Best Scary Savannah Podcasts (2024)

1
The Phantom of Ridgeway 24:16

5h ago24:16

24:16

This week our computer died on us - so we had to get it fixed. Unfortunately that means we weren't able to record this week's episode - but so that we don't leave you without content, we're going to release one of our Patreon episodes! In this episode we talk about the infamous spector known as the Phantom of Ridgeway, who can be found in the small…

1
Family Tragedies 43:42

3h ago43:42

43:42

Kelly and Thomas Crain had one child left living with them, 14-year-old, Alex. It was the same for Alan and Diane Johnson, with 16-year-old Sara. Neither set of parents would know their time together would be cut short, and at the hands of their own children. Join us as we discuss these similar cases, with different motives, but they are equally sa…

1
Carly Ryan 54:43

1d ago54:43

54:43

Carly Ryan was a sweet and fun loving 15 year old living in Stirling, Southern Australia. She loved to spend time online, especially chatting with her special friend, 18 year old Brandon Kane. Or so she thought. It turned out that Brandon was not everything he said he was and sadly, Carly fell victim to a deceitful online predator named Gary Newman…

1
Tybee Island Police Blotter 3/18/24-3/31/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach 23:16

2d ago23:16

23:16

In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, there's a rash of headlight violations, and even a serious encounter for one of Tybee's finest. Hate ads? Check out our newly revamped Patreon page! You can …

1
Michael and Susan Nobley 50:59

9d ago50:59

50:59

Michael and Susan met in college and both majored in international business. After graduating they married and became quite the power couple. Then one day they disappeared and were found in their submerged car in the everglades. What happened to the Nobley's? Sources: www.naplesnews.com www.tampabay.com www.brandenton.com --- Send in a voice messag…

1
Ep. 89: Bigfoot: Is He Real? And Is He Vegan? 1:15:50

9d ago1:15:50

1:15:50

This week we set out to discover the origins and lore of Bigfoot, and include some eyewitness accounts of their experiences with the elusive (possibly vegan) creature. On What We’re Watching we talk about the 1972 classic “The Legend of Boggy Creek.” On Layla and Coffee Talk, we talk about Coffee getting slowed down by an injury. Find us on the web…

1
Siam Lee 36:00

16d ago36:00

36:00

Siam was a 20 year old, aspiring teacher and traveler. She was trying to make money to go to school when she became a sensual masseuse, and started advertising on an adult booking website. I was through this website she met a dangerous predator. Join us as we discuss this case. Sources: https://www.news24.com/news24/insider-in-siam-lee-case-found-m…

1
Tybee Island Police Blotter 3/4/24-3/17/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach 31:46

24d ago31:46

31:46

In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, there’s a machete, women missing some clothing (if you know what I mean), and some stolen vehicles. Find us on the web: https://www.scarysavannahandbeyond.co…

1
Karen Winslett and Annette Huddle 52:05

23d ago52:05

52:05

21 year old Karen Winslett and 19 year Annette Huddle were both beautiful and smart young women in the primes of their lives. Unfortunately, they came across a man who was charming but had evil intentions, and they both lost their lives to him. After 7 years on the run, Paul Steven Mack was convicted of Karen’s murder, and later confessed to Annett…

1
Ep. 88: The 1979 Ghost Train Fire, Sydney, Australia 44:51

1M ago44:51

44:51

This week we dive into the mysterious unsolved fire at an amusement park on the Syndey Harbor, Luna Park. What caused the fire on the ride “The Ghost Train”, taking the lives of seven people. Was it arson? Or faulty wiring? Or a discarded cigarette? Or something more sinister? On What We’re Watching we talk about the television show “Ghosted", star…

1
Glenys Heyward 43:24

1M ago43:24

43:24

Glenys Heyward endured mental and physical abuse at the hands of Neil Heyward for 20 years. When she finally chose to leave him and claim a portion of the business and property she helped make successful, Neil planned her murder and used her children to help him. Please join us as we discuss this heinous crime. Sources: Inside Crime Season 2 Episod…

1
Tybee Island Police Blotter 2/19/24-3/3/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach 22:00

1M ago22:00

22:00

In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, there’s contraband at the rest home, a disaster for the parade, and a little news story out of Savannah. Find us on the web: https://www.scarysavannahandbeyo…

1
Mark Himebaugh's Disappearance 1:04:37

1M ago1:04:37

1:04:37

Mark Himebaugh was an 11 year old boy living in the small community of Del Haven, New Jersey. He mysteriously went missing near his home in November of 1991, and has never been seen again. Did Mark fall victim to a drowning accident? Was he abducted? Did he run away? The family and investigators believe that someone knows something. Where is Mark? …

1
Ep. 87: Spirits in the Ozarks, The Crescent Hotel, America’s Most Haunted Hotel 1:05:52

1M ago1:05:52

1:05:52

This week we explore the history of the spirits that haunt America’s most haunted hotel, the Crescent Hotel & Spa in Eureka Springs, Arkansas. On What We’re Watching we talk about the television show Ghosts: UK Version. On Layla and Coffee Talk, find out how our producers feel about our new green screen set up. Find us on the web: https://www.scary…

1
Episode 203: The Green Lady 33:30

1M ago33:30

33:30

Tonight Joe Rotondo joins us around the fire to tell us a story originating from Burlington, Connecticut. It's a tale of love and longing from beyond the grave, and ghostly spirits of possible good intention. This is the story of The Green Lady. Tonight's Charity: The Spina Bifida Association Find Joe Rotondo on... Instagram: @joetondo His Stories …

1
Brian Barrett 39:49

1M ago39:49

39:49

Brian Barrett was a 22-year-old aspiring teacher. He excelled in baseball in high school and every one loved Brian. Brian's only mistake was befriending Thomas Montgomery, a co-worker of his, and Talhotblond, a gamer on a gaming website. A love triangle begins, and Brian is the one who turns in a victim. Join us as we discuss this case, which has a…

1
Tybee Island Police Blotter 2/5/24-2/18/24 Updates From Savannah's Beach 24:50

2M ago24:50

24:50

In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, the odors continue to emit, and people love pulling out in front of officers with said odors. Find us on the web: https://www.scarysavannahandbeyond.com Plea…

1
Ep. 86: Is Jimmy Hoffa on a Golf Course in Savannah? 46:46

2M ago46:46

46:46

This week we dive into the mysterious disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa, and its possible ties to Savannah. Find out if Crystal can make it as a 1950s housewife. On What We’re Watching we talk about the 2024 disaster of a game that’s supposed to be a Super Bowl. On Layla and Coffee Talk Crystal experiences more rat-related trauma, and the girls get new …

1
Savannah Smith 40:16

2M ago40:16

40:16

Savannah Smith was a happy 8 year girl, playing with her friends and family in and near her home in 2006. Sadly, she trusted a young man with horrific intentions that no one saw coming. She was later found brutally murdered in a nearby town. Thankfully, her soulless killer will remain behind bars and out of society for the remainder of his life. Bu…

1
Julie Kibuishi and Sam Herr 39:19

2M ago39:19

39:19

Julie was a student studying fashion, at Orange Coast College, where she met Sam Herr, a war veteran who went back to school after returning from war. Julie and Sam had the misfortune of befriending, Daniel Wozniak, who also lived in the same apartment complex as Sam. Daniel was in financial trouble and decided his only way out was to hurt his frie…

1
Tybee Island Police Blotter 1/15/24-2/4/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach 33:01

2M ago33:01

33:01

In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, someone checks out of their room and thinks the TV is a complimentary gift, because Tybee. Find us on the web: https://www.scarysavannahandbeyond.com Hate ad…

1
Winner announced for our "Mystery at Hunter's Lodge" Game! 2:28

2M ago2:28

2:28

We announce the winner of our board game giveaway contest! Thanks for everyone who entered and keep listening as we're going to be doing more giveaways. Find us on the web: https://www.scarysavannahandbeyond.com Hate ads? Looking for extra content? You can get ad-free listening through Patreon! Plus additional other content, not on our main feed. P…

1
Ep.5: Grammys, Taylor Swift, El Paso Paranormal High and the Defoors Murder 57:49

2M ago57:49

57:49

Hello W.T.F Fans! Kristen and Sydney here, excited to bring you another thrilling episode. In this latest installment, we dive into a diverse array of topics. We get into the Grammys and why the media is dragging poor Taylor Swift. We also have another compelling 'Am I the Asshole' story straight from Reddit. Plus, we're shedding light on two fasci…

1
Larry McNabney 1:11:56

2M ago1:11:56

1:11:56

Larry McNabney was a charismatic, successful, and wealthy attorney in the Sacramento, California area. He was also well known in the quarter horse showing circuit. In September 2001, Larry went mysteriously missing. His wife, Elisa, and her best friend, Sarah, attempted to keep the law practice running in his absence. When Elisa also went missing, …

1
Ep. 85: Leonarda Cianciulli the Soap Making Cannibal 1:10:46

2M ago1:10:46

1:10:46

This week we’re going really dark with a story from the early 20th century exploring Italy’s first female serial killer. Trigger Warning - Listener Discretion advised. On What We’re Watching we talk about the 2024 show “Death and Other Details.” On Layla and Coffee Talk find out why Crystal is still traumatized over a gift that Coffee brought her. …

1
Ep.4: Nicki Vs. Meg, Who Murdered Strawberry & The Vanishing of Mary, The Bride 1:11:15

2M ago1:11:15

1:11:15

Hello W.T.F Fans! Kristen and Sydney here, excited to bring you another thrilling episode. In this latest installment, we dive into a diverse array of topics. We get into the Nicki vs Meg beef and why Generation Z aging like spoiled milk. We also have another compelling 'Am I the Asshole' story straight from Reddit. Plus, we're shedding light on tw…

1
Sierah Joughin 47:52

2M ago47:52

47:52

Sierah and Josh met when they were little and became high school sweethearts. in 2016, Sierah was 20 years old and going into her junior year of college and was on summer break. Sierah rode her bicycle to see Josh one evening. Josh rode his motorcycle next to her for a few miles, but then let her finish the rest on her own. She never made it home. …

1
Tybee Island Police Blotter 1/1/24-1/14/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach 31:04

3M ago31:04

31:04

In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week it’s the mystery of the missing golf cart - and an officer kicks a door in half. Find us on the web: https://www.scarysavannahandbeyond.com Hate ads? Check ou…

1
Ep2: Vivica vs Taraji, LGBT Atlanta Hate Crimes and Who Killed Rey Rivera? 1:25:29

2M ago1:25:29

1:25:29

Hello WTF Fans! Kristen and Sydney here, excited to bring you another thrilling episode. In this latest installment, we dive into a diverse array of topics. Explore the internet inspired beef between Vivica A Fox and Taraji P Henson. We'll also share a compelling 'Am I the Asshole' story straight from Reddit. Plus, we're shedding light on two fasci…

1
Ep.3: Whispers of the Vanished: The Enigmatic Stories of Nicole and Arianna Fitts and Shy'kemmia Pate 1:06:00

2M ago1:06:00

1:06:00

Hello W.T.F Fans! Kristen and Sydney here, excited to bring you another thrilling episode. In this latest installment, we dive into a diverse array of topics. We get into Rap Shit being cancelled... WTF? Nikki Haley playing every field but the right one and Donald Trump and his cult followers. We also have another compelling 'Am I the Asshole' stor…

1
What Happened to Sean Daugherty? 57:08

3M ago57:08

57:08

Sean Daugherty was a happy, smart 12 year old boy who had just arrived home from a wonderful vacation with his family. One ordinary afternoon in April of 2022, Sean was found hanging from the family’s swingset in the backyard. His death was quickly assummed to have been a suicide, but here are many details and aspects that do not line up. Sean’s fa…

1
Ep. 84: Masterminds? The Infamous Loomis Fargo Heist of 1997 1:34:23

3M ago1:34:23

1:34:23

This week we’re talking about a true crime story out of Charlotte, North Carolina. The Loomis Fargo heist was one of the biggest robberies in the history of the nation, with around $17 million dollars being stolen in total. Another interesting fact - all of this went down where we used to live (we’re both originally from North Carolina, Gaston Coun…

1
Survival of Kristie and Earleen 25:42

3M ago25:42

25:42

Embark on a riveting journey with our latest episode as we share two incredible survival stories that prove courage knows no bounds. In the chilling winter of January 1999 in Manassas, VA, 14-year-old Kristie faced a nightmarish intrusion that changed her life forever. The heart-wrenching tale unfolds as an intruder brutally murders her sister, lea…

1
Tracy Cusick 37:27

3M ago37:27

37:27

Tracy married Kenneth Cusick, and the two and Tracy's son, became a family. Tracy and Kenneth added a daughter to their family. Years later, Tracy would be found unresponsive with her her head in a toilet bowl after a fight with her husband. Did Kenneth have anything to do with this or did Tracy have too many drinks and drown in the toilet. You dec…

1
Tybee Island Police Blotter 12/18/23-12/31/23 Updates from Savannah's Beach 42:25

3M ago42:25

42:25

In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week someone is passing counterfeit money - Brett thinks it’s from a Monopoly board game. Find us on the web: https://www.scarysavannahandbeyond.com Hate ads? Chec…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Scary Savannah Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Quick Reference Guide