X-Men: The Xtreme Review (Original Trilogy)

Zealots of Nerd Entertainment

What if the X-Men trilogy you cherished as a kid isn't as flawless as you remember? Our latest episode dives deep into the original X-Men movies, with special guest Talos Gundam, to explore how these films that once shaped our childhoods hold up today. We start with X-Men 1, which was revolutionary in its time but now feels somewhat mid-tier. Moving forward, we celebrate X-Men 2 as the gem of the trilogy, while we can't help but pick apart the storytelling missteps of X-Men 3, often humorously referred to as "The Last Damn." We'll also ruminate on the potential for future remakes and the crucial need for Marvel to stick to established storylines and character integrity.
Next, our conversation shifts to a critical examination of character development, starting with Cyclops. We critique how the films portrayed him as weaker and less significant compared to his comic book counterpart. Other powerhouses like Nightcrawler, Quicksilver, and Xavier also get scrutinized for their diminished roles, leading to narrative inconsistencies. Rogue's character portrayal sparks a heated debate about missed opportunities and the creative decisions that left fans wanting more. Additionally, we touch on the attempt to rectify Cyclops' untimely death in Days of Future Past, positioning it as an unofficial fourth installment of the trilogy.
Finally, we spotlight X-Men 2, praising iconic scenes while lamenting the underutilization of characters like Colossus. Wolverine's portrayal and the complex power scaling of mutants, including the Omega and Alpha levels, come under the microscope. This leads us to the disappointing execution of the Dark Phoenix saga and the mishandling of character abilities, such as Kitty Pryde's role in Days of Future Past. We wrap up by reflecting on the trilogy's highs and lows and previewing upcoming discussions on the prequel quadrilogy, Wolverine movies, and Deadpool films. Tune in for a nostalgic yet critical exploration of the X-Men universe!

Text us for feedback and recommendations for future episodes!

Support the show

We thank everyone for listening to our podcast! We hope to grow even bigger to make great things happen, such as new equipment for higher-quality podcasts, a merch store & more! If you're interested in supporting us, giving us feedback and staying in the loop with updates, then follow our ZONE Social Media Portal!
DISCLAIMER: The thoughts and opinions shared within are those of the speaker. We encourage everyone to do their own research and to experience the content mentioned at your own volition. We try not to reveal spoilers to those who are not up to speed, but in case some slips out, please be sure to check out the source material before you continue listening!
Stay nerdy and stay faithful,
- J.B.
Subscribe to "Content for Creators" on YouTube to listen to some of the music used for these episodes!

Chapters

1. X-Men: The Xtreme Review (Original Trilogy) (00:00:00)

2. X-Men Trilogy Review (00:00:01)

3. Character Development in X-Men Films (00:15:52)

4. Exploring X-Men Characters and Storylines (00:20:46)

5. X-Men 2 Review and Analysis (00:38:10)

6. The Disappointing Portrayal of Dark Phoenix (00:51:21)

7. X-Men Films (01:05:33)

8. X-Men Characters and Plot Critique (01:15:57)

9. X-Men Trilogy Review Conclusion (01:29:08)