police sexual misconduct is second to excessive use of force in complaints against officers. The rise of serial sexual predators with badges calls for greater oversight within our institutions as well as a more stringent screening process. https://www.hutchnews.com/story/news/crime/2023/05/22/former-hutchinson-police-officer-sentenced-to-23-12-deca…

1
Orlean Hawks Puckett. Appalachian Granny Woman 14:03

7M ago14:03

14:03

Granny women were the healers and caretakers of folks in Appalachia, dispensing folk remedies, serving as midwives, and even dousing for water. These women were essential in rural Appalachia, where doctors and hospitals were scarce. Today we tell the story of one of these women, Orlean Hawk Puckett, from Carroll County, Virginia, known for being a …

1
Unsolved Murder Of Jodie Bordeaux 11:07

8M ago11:07

11:07

On November 21, 1997, at approximately 12:43 AM, Jodie Bordeaux home was assaulted with gunfire leaving the pregnant 28 year old dead. Reports show that Jodie had recently fired an employee from the Golden Eagle Casino, the first casino on the Powhattan reservation. Authorities believe alcohol was a factor. 26 years later distrust between reservati…

1
Baker-Miller Pink, Psychopaths & The Psychology of Color 28:10

8M ago28:10

28:10

Still having issues editing in the @spotifyforpodcasters link & app. Apologies!! In the late 1960s, Alexander Schauss studied psychological and physiological responses to the color pink. In 1979 the Santa Clara County Prison attempted to replicate the study & it went off the rails. We expound on that study what is the connection between Baker-Mille…

1
The Wood chipper murder of Helle Crafts 37 years later. 16:40

8M ago16:40

16:40

Hey guys! I want to apologize for the audio. I’ve contacted @spotifyforpodcasters about my editing issues but they still weren’t resolved & I wanted to get this episode out. Hope it isn’t too unbearable. Cheers! On November 19, 1986, Helle Crafts went missing. For a few weeks, the police were looking for her. They gathered evidence, wrote search wa…

1
Behind The Investigation 42:03

8M ago42:03

42:03

Update. Error in my recording partner’s podcast name. 🤦🏻‍♀️ Deb’s podcast name is @Dying2bfound please check out her podcast as well!! Be a part of our 100Th episode! Our interview with Deb @Dying2bfound as we dive deeper into our 34 year search for answers in our neighbor & friend Krista Martin’s murder. How are we feeling with the questions still…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Andrew Garber Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide